The Steelers had the Saints over a barrel twice in the final minutes of the game. The Steelers had the Saints in second-and-20 and third-and-20 on consecutive plays when they led by four with less than two minutes remaining. In each instance, the Saints had wide open receivers finding holes in the secondary.

Saints rookie Keith Kirkwood dropped the first pass from Drew Brees after he ran across the field with slot corner playing off and trailing him in man coverage. On the third-and-20, the Steelers played zone, and Brees threw a 25-yard completion to Ted Ginn Jr.

Ginn did not have a defender within five yards of him when he caught the ball.

“We didn’t cover the things we wanted to cover,” defensive coordinator Keith Butler said. “We jumped some things we probably didn’t want to jump. They had some guys in position that looked appealing for us to jump, and we did. We didn’t miss a coverage. We just didn’t play it the way we probably should have played it. We could have coached it a lot better than we did.”

Advertise with us

A few plays after the Saints converted the third-and-20 they scored the go-ahead touchdown. It was one of many late drives the Steelers defense gave up at the end of games in the past month. The Chargers drove for a winning field goal. The Broncos and Raiders drove for touchdowns in the waning moments of those games.

As a result, the Steelers need help in order to make the playoffs.

Butler didn’t name names, but a review of the video showed rookie safety Terrell Edmunds jumping an underneath route on the second-and-20.

On the third-and-20, safety Sean Davis and cornerback Coty Sensabaugh both ran with the vertical toward the end zone route while Ginn ran a post past the first-down marker.

“We have to do a better job of making sure our guys are in tune with the [first-down] sticks and what they’re trying to do,” Butler said. “That third-and-20 hurt us a little bit, but I don’t know if it beat us in the end. It did beat us, but the penalties hurt us quite a bit, too. Our guys played hard. They were trying to be competitive. They probably needed to cover a little bit better.”

Advertise with us

The pass defense has been a major issue this season. The Steelers were the fifth-ranked pass defense last season. This season they’re 16th and giving up 41 yards more per game through the air.

After three years of steady improvement under Butler, the defense regressed in almost every statistical category this season.

The Steelers were 18th in the NFL in scoring defense (points allowed) and total defense (yards allowed) in Dick LeBeau’s final season. Under Butler, the Steelers made steady improvement in each of his first three seasons. The Steelers shot up to 11th in points allowed in Butler’s first season, then 10th in 2016 and seventh last season.

The Steelers also improved in total defense every year after his first season. After dipping to 21st in 2015, the Steelers improved to 12th and then fifth last season.

Entering the regular-season finale against the Bengals, the Steelers are 15th in points allowed and ninth in yards allowed. They have given up 347 points, an average of 23.3 points per game, a full four points more than last season. If they give up another 23 points Sunday, it will match the 370 points they allowed in 2013, which is the highest for a Steelers defense since they gave up 421 in 1988.

Advertise with us

Despite those telling statistics, Butler believes his defense got better as the season went along.

“I think they’ve been more competitive, yes, especially with the last two teams we played,” Butler said. “We felt like they were two of the better teams in the league. If we could hold our own with those guys, we’d prepare ourselves to get into the playoffs. That hasn’t changed. We’ll try to win this one and see what happens with Cleveland.”

And in spite of the numbers, Butler said this defense is some ways is better than the defense that finished near the top of the league in so many statistical categories last year.

“I think we do stuff a little bit better, yeah, I think we do,” he said. “There are some guys who weren’t with us last year who are getting better. But we’re not good enough. We are what we are.”

In the end, Butler knows he will be evaluated on his team’s inability to make those late stops against the Chargers, Broncos, Raiders and Saints. If the Steelers win any of those four games they’d be in the playoffs rather than counting on the Browns to beat the Ravens on Sunday.

Advertise with us

“We have to stop them in critical situations,” Butler said. “Whoever gets the ball last, you have to stop them. In some of the critical games we lost, we didn’t.”

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.