It has not happened before, not since both came into the league and emerged as the two greatest receivers of their generation. It is a classic matchup of talent, eye-popping athleticism and incredible sustained production. It is Rafael Nadal and Roger Federer, Sidney Crosby and Alex Ovechkin, LeBron James and Steph Curry.
Antonio Brown, the most productive receiver in NFL history the past five seasons, and Julio Jones, who is right behind him, meet for the first time Sunday when two underachieving teams — the Steelers (1-2-1) and Atlanta Falcons (1-3) — play at Heinz Field.
Former Dallas Cowboys personnel director and long-time talent evaluator Gil Brandt called it “a duel between the two heavyweight wide receivers.”
While the game itself has a number of similar story lines — big-time quarterbacks, explosive offenses and accommodating defenses that allow more yards than all but 27 other teams — the most fascinating and intriguing similarities exist with Brown and Jones.
Brown is the reigning AFC offensive player of the year and the No. 2-ranked player on the latest list of the NFL’s Top 100 players, behind only Tom Brady. Jones is a three-time Pro Bowler who averages more than 100 yards receiving a game since 2014.
Curiously, the only game Jones did not play in 2014 was against the Steelers, the last time the teams met in the regular season. Too bad, too, because Brown put on a show — 10 targets, 10 catches for 123 yards — in a 27-20 Steelers victory.
Read More
That sets up what could be an entertaining first-ever meeting between receivers who sit at or near the top of the league every year in receptions and receiving yards.
“Julio’s got the height, he’s got the speed, the guy is an extraordinary hard worker,” Brandt said. “When we see guys who do what Brown has done, it’s meaningful.”
Jones is off to his usual start, leading the NFL with 505 yards receiving after four games, a pace that would allow him to become the league’s first-ever 2,000-yard receiver. Brown, though, has not been his usual dominating self, lacking big plays despite 29 catches and three touchdowns, which, surprisingly, is three more than Jones.
Falcons coach Dan Quinn is not dismissing Brown’s slow start.
“I guess it’s the speed, the explosiveness he has,” Quinn said. “For a long time I have been impressed by his ability to stop, start, he has a stiff arm, he can make you miss. He has double moves. Not on track? He is an excellent player.”

Two of a kind
Since Jones came into the league in 2011, a year after Brown, the dynamic duo have done their best to outdo the other, creating a debate as to which is the better receiver.
On paper, Jones’ prototypical size (6-foot-3, 220 pounds), speed (4.39) and freakish athletic ability make him the ideal choice, the type of receiver NFL coaches and general managers fawn over at draft time. That’s why he was the sixth overall selection in 2011.
“He’s big and he’s fast and he’s quick,” said Steelers defensive coordinator Keith Butler. “Usually you don’t have that many characteristics of a good wide receiver. Most of the time they’re not as big and they’re quick and run good routes. But this guy’s got it all.”
While Brown’s size (5-10, 190) and speed (4.47) do not match Jones’ measurables — witness his sixth-round selection in 2010 — his production is not only greater than Jones, it’s unmatched in NFL history.
Since 2011, Brown has more receptions (736 to 614), receiving yards (10,015 to 9,556) and touchdowns (62 to 43). While Brown has played 11 more regular-season games (100 to 99), Jones averages more receiving yards per game (96.5 to 91), more yards per catch (15.6 to 13.4) and more 100-yard games (41 to 37).
The numbers aren’t much different in the postseason. Since 2011, Brown has appeared in seven playoff games and averages 106.7 yards per game; Jones has played in eight postseason games and averages 104.3 yards per outing. Jones has two more touchdowns (6 to 4) in the postseason.
But it’s really over the past couple years where the tandem has put up dizzying numbers.
Brown is the first player in NFL history to have five consecutive seasons with more than 1,000 receiving yards. He led the league last season with 1,533 yards despite missing the final two games with injury. He has the most receptions in any two-year (262), three-year (375), four-year (481) and five-year period (582) in league history.
In the past four seasons, Jones has averaged over 100 yards receiving per game, and this year is no different. He leads the NFL with 505 yards receiving on 29 catches after four games, a pace that would allow him to eclipse Calvin Johnson’s record 1,964 receiving yards in 2012. Jones is the only player in NFL history to have three games with at least 250 receiving yards.
Their ascension as the best two receivers in the league was impressively illustrated in 2015 when Brown and Jones tied for the league lead in receptions (136) and Jones edged out Brown for the league lead in receiving yards (1,871 to 1,834).
Last year, Brandt, who goes back to 1960 as vice president of player personnel for the Cowboys, placed Brown No. 5 on a list of his all-time greatest receivers, behind Lance Alworth, Randy Moss, Don Hutson and Jerry Rice.
“Antonio Brown is a guy, in my estimation, who’s very talented, is a great competitor and is on the right team with a quarterback who knows how to get the ball to him,” Brandt said. “Whether it’s a cross route or a quick screen, he’s mad if he doesn’t get the ball and he’s mad if he doesn’t get 10 yards.”
But through four games this season, some of that hasn’t been happening.

Slow start
Brown remains the favorite receiver of quarterback Ben Roethlisberger, who has targeted him 53 times through four games — second most in the NFL.
Brown, though, has only 29 catches, meaning his catch rate per target is 54.7 percent. That is below last season’s rate of 61.9, when he was the NFL’s second-most targeted receiver (163) behind Houston’s DeAndre Hopkins (174), despite playing one fewer game. Brown and Hopkins tied for most targets per game at 11.6.
Maybe more troubling is Brown is averaging just 9.4 yards per catch and doesn’t have a reception longer than the 27-yard catch-and-run touchdown he had in Tampa two weeks ago. That is the second-lowest average among wide receivers with more than 22 catches, leading many to wonder about the disconnect between the franchise’s most lethal passing combination of all-time.
After leading the league with 27 catches of at least 20 yards and seven of 40 or more yards, Brown has just three catches longer than 20 yards this season — all touchdowns.
“I think I just have to play better to help him get his numbers, which would help get us wins,” Roethlisberger said.
“Usually over the course of the journey the cream rises and they’ll show what they’re capable of,” coach Mike Tomlin said. “They’ve done it for a long time. We’ll find a rhythm, they’ll find a rhythm, they’ll be the formidable tandem that they always are.”
Offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner said Roethlisberger and Brown talk all the time about routes and concepts, despite a perception the two don’t often speak.
“They do, and they work hard,” Fichtner said. “Not that they’re trying to do anything that’s not normal. Usually a lot of balls go his way; a lot of balls have been going his way now. We just haven’t hooked up on them. I think they’re coming though.”
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.