Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Let's get started.
Jonathan : The WR room gets even more crowded with Switzer. Has Tonkin finally found his return specialist?
Ray Fittipaldo: Could be a strong possibility he returns punts. Cam Sutton has worked there in practice and preseason games. he fumbled on Saturday against the Titans. I'm assuming he's also the fifth or sixth WR instead of someone like Griffey, Tucker or Patterson. Reading into the trade, I guess they just weren't all that excited about any of those three.
Larry "The Mooch" Howard: Hey y'all! Does this rumored trade for Switzer mean Henderson, Toussaint, and anyone else looking to specialize in returning kicks is gone? What about Marcus Tucker?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not good news for Tucker, that's for sure. I have to look into Switzer's background more and find out if he returns kicks too and if he does it well. I do know he averaged 20.9 yards per punt return in college. He was a fourth-round pick of the Cowboys last year and was dealt to the Raiders in the spring.
Bill: i love the idea of a Le’Veon Bell trade for Khalil Mack. Mack would have a greater impact on the entire defense than Bell has on the offense. Mack would fit with the Steelers’ history of defense and pass rush. What are your thoughts? Is it feasible?
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: I would do it if Mack could be signed to a long-term deal. Actually, both sides would have to know long-term deals could be done before that happened.
CoalportKid: So Ryan Switzer a Steeler. Who is out?
Ray Fittipaldo: As I mentioned previously, not good news for Tucker, Griffey or Patterson. If Switzher impresses it might not be good news for Eli Rogers. But if he doesn't impress, Rogers just takes his places when he comes off IR.
jumbo: hey Ray love the chats, what's your take on this year defense? are we going to be pleasantly surprised with this group or will we have growing pains this year?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think the secondary will be better, but I am concerned about the inside linebacker position. So I think some aspects of the defense could be better, but I don't think the defense will be among the best in the league or anything like that.
Kurtis: Ryan Switzer!?!? Has to be end of Tucker, Henderson, Griffey and Rogers?
Ray Fittipaldo: Rogers is going to start the year on IR. Can be activated after six weeks... But for the rest you mentioned? Yes, not good news for them.
Craig B: Z Banner looked dominant and nasty to me. What say you?
Ray Fittipaldo: Practice squad material if you ask me, if that.
CoalportKid: Can we assume after Saturday's second half that Samuels has the team made?
Ray Fittipaldo: I have him on my 53-man roster projection. Close competition with Ridley and Toussaint. But Samuels did play well against the Titans and Ridley has been injured so I went with Samuels.
jumbo: any chance boz is cut to save money?
Ray Fittipaldo: Huh? They just signed him to a new contract. He's one of the best kickers in the league.
JoeB: Any idea what they are giving up for Switzer? What did Oakland give Dallas for him?
Ray Fittipaldo: Can't imagine it would be anything more than a seventh-round pick. But I haven't seen the compensation yet.
Larry "The Mooch" Howard: What's next in terms of a trade? OT? TE? OLB? ILB?
Ray Fittipaldo: All of the above? Seriously, there are some depth concerns at all of those positions. You just can't address them all with trades. Maybe with roster additions after other teams make cuts.
Ryno: Odds Wile ends up making the team?
Ray Fittipaldo: 30-70. I wouldn't be all that surprised, but I still give a slight edge to Berry.
Cole: Do you think James Conner will get playing time and meaningful carries once LBell is back?
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe 1 or 2 more a game than last year but they are paying Bell $14.5 million. He's going to get touches galore.
Ryno: Was there a specific reason Dobbs didn't play even one series Saturday?
Ray Fittipaldo: He will play plenty Thursday. Likely the majority of the game.
The Binnzer: Has number 46 done enough to be kept on the 53? He sure has speed and can move out there.
Ray Fittipaldo: I have him on my 53-man roster. Based on the way the Steelers coaches used him Saturday it seems like they are looking for ways to get him on the field, or at the very least, find out for sure if they want to keep him. He has speed and athletic ability. He looked very comfortable out there with the starters.
Rico: My weekly Ola question...has he done enough to make the roster?
Ray Fittipaldo: I have Ola on my 53-man roster over Adams and Huguenin. Wouldn't be surprised if they kept Adams or Huguenin and got Ola onto the practice squad. I just think he's been the more consistent performer this summer. I do understand, however, that he is 20 and is a good candidate to learn on the practice squad.
Steelmann58: why trade for a WR is Washington injury Serious
Ray Fittipaldo: As of right now, I don't get that sense. Washington told me his injury was not serious Saturday after the game.

Larry "The Mooch" Howard: Which rook will crack (earn) the starting lineup first: Matthew Thomas, Edmunds, Washington (does 3rd WR count as a starter?), or Wile?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's a really good question. I say Washington but I would not be surprised if Thomas over Bostic happens at some point during the season. And Edmunds has a shot to start at some point too.
Steelmann58: Ray what are the final spots you think the Steelers can search outside on cut down date to add
Ray Fittipaldo: OLB, ILB, TE, OT
Jonathan : Is Matthew Thomas the No. 3 inside linebacker now?
Ray Fittipaldo: Seems that way. Matakevich and Fort are good special teams players, but I don't know that they trust them as ILBs.
SteelCity: Think the hybrid def with Edmunds will end up being base def?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not the base, no. But he should play in subpackages.
