Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my weekly Steelers chat. Post your questions and we'll get started.

SILLY in PHILLY: Assuming Samuels makes the transition- would he be a viable 4th receiver option? Imagine he would be a size and speed nightmare for opponents’ 4th corner?

Ray Fittipaldo: The coaches like Samuels. I think he has a good shot to make the 53-man roster. He is versatile, but I'm not certain how they'll use him at this point. In the spring, they used him in the same way they've used Le'Veon Bell int he past -- lined him up all over and took advantage of his skill set. He's someone to keep an eye on in training camp. He'll get a lot of work at RB and I think you'll see him lined up as a receiver, too.

GENE: Hi Ray, What's the holdup with the Boswell deal ?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: It's not just the players who get a break in late June and early July. It's also when front office personnel and agents get away for some vacation time, too. I think you'll see the negotiations pick up in August and early September. The Steelers are never in a rush with these things. David DeCastro signed a few days before the season opener a few years ago. And if for some reason the Steelers don't strike a deal with Boswell they'll have the franschise or transition tag at their disposal in March because it's highly unlikely they'll use one on Le'Veon Bell again.

MoreDread: The Steelers run game, under Haley, featured mostly zone blocking with inside runs. Fichtner has typically used gap blocking and pulls in an outside run game. Bell seems to prefer the former as he is not really fast. Do you see Fichtner adapting to the way it's been or trying to install his own style?

Ray Fittipaldo: When you say Fichtner "has typically used gap blocking and pulls in an outside run game" what are you referring to? Fichtner hasn't been an offensive coordinator since 2006 when he was at the University of Memphis. He has been with the Steelers since 2007 as either the WRs or QBs coach. So he is certainly well-versed in how the run game was schemed under Todd Haley. Also, as to Haley mostly using noze blocking with inside runs that's not really true either. The Steelers used zone and man blocking under Haley. In fact, Haley allowed Mike Munchak to play to his players' strengths. Munchak was almost all zone blocking when he was the line coach in Tennessee, but he changed a bit upon arriving to the Steelers because he had different personnel. So in an attempt to answer your question, I think it's safe to assume Fichtner will run an offense that is similar to the one Haley oversaw with a few wrinkles along the way. But don't expect any major changes in regards to which blocking scheme they employ.

jim: Since the money from the Steelers would be "virtually" guaranteed but not actually guaranteed. Wasn't Bell foolish not to sign it? If he is banking on himself so much, why would he think we would cut him after a year, or two?? Seems like the Steelers have a history of honoring their contracts.

Ray Fittipaldo: Right. You are correct. That's why I found it so odd that his agent did a media blitz and pointed out how the Steelers conduct their business. What was the point of that? To strain relations with the club in future negotiations with other players he might represent? It was dumb. The Steelers aren't going to change the way they structure their contracts. As for the decision not to sign that will be determined by whether Bell stays healthy this season. If he does he'll likely earn more on a contract when he becomes a free agent. However, if he suffers another major injury it will be a foolish decision because as you point out the Steelers don't cut guys in the second or third years of deals. They never have because the dead cap hits would be too harsh.

Advertise with us

Guest: I'm not going to hold you to it, but as camps open, what is your gut telling you about this season? Give me the Steelers' record and what they'll do in the playoffs (assuming you think they'll get there).

Ray Fittipaldo: 10-6. Win the division. No. 4 seed in AFC playoffs. Probably win a wild-card game but don't expect a deep playoff run. Just too many holes on defense for me to pick them to be Super Bowl contenders. Maybe they'll change my mind if the defense suddenly improves. I just have a hard time seeing how with the moves (or lack thereof) they made over the offseason on that side of the ball.

SILLY in PHILLY: Better or worse w/out Martavis THIS season?

Ray Fittipaldo: Will depend on the development of James Washington. I tend to think he'll do just fine and they won't miss Bryant all that much. But we'll have to wait and see how it all plays out.

jim: Bell's agent says he is a generational talent, but aren't a lot of the running backs coming out now (i.e. Barkley,Samuels) runner/receivers? I don't see anyone giving Bell the money he wants.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Not to mention the presence of Ezekiel Elliott and Todd Gurley, who are already in the league. But don't underestimate the free-spending ways of some owners and GMs once free agency begins. If Bell is healthy some team will pay him more than the Steelers were willing. I'm almost certain of that.

Glen: Hi Ray, when do we start getting nervous about Edmunds remaining unsigned?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think there is any reason to be concerned. There are a handful of other first-rounders still unsigned. If he does decide to miss a good portion of camp he'd be receiving some monumentally bad advice. He's not a starter, and he'd only be hurting himself by quibbling over a few thousands dollars. These rookie contracts are slotted so there really isn't a lot of negotiating that goes on.

