The Steelers scored 42 points in their playoff loss to Jacksonville last season. They gave up 45 in the same game, and the season ended because their defense couldn’t stop the offensive juggernaut led by Blake Bortles. The same Jaguars offense scored a total of 10 points the week before in an ugly playoff win over the Bills.

The year before, the Steelers’ season ended in large part because they gave up 36 points to the Patriots in the AFC title game. Wide receiver Chris Hogan looked like a Hall of Famer that day as he torched them for 180 yards and two touchdowns.

In the past three seasons, the Steelers’ defense has given up a total of 104 points in their postseason finales. That isn’t even acceptable in Arena Football, much less the NFL.

Keith Butler was at the helm of the defense for all three of those games. Naturally, it was offensive coordinator Todd Haley who was fired this offseason.

Advertise with us

No criticism seems to stick on Butler, and there is always some excuse for why the defense under his watch has been below the line. The secondary got old, the secondary is too young, the linebackers haven’t played like first-round picks, they lost Ryan Shazier, the defense is on the field too much because the offense scores too quickly, etc.

The bottom line, according to Mike Tomlin, is that the NFL is, well, a bottom line business. The standard is the standard, and every man is held accountable for meeting that standard. That is, apparently, except for Butler, who always seems to find a way out of the crosshairs when it comes time to finding someone to blame for a season that has finished well short of expectations.

Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.

Yes, the Steelers were among the top teams in just about every defensive category last season. But the unit benefited greatly from playing a lot of games against bad offenses and backup quarterbacks.

Advertise with us

They played the Browns and Bengals two times each. They played the Packers without Aaron Rodgers (and still managed to give up 28 points to Brett Hundley). They faced the Texans without DeShaun Watson and the Colts without Andrew Luck. Those offenses contributed greatly to skewing the Steelers’ defensive statistics.

The Steelers couldn’t get a stop against the Patriots twice late when they needed one to win the game in December. They were run over by Jacksonville — twice — and got run over by the Bears. They gave up 38 points to the Ravens late in the season and needed a miracle sideline catch by Antonio Brown to set up a field goal and escape with a one-point win.

Butler has a first-round pick and hybrid safety in Terrell Edmunds and has switched sides of his two former first-round pick outside linebackers, Bud Dupree and T.J. Watt. Two free agents were brought in at key positions, and cornerback Artie Burns is entering his third year, so it should be his time to have a breakout season.

There are no more excuses left for Butler. This is Year 4. He is no longer learning on the job nor should he need the help of Tomlin like he apparently did down the stretch last season when Tomlin took over most of the play-calling duties. This has to be the year Butler figures it out and the Steelers become a championship-level defense.

Butler is by all accounts a great guy and one of the nicest men in the business. That goes far with Dale Carnegie, but in the NFL it’s meaningless if the team or unit you are responsible doesn’t get the job done.

Advertise with us

The Steelers’ defense holds the key to the upcoming season. If it fails again in the playoffs, Butler will and should be the one to answer for it.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com