Ed Bouchette & Gerry Dulac preview the Steelers-Browns Week 8 matchup
The Steelers have a problem at cornerback? Stop the presses (which most of their cornerbacks actually stopped doing long ago as a way to play defense).
The Steelers having trouble at cornerback is like saying the Browns can’t win on the road. It’s endemic. This is nothing new. It goes back more than 30 years for the most part to a fellow named Harvey Clayton.
As his first name might suggest, Harvey was invisible on the field, but he was their starting cornerback in 1985 and 1986, two of the more dreadful seasons under coach Chuck Noll. Clayton became known as Little Harvey Clayton both because he was 5 foot 9, 179 pounds and because of his play at cornerback.
One day near the end of Clayton’s brief career with the Steelers, his agent publicly asked them to trade him. Art Rooney Sr., the Chief, was so tickled by the request that he told a reporter he wished the agent could come up with an NFL team that would actually give something for Clayton.
But don’t blame Clayton, whose son Harvey Clayton Jr. plays defense at Duquesne University. Clayton Sr. may have gotten every last drop out of his talent, but it just wasn’t enough to become a good NFL cornerback. Blame it on the Steelers, who had little talent at cornerback on those teams. It was a far cry from the days of Mel Blount, Glenn Edwards and Ron Johnson in the 1970s. It is a conundrum that continues to this day: Why can’t the Steelers find good corners?
Over the past 38 years, the Steelers have had one cornerback make the Pro Bowl. One. Rod Woodson did it seven times with them, but no one else since Blount made it for the fourth time for the 1979 season. Both players are in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, so maybe the next Steelers cornerback to make a Pro Bowl will follow in their footsteps.
Read More
Joe Haden is a two-time Pro Bowl cornerback, both of those with the Cleveland Browns, and he is playing like he will make it for a third time. The Steelers were lucky to have him fall in their laps. Maybe that was one good turn to help make up for all the bad luck at the position through the years.
Pursuing a trade for Arizona’s seven-time Pro Bowl cornerback Patrick Peterson was pure fantasy, as it turns out.
But why can’t the Steelers draft good cornerbacks? They have drafted players who went to Pro Bowls at every other position but that one. Ike Taylor, Chad Scott, Dwayne Woodruff and Dewayne Washington were among some good cornerbacks who played for them through the years, but none made a Pro Bowl.
Scott and Artie Burns were the only two cornerbacks the Steelers drafted in the first round over the past 30 years, or since Woodson in 1987, and Burns is fighting to keep his starting job this season. He did not start against Tampa Bay in the third game of the season as the coaches tried to light a fire under him. He has since alternated every two series with Coty Sensabaugh.
Besides drafting them, the Steelers have signed free agents and traded low picks for cornerbacks, but until Haden dropped out of the sky just before the start of the 2017 season, they found little by going either of those routes.
Since Mike Tomlin took over as coach in 2007, the Steelers have drafted 14 cornerbacks. They deemed only one good enough to sign to a second contract, William Gay, the first cornerback drafted under Tomlin as a fifth-round pick in 2007.
There were some real clunkers among those 14 drafted cornerbacks, including two more recent misses in 2015, Senquez Golson (second) and Doran Grant (fourth).
Gil Brandt has some theories. One of two nominees and a likely election to the Pro Football Hall of Fame in February as a contributor, Brandt headed the Dallas Cowboys player personnel department from 1960 to 1988 and has served as a draft expert for NFL Media for years.
“One of the things happening, high schools and colleges are now taking the best athlete or fastest guy and putting him at wide receiver,’’ Brandt noted, “and we’re not having the guys like Mike Haynes as shut-down corners. Those guys are now playing offense.”
And it’s just more difficult to evaluate those cornerbacks in college.
“It’s hard because we play so much different,’’ Brandt said of the NFL. “We play so much press coverage and they’re off coverage in college. I don’t think there is the quality of player they play against like we have to do in the NFL. The player now, the receiver you’d have to cover is unbelievable.
“Remember also the old ways when you could engage the guy all the way down the field as long as he was in front of you. You could do everything but karate chop him. Now you can only do that for five yards.”

Blount holds the Steelers record with 11 interceptions in a season and Woodson once had eight. They are in the Hall of Fame, but would it be too much to ask one of the Steelers corners to get more than two or three interceptions in a season? You have to go back to 2004 to find one who did, when Deshea Townsend picked off four in 2004. The only other cornerbacks with more than three in this century were Scott in 2001 and Washington in 2000, each with five.
Mind you, this even though the Steelers consistently have ranked among the best defenses in sacking the quarterback and in an era where those quarterbacks are throwing the football like never before, although much more accurately.
“The quarterback play in some way affects this whole thing,’’ Brandt noted. “We have quarterbacks now completing 92 percent, 88 percent and so forth in games. Drew Brees I think is up over 75 percent right now [77.3 this season]. It’s just hard for these guys.”
Yet 10 NFL players already have three interceptions this season, two of them rookie cornerbacks, Denzel Ward of Cleveland and Donte Jackson of Carolina. Ward was the fourth overall pick in the draft. Jackson, hailed as one of the best young corners in the NFL, was a second-round pick by the Panthers, five spots before the Steelers drafted wide receiver James Washington.
The Steelers have four interceptions as a team. Cornerbacks Mike Hilton, who has become a good slot man, and Cam Sutton have one apiece.
Maybe Burns will find himself and join Haden as a Pro Bowler some day. Or maybe the Steelers will have to keep searching for just their second one in nearly 40 years.
Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com and Twitter @EdBouchette



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.