SILLY in PHILLY: Can you let us know how Mathew Thomas looks in camp?

Ray Fittipaldo: Sure thing.

Advertise with us

Bud is Weiser: Your thoughts on James Harrison . . . honest opinion or sour grapes or a little of both? I tend to think it's a little of both.

Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah little bit of both I suppose. I mean, how can anyone argue with what he said. Of course Bill Belichick is a better coach. He's a better coach than the other 30 head coaches too. That wasn't breaking news. I think the part about the discipline and playing favorites was telling. It's been obvious guys like Antonio Brown and Le'Veon Bell have received special treatment in the past. Harrison said that does damage in the locker room. Perhaps it does, but for a guy like Harrison to be the messenger on this is a bit odd. He received special treatment from Tomlin for years. Some years, he didn't put on pads in camp until two or three weeks had gone by. He was sleeping in recliners in team meetings according to his teammates and apparently was not punished for his actions. Until he was released I guess. But that's not exactly punishment. It seemed that's what Harrison desired.

SILLY in PHILLY: Is this the year DHB’s time on the team comes to end?

Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't be surprised either way. He's not really involved in the offense all that much. They keep him because they like him on special teams. As always, he'll have to prove he can be effective on those teams to make the 53-man roster.

SILLY in PHILLY: Expectations for Mason Rudolph?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: He played well in the spring. I would expect him to continue on an upward trajectory in camp.

Dudley Dawson: Am I crazy to think the offense may be more explosive this year?

Ray Fittipaldo: All the important pieces return. Offensive line will be intact. The skill players too (once Bell decides to sign his tender). I think the offense might have to be better because I don't know if the defense will be better than it was last year. Roethlisberger and Co. might have to carry this team.

DW: Ray, it seems consistently for the past several years the Steelers always been able to find top tier receivers. If we lose one in free agency, seems like they always draft a replacement who ends up being even better. Who within the organization has such a keen eye for talent at the position?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know if there is one scout who receives the credit. I guess you have to credit Kevin Colbert the most because he's the guy who is pulling the trigger on these picks.

Advertise with us

Bill: Ray, why does the NFL set a deadline for franchise players to come to terms? If the Steelers and Bell wanted to continue working on it who does it hurt? It makes no sense to me.

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree. I'll see if I can find out if there is a reason the NFL or NFLPA wants a deadline. I suspect there is a reason.

SILLY in PHILLY: what excites you most about upcoming camp?

Ray Fittipaldo: Watching the new guys in pads. This will be the first opportunity to see the rookies play some semblance of tackle football. The intensity is ratcheted up and the cream rises to the top.

ryanh103: Do you think anybody well actually be able to win punt return duties this year so we can finally take AB off

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: They've been trying to do that for years. Cam Sutton is a candidate to earn that job with Eli Rogers not currently on the roster.

Baba Booey: Assuming Bell is gone, What does the cap look like heading into next off season?

Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers spend to the cap every year so they won't have a ton more room. Just the $14.5 million they devoted to him in 2018.

T. Lazarus Link, aka, The Bishop: Afternoon sir, any thought as to why Edmunds has not yet signed? Expect it to happen?

Ray Fittipaldo: I expect it to happen sooner rather than later.

Advertise with us

SILLY in PHILLY: Thanks for your “open” mind during these Q and A’s. Was wondering, do you get to go to all the Steelers’ games?

Ray Fittipaldo: I attend all home games and the road games that we drive to. I generally don't go on the longer trips unless one of the other reporters or columnists can't go.

K Dot: In your opinion what might be the biggest position shakeup after camp? CB? S? WR?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think we're all wondering how the safeties will be deployed, but I wouldn't necessarily call what might happen a "shakeup" either. Cornerbacks are set although Artie Burns might get pushed a bit by Cam Sutton. The receivers are set, too. It's going to be Antonio Brown, JuJu Smith-Schuster and James Washington as the top three unless there is an injury.

Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.

Advertise with us

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.

CK: Do you think that JuJu spolied us in his rookie season...can we expect even bigger things this year?

Ray Fittipaldo: They're counting on him to be better. He's the undisputed No. 2 this year with Martavis Bryant gone. They need him to produce like one.

jim: What do you make of Harrison's comments about the defense. Was he saying the players basically weren't prepared? I think it was directed at Mitchell, Burns, Gay, etc. Did you get that impression?

