David Carr isn’t walking away from his criticism of Ben Roethlisberger.
The former quarterback-turned-analyst for the NFL Network on Sunday defended his decision to leave the Steelers veteran off his list of the league’s top 10 quarterbacks.
“I don’t think that Ben is in his prime right now,” Carr said on the network. “That’s the biggest thing. I was at his first preseason game in Pittsburgh. Actually played against him. He walked onto the field, he was a different level. He threw defensive linemen off of him. He made plays outside the X’s and O’s. Hall of Fame player. Absolutely no question. He doesn’t do that as much anymore. That’s not his strength.”
That was a new talking point, as Carr’s initial comments focused more on the talent around Roethlisberger than the quarterback himself. But it’s just as off-base.
Those ad-lib plays Roethlisberger made early on were spectacular, but they weren’t ideal. The Steelers’ offensive line couldn’t protect him the way it has in these later stages of his career, and so he was forced to make plays while scrambling out of the pocket, or after shrugging off a defender or two in the backfield. That limited his production statistically, even if it was impressive to watch at times.
Now that he has better protection, his numbers have improved quite a bit.
Read More
Three of his five 4,000-yard seasons have come since 2013. Four of his five biggest years in terms of passing touchdowns have come in that same time frame. He is affecting the game more than he did in leading the Steelers to Super Bowl wins in 2005 and 2009, when the knock on him was that he was more of a game manager.
Do Le’Veon Bell and Antonio Brown have something to do with that? Sure. One could even argue reasonably they hide some of Roethlisberger’s warts by making big plays on throws that may be a little less accurate than they used to be.
The numbers are what they are, though. They say Roethlisberger is better in the pocket than he was when he was running for his life out of it as a young player. Sure, it’s not as dramatic as watching him shed a linebacker before hitting his man for a big gain down field. And perhaps he won’t be able to stay at that level into his late 30s.
Regardless, it’s a good thing Roethlisberger is a different quarterback now than he was in his 20s. And if he was consensus top 10 signal caller then, he certainly should be now. Maybe that’s why Carr’s own network had Roethlisberger at No. 18 overall and No. 5 among quarterbacks in its recent top 100 players list.
Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.