Alejandro Villanueva stuffed belongings from his locker into a large, black garbage bag, breaking only to talk about the Steelers’ fortunes, which really wound up in the trash.
As distasteful as 2018 was for Villanueva and his Steelers teammates, it did not end with the Ferrari going over the cliff as it did a year earlier.
“We saw this coming; it was an easy death,” Villanueva explained one day after the Steelers were eliminated from making the playoffs. “It wasn’t a tragic loss in the playoffs. It was as easy to put down as possible. We knew there was a very small chance of us going into the playoffs. We knew we were in a hole and we put ourselves in a very bad situation.”
So while the end to 2018 came with a whimper, the noise as they move toward 2019 could be explosive. There will be changes, Mike Tomlin promised without specifying who or what. He made his first on Friday when he fired Joey Porter as outside linebackers coach.
They do not need to overhaul the product — BetDSI Sportsbook, for one, already has them tied as the No. 2 favorite to win the Super Bowl next year. But they need to improve it, both by talent and creating an atmosphere where winning supersedes all else, including the selfishness that may have helped bring them down.
They have two major orders of business first: Pass on tagging Le’Veon Bell for the third time, and explore a trade for Antonio Brown. Unthinkable a few years ago, those decisions actually should be easy now. They started the ball rolling toward their 2018 disappointment by giving Bell the franchise tag again last year. He held out until six days before the start of the 2017 regular season, and they misjudged badly his intentions for 2018. Let him go and collect that third-round draft pick in 2020 for him.
Read More
They will need to add another good running back either through free agency or the draft to add to the mix of James Conner and Jaylen Samuels. That would give them a solid backfield again and, perhaps, one more immune to an injury. With another good back, they could abandon the idea of using primarily one player to carry the ball and spread things around as many other successful offenses do.
They cannot trade until the new NFL season begins March 13, when free agency also starts. But they can explore trades before then and should do so for Brown. If so, they would need to replace him, and that’s where the difficult part comes.
They can use some of his $15 million in salary and bonuses that won’t be paid or count on their cap to sign another receiver and/or draft one.

Brown has been a spectacular receiver for them, but it’s time they move on as he turns 31. Despite his baggage and age, he has three years left on his contract and should fetch a first-round draft pick.
That would put the end to the Killer B’s with only Ben Roethlisberger back, which is the biggest reason the Steelers are still highly regarded as a Super Bowl contender.
He does not need to be surrounded by stars. Brown, Bell, and Martavis Bryant never won a Super Bowl. Roethlisberger needs competence at receiver.
They would do well to feature tight end Vance McDonald even more. The guy is a brute, and while he did catch 50 passes for 610 yards, he has Rob Gronkowski-like ability to do more. With JuJu Smith-Schuster, an improved James Washington and the receiver who replaces Brown, the Steelers will have at least an adequate receiving corps that also includes backs Conner and Samuels.
The Steelers won Super Bowls with less.
Their offensive line will remain among the strongest in the league even if they lose Ramon Foster and part ways with Marcus Gilbert. Both could return because Gilbert is under contract and Foster, who turns 33 Monday, might be amenable to re-signing with them at a fair price rather than test free agency. If both leave: Matt Feiler performed well at right tackle in Gilbert’s long absence, and B.J. Finney is a starting guard in waiting but a restricted free agent.
Improving the defense, which has been ongoing for years, will be more difficult.
It is an annual statement that the Steelers need another cornerback, but they may need more than one. Artie Burns was benched for much of the season, and unless something changes there, he’s not much in their plans. Joe Haden enters the final year of his contract. Coty Sensabaugh, who replaced Burns unspectacularly, will be an unrestricted free agent. Others have not shown they are capable of stepping in.
Then there are the linebackers. They need a bunch — starters and depth. After T.J. Watt, all are replaceable, and some should be.
They have not adequately replaced Ryan Shazier but must keep trying. It has become obvious that Bud Dupree is not the next James Harrison. Although they committed to paying him $9.232 million when they picked up his fifth-year option for 2019, they are not bound by that. He would not make near that on the open market if they withdrew it. They could negotiate a multi-year contract for him at a much lower price.
Anthony Chickillo, their only backup for most of the season at outside linebacker, is an unrestricted free agent, as is L.J. Fort, their most reliable inside backup.
Tyson Alualu and Daniel McCullers, the only two backups they used regularly on their defensive line, also will be unrestricted.
What the Steelers need on defense are playmakers, defensive backs who intercept passes and others who not only force fumbles but know how to recover them. Not forcing turnovers may have been the biggest factor that kept them out of the playoffs.
They must decide on whether to re-sign punter Jordan Berry and what to do with kicker Chris Boswell, who is due a $2 million signing bonus in March. Pay that and have him compete with Matt McCrane, or just move on without Boswell?
There are changes every year, but when the Steelers don’t make the playoffs, especially after 13-3 last season and high expectations for 2018, making those changes are easier. A few more coaches may join Porter and go as well, but they made a bunch of coaching changes last season and that didn’t help the bottom line.
Soon, Mike Tomlin will find one of those large, black garbage bags like Villanueva’s and start using it.
Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com and Twitter @EdBouchette
Editor’s note, Jan. 4, 2019: This story has been updated to reflect news of Joey Porter’s firing.
Ed Bouchette and Gerry Dulac on Mike Tomlin's season-ending conference



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.