Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Bake McBride and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Dave Smith1, @DaveSmith2519: Should Conner get more playing time than Bell when he shows up???
Starkey: Huh? James Conner is having a decent exhibition season. Le’Veon Bell, through his first 60 games, had more yards from scrimmage than ANY PLAYER IN NFL HISTORY. That includes, as I’m sure you’re well aware, Mr. Smith, names such as Jim Brown, Barry Sanders and Walter Payton. Yet we now have Pro Football Talk’s Mike Florio wondering if the Steelers might rescind Bell’s franchise tag because Conner has looked pretty good on 19 preseason carries and a few catches? Dear God.
Listen, I get it: Bell wasn’t up to par early last season. Neither was anyone else, including the quarterback and Martavis Bryant (who had been off for more than year). Plus, the Steelers played an elite run defense (Vikings) in Week 2. It wasn’t just Bell.
John Texas, @JohnTexas9: How many snaps should Conner get Week 1?
Starkey: That is a more reasonable question, Mr. JohnTexas19, although the bar was shorter than Ryan Switzer. And I’m not sure Conner is doing anything unexpected. This is precisely what any reasonable person should have expected out of him when the Steelers made the pick.
Read More
Don’t get me wrong: I’d love to see Conner get more reps. In fact, I’d love to see him in the backfield, with Bell split wide, when the Steelers advance deep into the red zone — say, first-and-goal from the 8. Let’s see how many of those pass defenders, spread across the field to cover receivers, want a piece of Conner.
Conner had four of the Steelers’ 17 rushing attempts in last year’s opener against Cleveland. I wouldn’t mind seeing him get about a quarter of the carries in Cleveland again this year — although I’d like that number to be more like eight of 32. Plus a few catches. That sounds like a reasonable plan to me.
— Now to our immensely popular Twitter Polls segment, in which our hero, Mullsy, presents the following question. Nearly 1,700 respondents voted.
Joe Starkey doesn't like the Ryan Switzer deal -- he loves it. How do you feel about it?
— Chris Mueller (@ChrisMuellerPGH) August 27, 2018
What we learned: That a surprisingly large number of fans were nonplussed. On the other hand, a full 64 percent either liked or loved the deal. I love it. I think Switzer gives the Steelers not only a full-time return man who can change a game but also some interesting possibilities on offense, in the slot or as a gimmick guy. Somebody to keep defenses honest, as all he needs is a sliver of daylight. I’m not sure why he didn’t pan out as a receiver in Dallas or why Jon Gruden was not a fan. Sometimes a player just needs the right environment. If you have any doubts about Switzer’s abilities, check out what he did against Washington last season:
Or just remember how he tortured Pitt, right here (is that a clip on No. 35?):
And here …
OK, rapid fire …
Bryan, @Bryan_PGH: 5 best QBs to never win a Super Bowl
Starkey: I am considering only those who were in their prime in the Super Bowl era …
5. Fran Tarkenton
4. Warren Moon
3. Dan Fouts
2. Jim Kelly
1. Dan Marino
Dan Klimko, @kliminator: Was Dan Sickles a hero or a goat?
Starkey: Fair question, Mr. @kliminator — and I didn’t realize Sickles killed Francis Scott Key’s kid in a fit of a jealous rage until your question sparked some research. He seemed angry. He also had only one leg. And a complicated Civil War legacy.
Can I get back to you on this?
Larry, @HeartSeanLeahy: I have a question, why are they breaking up you and Mullsy (Mullsey)? Seems unnecessary. Especially since you guys have a great give-and-take relationship on air. Makes no sense to us listeners. @937theFan
Starkey: I honestly don’t know, Larry.
Rhino, @Rhinosteel6: Will you still play the Buffalo song for the new show, or will that be retired?
Starkey: We’ll see. I’m guessing Cookie isn’t a big fan. Which might make it imperative. BTW, the name for the show is officially “The Cook & Joe Show.” I like that. But I wanted us to add Mullsy and call it “Two Men and a Baby.”
Colin, @Cashner412: Who is your early Penguins darkhorse to have a breakout year?
Starkey: Believe it or not, Mr. Cashner412, my pick is Olli Maatta. I still believe there is an entirely new level for him to reach. He is only 24 (just turned last week). He has played remarkably well for a man who has been through so many physical challenges. I think another offseason of unfettered training, combined with his smarts and talent, could lead to a 15-point bump in scoring. I’m looking for a breakout year.
John Popovic, @jmpopovich72: Is Ryan Switzer Barry Switzer’s grandson?
Starkey: No. Are you Gregg Popovich’s?
Dave Hrinak, @DaveHrinak: How did you decide to move to Pittsburgh?
Starkey: It was November of ’89 (that’s 1989), and I was drawn by tales of a young basketball phenom in the north suburbs of Pittsburgh. Kid they called “Mullsy.”
Thank you. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.