The Talk of Fame Network, which is associated with the Pro Football Hall of Fame, has been doing a series of shows on the same topic:

The best player not in the Hall of Fame for each team.

As a guest the past week, they asked me to select one former member of the Steelers who deserves it most. My answer: There is not just one.

Alan Faneca’s credentials already should have put him in Canton. This will be his fourth year of eligibility. Faneca’s nine Pro Bowls and six first-team All-Pros stand up well against any guard in the Hall of Fame, and he will one day make it, possibly when we vote again the day before the Super Bowl.

Advertise with us

Troy Polamalu will soon follow after he becomes eligible next year. It is a crime that Hines Ward has not reached the final 15 in his two years of eligibility, but for all of his accomplishments and his unique play at the position, his receiving numbers may just not be enough to convince voters he’s deserving.

But of those Steelers who have been eligible for a long time and have not made it, here is my list of those who should:

L.C. Greenwood, Andy Russell and Donnie Shell as players, Bill Nunn as a contributor. The players now fall under the seniors category.

Greenwood was a disruptive defensive end in the days before quarterback sacks were regarded as THE key stat for 4-3 ends. He made six Pro Bowls and was selected as a member of the NFL 1970s All-Decade second team. He was a six-time finalist (final 15) for the Hall and is one of only five defensive players of the 22 on either the first or second All-Decade teams not to be inducted.

Many of the great defensive fronts in NFL history have at least two players in Canton. The Steel Curtain, perhaps the greatest, has one: Joe Greene.

Advertise with us
Joe Greene puts a pass rush on Browns QB Brian Sipe in 1979. (Albert Herrmann Jr. / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Andy Russell made seven Pro Bowls, several for Steelers teams that were not so super — 1968, 1970 and 1971 seasons. He was a rookie in 1963 and then served two years in Germany as a second lieutenant in the U.S. Army before rejoining the Steelers in 1966.

Myron Cope, who preceded me as the Hall of Fame selector from Pittsburgh, strongly believed Russell was overlooked when he was a modern day candidate. There has been a big push from local advocates for Russell as a seniors candidate over the past year, and his candidacy has strengthened because of it.

Shell earned five Pro Bowl trips and three first-team All-Pro selections. He finished with 51 interceptions, most ever by a strong safety when he retired after the 1987 season. Strong safeties are not ball vacuums the way free safeties can be, yet Shell was both a big-time hitter and a ball magnet.

Gil Brandt, the former Dallas Cowboys personnel director and current NFL Media analyst, picked his top 32 safeties of all time, both strong and free. Brandt, a contributor nominee this year who likely will be voted into the Hall of Fame himself in February, chose Shell as his 14th best safety ever, behind his No. 13, Polamalu, who is considered practically a shoo-in for the Hall.

Nunn, who was selected this year to the Steelers Hall of Honor, is as much a reason they won those four Super Bowls in the 1970s as any single player. That’s because he found those players, dug them out of small black colleges when few others were even looking their way.

Advertise with us

Nunn was a sports writer and then managing editor of the Pittsburgh Courier in the 1960s when that paper had a national edition. He picked a black college All-American team and knew virtually every coach in that world. The Steelers hired him as a part-time scout in 1967 and full-time after Chuck Noll was hired in 1969.

He found players like Greenwood, a 10th-round pick in 1969 from Arkansas State, and Shell, undrafted in 1974 from South Carolina State. Among others who came from those small schools: Mel Blount (’70) of Southern University, Ernie Holmes (’71) of Texas Southern, Joe Gilliam (’72) of Tennessee State, John Stallworth (’74) of Alabama A&M and more.

It’s one impressive list during a time when the NFL largely overlooked those schools and players. Nunn helped propel the NFL into creating its own civil rights era and should be a strong candidate for the relatively new contributor’s ballot for the Hall of Fame.

One sticking point that has hurt Greenwood, Russell and Shell is the number of players already inducted from those great Steelers teams of the 1970s. There are nine players, Noll and Dan Rooney. After we elected John Stallworth in 2002, one selector told me, “Don’t think we’re now going to put in that safety, too,” meaning Shell.

Stallworth was the last one from that dynasty to be inducted. One of those three may make it as a seniors candidate some day, but that also could hurt the other two from ever going in.

Advertise with us

The next good Steelers era produced four in the Hall of Fame — Rod Woodson, Dermontti Dawson, Kevin Greene and Jerome Bettis, who straddled two eras, that of the 1990s and the next one in the 21st century.

Besides Polamalu, this current era also could send a handful to Canton — Ben Roethlisberger, Antonio Brown, maybe Le’Veon Bell and Maurkice Pouncey/David DeCastro. Winning another Super Bowl also might help them.

Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com