Ray Fittipaldo: You'll have to be more specific. I read about the Harrison comments on Tomlin. What did he say about players?

Advertise with us

ryanh103: James Harrison said communication on defense was a mess because multiple coaches were calling different defenses at the same time do you have any idea on what coaches he was talking about

Ray Fittipaldo: OK thanks for posting. I only saw the comments about Tomlin. That doesn't surprise me. Their communication was admittedly terrible at times. The players spoke up about it after the Jacksonville game.

jim: Any idea why we aren't resigning Rodgers now that he is healthy again?

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe they like Marcus Ticker better. I mean, it's not like Rogers was a productive player last year. They got by just fine with him being a bit player in the offense.

T. Lazarus Link, aka, The Bishop: Ray, I heard that Aaron Donald needed to report to camp by a certain date in order to qualify as a UFA next season, since he had already held out of a previous offseason. I was curious why (assuming that's correct info) it doesn't apply to Bell?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Because Bell is not this year and was not last year under contract. He's not under contract until he signs his tender.

John MA: Where is Bell going to find a better situation? HOF QB and WR and excellent offensive line.

Ray Fittipaldo: Good question, but I'm not sure he's all that worried about that. It appears money is at the forefront of his contract stance. That's fine too. He's earned that right.

MoreDread: Actually,yes, I was referring to Fichtner's time in Memphis. I do realize that Haley used both schemes but it was predominately zone in the run game. The reason I'm asking is because I've never seen Conner play college ball. Since the chances of Bell being here are quite low next year, I was wondering which of these schemes would suit Conner better.

Ray Fittipaldo: I think Conner is fairly adaptable. When he was a bigger back at Pitt a power scheme might have suited him better, but he's slimmed down and I think he'll be fine in a zone or man scheme.

Advertise with us

SteelerBill: Do you think there is any scenario where the Steelers rescind the tag?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think so. Not unless he does something so bad that they'll want to cut their losses.

SILLY in PHILLY: Does a first year Undrafted free agent like Mathew Thomas get a fair opportunity to start? Meaning are there enough camp snaps and pre-season opportunities given to him w the first team to truly show the coaches he has the tools?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes and no. There are plenty of camp snaps, but the vast majority of personnel decisions have already been made. They know who their starters are at most positions even if they haven't been officially announced yet. Very few jobs are won in training camp.

ryanh103: whats a underrated camp battle that you're looking forward to seeing

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I'd have to say swing tackle. Chuks Okorafor looked good in the spring and he'll have a chance to earn that job. The Steelers brought in some competition after the Jerald Hawkins injury, but I think they'd like Okorafor to win that job.

Ryno: The mystery of Dupree underperforming has been discovered to be that the QB can see him coming. Was that the craziest reason you've ever heard for a player?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know about the craziest, but it certainly was odd to hear. I've covered football for a long time and I never heard that used as an excuse before. Usually, you can either rush the passer or you can't.

ryanh103: do you think artie is really in competition for his starting spot or is he pretty much set no matter what happens in camp.

Ray Fittipaldo: They'd like to see more consistency out of Burns, but it would be a major story if he was beaten out. He was a first-round pick in 2016. That would be a major admittance of failure by the front office.

Advertise with us

Ernie: Hi Ray, do U see our 7th rnd dL from Alabama makin the squad. He seems intriguing

Ray Fittipaldo: I could see him making it. They carried Dan McCullers for four years and he almost never played. And it's not like there's a ton of competition at nose guard.

Bob: Do the Steelers plan on reducing concessions this year? Seems like they are trying to increase the interest in gameday experience . Lowering prices may help! Ravens lowering prices!!

Ray Fittipaldo: Omari Sankfora wrote a story about that and the Steelers chose not to comment. I read that as they won't lower prices.

Bleans : I noticed Eli Rogers is working out with a couple of teams. Are the Steelers not interested in him anymore?

Ray Fittipaldo: Apparently not. At least not right now.

Durt Reynolds: James Harrison mentioning more than one defensive play being called at times and players being confused on the field. Would this type of behavior be indicative of a coaching change? HC or DC?

Ray Fittipaldo: It would be indicative of bad coaching. I know that.

Ryno: Is there no interest in bringing Eli Rogers back to Pittsburgh? I saw he is on a tour of at least three other teams, and none of those teams is the Steelers.

Ray Fittipaldo: Just because Rogers is working out for teams doesn't mean they'll sign him. It could happen, but they have to work him out first to see how well his knee healed.

Guest 6Rings: I think the Steelers [and you :)] are undervaluing traditional NT's.

