Antonio Brown has spent the past few weeks drawing a lot of comparisons between himself and Jerry Rice, the legendary former receiver he frequently refers to as the “GOAT,” short for “greatest of all time.”

If you believe Pro Football Reference’s similarity scores, he may be flattering himself a bit. Rice isn’t among the 10 players that website ranks as the most similar to Brown using a formula that seeks to add context to modern players’ statistical profiles by comparing them to past’ players production, as opposed to style.

That’s far from a knock on Brown. There are a lot of very good receivers on his comparables list. There are also trends running through it that are important to keep in mind as the Steelers enter an offseason of uncertainty about whether team and player will move forward together after a well-publicized falling out at the end of 2018.

The most obvious is rapid decline or departure from the game entirely. Of the 10 players on the list, six — Wes Welker, Bob Hayes, Herman Moore, Lance Alworth, Chad Johnson and Roddy White — experienced steep drops in production at age 32 or earlier. Two others — Sterling Sharpe and Calvin Johnson — retired at or before Brown’s current age of 30.

Advertise with us

Only Rod Smith and Julio Jones, a younger contemporary, don’t fit in that group, suggesting Brown’s shelf life may not be as long as he or whatever team employs him in 2019 may hope.

Welker, in particular, could be a cautionary tale for Brown, as his decline coincided with a move to a different team. His age 31 season with New England was superb, as he posted 1,354 yards on 118 receptions. A year later with Denver, his numbers nosedived to 778 yards on just 73 receptions. One comparison does not a trend make, but it’s a good one to highlight among the group of them given Brown’s apparent desire to leave Pittsburgh for greener pastures.

They may, in fact, not exist, something a lot of the players on the list seemed to recognize. Eight either played their entire careers for one team or played just one season elsewhere before retiring. The two who aged best stayed with their original teams the longest.

Smith was the model of consistency. He played 12 seasons in Denver and posted a 1,100-yard season there as late as age 35. He never quite reached the heights that Brown has, but he never really struggled to produce until his final season a year later either.

White’s decline wasn’t quite as graceful — he fell from 1,351 yards at age 31 to 711 at age 32. But his 921 yards at 33, his 10th season with Atlanta, were more than any player on the list besides Smith at that age or older.

Advertise with us

Add them up and these trends suggest that Brown and the Steelers may be better off together than they are apart. Despite his infamously strict workout regimen, potential suitors may be leery of giving up too much to acquire a receiver whose best days are more than likely behind him. This may leave the Steelers receiving less in offers for Brown than they may feel they deserve,

The receiver, meanwhile, may find that a trade thrusts him into a less-than-ideal situation in which his production could suffer quite a bit. Certainly there have been plenty of examples of receivers having impressive second acts — think Randy Moss and Terrell Owens — but that success is far from a sure thing, especially in a trade situation where the player doesn’t get to pick his destination.

Team president Art Rooney II has said the Steelers won’t make any decisions on Brown’s future until March. The time between now and then may be well spent seeing if cooler heads can prevail on both sides.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.