Kurtis: Matthew Thomas showed ability to make some plays defensively and on ST. Do you think we can cut loose Matekavich
Ray Fittipaldo: Possibly but Danny Smith likes him on teams too. I had them keeping five ILBs in my roster projection. But I could see Matakevich or Fort being cut to be honest with you if they don't want to keep five ILBs.
Jimmy G: I know it’s probably difficult to call it at this point, but in your estimation, how does Randy Fichtner’s play calling differ from Haley’s?
Ray Fittipaldo: Way too early to tell. He's not calling games now like he will during the regular season.
JJ: With the speed we have added defensively, will we be able to play more man to man, and if so, will we ?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think that is in their plans, yes. But we'll see if it happens.
DC: What are the odds that the Steelers put Bell on roster-exempt status for the first two weeks of the season, or pull the tag entirely?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not good.
Ernie jamison: Hi ray, is there a chance on God’s green earth that we could sign and trade bell for Mack in the emergence of Conner. And is it true we could cut Dupree and save his 9m if that were to happen?
Ray Fittipaldo: Dupree isn't making $9 million this season. That's next season (if they keep him and if they don't do a long-term deal with him.
Larry "The Mooch" Howard: Could we see the Steelers line up with both Bell and Samuel splitting out in a short yardage situation?
Ray Fittipaldo: That would be intriguing. Lots of possibilities for Ficthner to consider.
Solidsteeler84: Did Thomas improve his stock enough to start at ILB?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know about starting just yet, but I have him making the team.
Kool-Aid: Hi Ray, Do you think McCullers ability to make the 53 man roster is attributed to Coach Dunbar or is Frazier just not that good?
Ray Fittipaldo: Can't say at this point, but there hasn't really been a big push by any fringe DL in camp, including Frazier.
ET: think Edmunds will be the starter before Burnett’s 3 year contract is up?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, of course. He'd be a failed first-round pick if that did not happen.
rob: what's your best guess on the status of mcdonald for week 1. and james
Ray Fittipaldo: They are practicing now. I'll have a better idea after today or tomorrow. They need to get some of these guys healthy.
Jonathan : Have you seen enough of Sean Davis at FS to think he will be good for the job?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not but the coaches have said he'll be better there. I guess I'll take their word for it until I see him play there during the regular season.
Ryno: The interception and returned by Edmunds on Saturday looked amazing. To me it looked like he showed ridiculous athleticism and amazing speed. Has he been making plays like that on a regular basis during training camp? If so, this guy could be the real deal.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, he's been making plays most of camp. And he's had a lot of opportunities because Morgan Burnett has dealt with injuries.
Jimmy G: Based on your roster projections, you don’t seem to trust Chuks to man the swing tackle role. Is there something specific you’ve noticed lacking in his game? Or could just use a little time to grow and develop?
Ray Fittipaldo: They didn't draft him thinking he'd be ready for that role. Jerald Hawkins was going to be the swing tackle until he got hurt. So I just think they'll bring a veteran in and let the young guy develop without rushing him into a situation he might not be ready for.
Larry "The Mooch" Howard: I like Chickillo and Matekevich, but don't feel like either has earned a roster spot. While both are solid on STs, they're not productive position players. Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Chickillo is the only experienced reserve among the OLBs. That's why he's on my 53. And I have Matakevich on their because of his special-teams ability. But as I stated before, I would not be surprised if Matakevich is cut.
J from Akron: Do you see any scenario where Bostic gets cut? I know they just signed him this offseason, but he does not look impressive at all.
Ray Fittipaldo: Cut? Probably not. But lose his starting job? Yes at some point.
MauiMike : Are the no huddle rumors true ? Do we know if that’s per Ben’s request? I’ve always thought they operated better giving him the ropes
Ray Fittipaldo: Not rumor at all. Ben Roethlisberger told Ed Bouchette about it. Whether they follow through or not is anyone's guess, but I wouldn't categorize it as a rumor.
Jonathan : Potentially 3 draft picks are in danger of not making the 53, would that be considered a bad draft or does it not matter if 2 or 3 guys hit?
Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't say that. Maybe some of those guys get on the practice squad and develop there. This is a pretty good roster. When you have quality rosters it's supposed to be hard for draft picks to make it.
Jud: Do you think Bell will come back earlier than Thursday?
Ray Fittipaldo: In don't think he will. I think he'll do something similar to last year. Show up on Labor Day and practice and get ready to play in the opener.
Lambert Lunatic: Ray, do you believe the Steelers will approach trades the next few weeks based on the fact they will likely get a second or third rounder for Bell?
Ray Fittipaldo: I am sure that factors into their thinking.
Fan from Denver: What is the status of TJ? Hes missed so much time as a year 2 guy. Do you think it will impact his performance in the first quarter?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think so. I think with some of these injured players they're just making sure they are ready for the regular season.
Ski: Who do you hold responsible for the In side LB situation?
Ray Fittipaldo: Listen, they knew there were some good ILbs in the draft. They just couldn't land any of them in the first round. After that, they didn't like as many. So they passed and addressed other spots. If they didn't like a guy I certainly didn't want them to draft a guy just for the sake of drafting a guy. That doesn't make much sense.
Lambert Lunatic: Ray, how do you pronounce Fichtner? I’m tired of discussing things with my friends and probably butchering it.
Ray Fittipaldo: I believe it's FEEK-NER
Ray Fittipaldo: OK. I have to go watch some practice. Thanks for all the questions this week. We'll do it again next week.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.