I understand not paying a Hampton-esque NT to an extent: they only play ~33-50% of the snaps. But isn't part of their value shutting down the run so that they CAN get off the field and let our pass rushers get after it, as opposed to constantly putting the defense in 2nd & 3rd and short? Especially given the run stats after 50's injury last year, I worry about not having a stout NT. Does that make sense?

Ray Fittipaldo: It does make sense, but it's all about how you spend your assets. Does it make sense for Kevin Colbert to use a first-round pick on a NG that might play a quarter of the snaps in any given game? No, it does not. The trick is finding a stout NG that is versatile enough to move up and down the line. Those types of DTs usually go higher in the first round than when the Steelers traditionally pick.

Lambert Lunatic: Hey Ray, why do the Steelers seem so uninterested in Eli Rogers even though he has been a decent contributor and knows the ins and outs of the offense/Ben?

Ray Fittipaldo: What's his role going to be? Backup slot WR? How many snaps might he get a game? 10? 12? I mean, there are plenty of other concerns for fans out there.

mtsteel: Hi Ray and thank you. So it looks like the Steelers only offered Bell 10 Million in guaranteed money. This is way below many contracts in the NFL (for players of his caliber). Would 20 mil guaranteed sealed the deal? if so it doesn't seem like that much in today's NFL to guarantee 20, especially when your talking about 70 million. Your thoughts? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: That's not true. The Steelers don't guarantee a lot of money to any player in contracts except for QBs. Bell would have had a $10 signing bonus plus whatever his 2018 salary was set for. I think it was around $7 million. So that's $17 million right there. Plus whatever he was set to earn in 2019 and 2020. As you know the Steelers don't make a habit of releasing guys in the second or third years of contracts either.

Ryno: After this season, will the Steelers even bother to try to negotiate with Bell on a new contract? Or have they finally realized he wants FAR more than they are able to offer him?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think they'll try, but they've been trying for the past 18 months. I don't expect a different result.

mtsteel: Hey Ray, I was thinking of going to the Friday night 8/3 practice that is a fan fest of sorts. How is it? in your opinion...Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: I always enjoy it. That's when they traditionally do backs on backers too. Lots of hitting.

TOM T: Ray, Biggest concerns on defense? LB's or secondary?

Ray Fittipaldo: At this point, the LBs but the secondary isn't far behind.

jim: Keith Butler's last year if we don't get the communication issues fixed? Or do you think it is on the players not doing what they are being taught?

Ray Fittipaldo: It's on everyone. I struggled to know last year and I continue to struggle to understand why this communication thing is such a big issue for the Steelers. I think Tom Bradley tried to iron some of that out this spring, but it's certainly an issue worth watching.

Arturo: Hi Ray... thanks for the weekly chat... It’s the highlight of my Monday morning! Do you know if the players care about Madden ratings? I guess they shouldn’t but vanity is Hard to avoid...

Ray Fittipaldo: I saw Ryan Shazier tweet about his rating. He was upset. I guess players do care. Just like they care about their ratings by Pro Football Focus. This stuff is out there for NFL fans to consume.

jim: Do you think TJ and be as good as JJ? They seem to have the same motor, but JJ a little bigger.

Ray Fittipaldo: Different players. JJ is a defensive end. TJ is an outside linebacker. JJ rushes every snap and TJ has converage responsibilities. Different body types too.

Krugerrand: Bell wants to reset the market for Running Backs. Okay, but given that there is a salary cap, has anybody asked him which positions, in general, need to give some money so that Running Backs can make more?

Ray Fittipaldo: You think he cares about that?

SILLY in PHILLY: In your opinion, the Steelers coming up short the past couple of years- a talent issue or coaching problem?

Ray Fittipaldo: Talent on defense has been an issue. But there has been a coaching problem too. I think that has been obvious. We've been discussing this communication issue for it seems like years now.

Kurt: Ray how will this D be any better? They say they want the new Safeties etc to play linebacker in sub packages but we wont get to sub packages if they are getting gashed by the run again. I think the O needs to score like 35 a game because i don't see this D stopping anyone.

Ray Fittipaldo: I tend to agree with you. If the defense is better than last year I'll be pleasantly surprised.

Ryno: Speaking of Eli, what is your best guess as to the reason he went from being "Automatic Eli" two seasons ago, to being so hit or miss last season?

Ray Fittipaldo: The arrival of JuJu for one. And he always seemed to get in Mike Tomlin's doghouse at least once a year.

Ray Fittipaldo: Ok thanks for taking part in the chat today. We'll do it again next week after a few days of observing practices. That should make it fun.

Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.