Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lucius Allen and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
mgmervosh, @ariba21mgm: Is replay ruining The Fan Experience? Especially if you're sitting in the stadium waiting and waiting.
Starkey: Good morning, Mr. @ariba21mgm. Allow me to commend you on an excellent question, and let us start with this: On the NFL’s list of priorities, the fan sitting in the stadium is very low — no matter what Roger Goodell might tell you.
The fan sitting at home, eyeballs glued to the television, is the one that counts.
It wasn’t the guy swilling beer in Section 114, after all, who gave the NFL $3.3 billion for the rights to “Thursday Night Football.” That was Fox, and that was Fox counting on millions of eyeballs glued to televisions, even for replay delays. Maybe especially for replay delays, which I would argue have become an indispensable and enjoyable part of America's football-watching ritual — even if fans love to complain about them.
The replay delay is a game show. It is “Jeopardy” or “Family Feud” in football form, and anyone can play. We all watch the disputed incident from every conceivable angle, at every conceivable speed. We are given just enough time to argue about it and register an opinion. And we all want to be right.
Read More
Did Julian Edelman’s thumb touch the football? We don’t have to know anything about the game to weigh in. We just do. And then we wait for the game-show host (the official) to tell us the answer.
Meanwhile, officiating fiascos like the missed interference call in the Rams-Saints game are good for the league, as well.
What do you think everybody was talking about around the proverbial water cooler Monday? The NFL, that’s what. We will complain and rage about the officiating and how the league has to do something. But we will watch.
Will we ever, as this nugget from the Hollywood Reporter proves: “CBS' primetime coverage of the AFC Championship, in which the New England Patriots beat the Kansas City Chiefs, 37-31, averaged 53.9 million viewers, making it the most-watched conference title game in five years.”
Long live the NFL. The NFL is king. Especially on TV.

Scott Hemphill, @Scott_Hemphill: How do you feel about the no-call DPIs in ChiefsvPats after Joe Haden was called for lightly brushing the receiver's backside 2 seconds before the ball came down?
Starkey: In Chiefs vs. Pats? I’m focused more on the NFC game, Mr. Hemphill — and I feel like the Football Gods dispensed a bit of justice to the New Orleans Saints.
The Saints might not have played at home in the NFC title game if not for the horrendous call on Haden (and a highly questionable one later in the game). So I don’t want to hear all the whining. How about score in overtime after you are blessed with a coin-toss win? How about stop the Rams late in regulation?
Gary Morgan, @garymo2007: If the Pirates’ payroll stays at or near projected, $71M, is there any real argument to be made that they are “trying”?
Starkey: No.
Jared Starks, @JaredStarks33: What has been wrong with Casey DeSmith? Ever since he signed his contract extension, he has played very poorly, a la Chris Boswell.
Starkey: Maybe L.J. Fort will rip him on Twitter, Mr. Starks (nice name, by the way).
Listen, I wouldn’t worry about this. It’s only been two starts since DeSmitty signed his contract, and even if he has given up 10 goals on 58 shots, no goalie would have stood a chance the way the Penguins played in Vegas the other night. It was like a breakaway contest. The Golden Knights had three of those in the first period alone, several other odd-man rushes and a two-on-none break in the third. It was ridiculous.
That being said, DeSmith did his best work when he was playing regularly. Getting used to sporadic backup duty is a different animal — and one DeSmith must conquer.
mikedojcak@gmail.com: Joe, Is there any truth to the rumor that the Pirates are looking to move the Pirate Parrot for some younger, Minor League talent?
Starkey: If that would get their payroll closer to zero, then yes.
Brettski, @Cutch_22: The countdown begins! Under a month until Daytona! Who has the best shot this year?
Starkey: I’m going with A.J. Foyt or Danica Patrick.
BustedLockerPodcast, @bustedlocker: When the Patriots beat the Rams in the Super Bowl, will that put them on equal footing with the Steelers (6 Super Bowl wins each), or will they have surpassed them as greatest dynasty/franchise we’ve ever seen?
Starkey: Greatest dynasty and greatest franchise are separate questions, Mr. @bustedlocker.
The Steelers winning four Super Bowls in six years would still stand as the greatest dynasty of the Super Bowl era because … THEY WON FOUR SUPER BOWLS IN SIX YEARS.
As for greatest franchise, the Patriots, by virtue of what they will have accomplished in the 21st century — six Super Bowl wins — will equal the Steelers (of course, they still have to play the game).
I mean, that’s the ultimate leaderboard, right? Most Super Bowl wins.
God, I wish the Bills had one.
Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.