Antonio Brown’s stats were as solid as they’ve ever been in 2018. He finished among the NFL’s top 11 in catches (104), yards (1,297) and touchdowns (15), numbers that square nicely with his reputation as one of the game’s premier receivers.
Still, it felt like his “WiFi” connection with quarterback Ben Roethlisberger was just a bit off at times. The explosive plays that seemed so effortless for the pair in the past would go missing for noticeable stretches. For every vintage performance — 185 yards on 14 catches against New Orleans, for example — there was a dud like his five catch, 35-yard effort in an embarrassing loss at Oakland two weeks prior.
Your eyes weren’t deceiving you. Advanced statistics from analytics website Football Outsiders suggest Brown did considerably less with his opportunities this season than he has in the past.
If you’re a baseball fan, you’ve probably heard wins above replacement, or WAR, tossed around a lot in recent years. The stat is the product of a complex calculation aimed at estimating a player’s offensive and defensive value in one number, expressed as wins contributed to the player’s team compared to what an easily-acquired “replacement” player might produce over the course of a season. If you’re unfamiliar, you can read more about the methodology here.
Football Outsiders produces a similar number: defense-adjusted yards above replacement, or DYAR. With consideration given to the quality of opposing defenses, its goal is to estimate how many yards — or equivalent value in first downs, touchdowns, and turnovers — a player produces for his team beyond what a run-of-the-mill backup might in similar situations.
You can read more about the methodology here, but the important thing to know is that DYAR attempts to separate quality from volume. Any receiver can be targeted 160 times in a season, for example. DYAR is an estimate of how much more the best receivers produce with their opportunities.
Read More
Brown had been among the NFL’s best in this category before 2018, ranking no worse than seventh in the league in any year from 2013 to ‘17. He topped the ranking with 554 DYAR in 2014, 517 in 2015 and 430 in 2017.
In 2018, his 191 DYAR was good for just 19th. Not only was he beaten out by teammate JuJu Smith-Schuster (235 DYAR), he also produced less than half of top receiver Tyler Lockett’s total of 464 and came in behind second-tier names including Detroit’s Kenny Golladay (250) and Green Bay’s Davante Adams (246.)
The news gets worse, too. Football Outsiders also produces a stat called defense-adjusted value over average, or DVOA. It “represents value, per play, over an average receiver in the same game situations,” and it returns an even more damning verdict.
Brown’s DVOA was estimated at a mere 1.7 percent in 2018. That number places him a startling 41st in football and represents a substantial drop over past performance. He ranked 11th at 20.1 percent last year and posted numbers no worse than 11.1 percent from 2013 until this year.
Football Outsiders is quick to point out that a low DVOA isn’t necessarily bad in and of itself.
“By definition, an average level of performance is better than that provided by half of the league and the ability to maintain that level of performance while carrying a heavy workload is very valuable indeed,” the website writes in its explanation of its statistic. (You can read it in full here.)
Translation: Brown was far from a liability overall. He was reliable while carrying a heavy workload of 168 targets. The problem for the Steelers is that they’re used to getting much more out of him.
And lest you think Roethlisberger is an equal part of the problem, his numbers in the same categories were relatively stable. He ranked fifth among quarterbacks with 1,208 DYAR in 2018. That figure is as good or better than the figures he’s posted in every season since 2014, when he led the league with 1,572 DYAR.
Really, it’s only Brown that’s taken a noticeable step back in the past year.
We can only speculate about the reasons why. One could be personal strife with the quarterback that’s bubbled into public view since Brown was benched for the season finale against Cincinnati for skipping practices and meetings in the week prior. Another could be the continued emergence of Smith-Schuster as a favorite target of Roethlisberger’s. It could also be a simple case of age catching up to the soon-to-be 31-year-old.
Regardless, these stats suggest Brown’s behavior shouldn’t be the only factor as the Steelers weigh whether to trade Brown this offseason. If another team is willing to pay a premium to acquire him because of past production, the Steelers may be wise to take the deal, as there’s reason to believe the value of the return could eclipse Brown’s if his diminished excellence in 2018 becomes a trend in the future.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.