Kevin Colbert had a terrific record when it came to drafting safeties early in his tenure as Steelers general manager. The first time he picked a safety was 2002, when Chris Hope arrived in the third round. One year later, Colbert recognized future greatness in Troy Polamalu and traded up 11 spots in the first round to secure him.

Polamlau and Hope started next to each other for two years and were integral parts of the defenses that helped the Steelers appear in consecutive AFC championships and win Super Bowl XL following the 2005 season. Polamalu became one of the best safeties of his generation and will someday be enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

It was, by any measure, expert selecting by Colbert and his staff. But in the 14 years since Polamalu was taken with the No. 16 overall pick, the Steelers haven’t been as shrewd when it comes to picking safeties in the draft. They’ve taken five safeties since 2006, and only one has developed into what can be considered a solid starter. The others either failed miserably or served as reserves.

Anthony Smith (2006), Ryan Mundy (2008), Shamarko Thomas (2013), Sean Davis and Gerod Holliman (2016) followed Polamalu. Of that quintet, only Davis has become a consistent starter, and the jury remains out on whether he’ll be offered a second contract. Smith, like Davis a second-round pick, was a bust best known for trash-talking the Patriots and struggling mightily to back it up. He started 14 games over three seasons and was released before his rookie contract expired. Mundy and Thomas were mostly reserves, and Holliman never played in an NFL game.

Advertise with us

Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.

The Steelers haven’t been the only team that has struggled to find quality safeties in the draft, and there is good reason for that. It has become harder to find players who can thrive in today’s pass-happy NFL.

“The way the game has changed, it has become more passing-based, so what you're looking for from the safety has also changed,” said Bucky Brooks, a former NFL defensive back and scout who now analyzes the draft for the NFL Network. “Before, you were looking for the big, physical guy to come and be the eighth guy in the box, a guy that can be an effective run defender and make plays sometimes near the line of scrimmage.

“Now, with the more teams going 11 personnel — one back and three wide receivers — you need those safeties to be able to play comfortably in space, to be able to have the skills to play in man-to-man and zone in the open field, have ball skills to be able to kind of turn the ball over, while also still possessing those skills as tacklers and run defenders. It's really a hard job to find the right kind of guys that have that versatility.”

Advertise with us

More often than not, over Colbert’s tenure the Steelers have found their starting safeties in free agency. The previous three times the Steelers needed to fill a starting safety spot, they went the free-agent route. In 2006, when Hope left via free agency, they signed Ryan Clark, and he paired nicely with Polamalu for eight years. Mike Mitchell followed in 2014, after Clark was released, and held down the job for four years before he was released last month. Shortly after Mitchell’s release, the Steelers signed Morgan Burnett to a three-year contract worth $14.3 million to be their starter this season.

One reason the Steelers have opted to go the free-agent route has been where they are selecting in the draft. More often than not this century, they have been drafting in the bottom half of the first round. Polamalu was the No. 16 overall pick in 2003. The Steelers haven’t had the luxury of getting to pick the best safeties.

Minkah Fitzpatrick of Alabama and Derwin James of Florida State are the best safeties in this draft, and they’ll be long gone by the time the Steelers are ready to pick. Both are likely top-10 picks.

“Safety is becoming a premium position in the NFL because you need to be able to defend these hybrid offensive weapons these teams are deploying in the middle of the field,” said ESPN analyst Louis Riddick, a former NFL safety and scout. “That’s the area of the field you have to protect.”

The Steelers have struggled to defend the pass since 2013, which coincides with Polamalu’s decline as a player. He retired after the 2014 season.

Advertise with us

The Steelers once had the luxury of having the league’s most dynamic (and unpredictable) playmaker in the back end of their defense. Not having that dynamic at safety the past few years has been problematic, as opposing quarterbacks have successfully attacked the Steelers secondary.

“Those players become so much more important,” NFL Films analyst Greg Cosell said of safeties. “If you don’t have good safeties, it really limits your options defensively. When you get multidimensional safeties, it really expands your playbook.”

The Steelers are moving Davis to free safety and are hoping he can have more success there. Burnett is penciled in at strong safety, but he is 29 and obviously isn’t a long-term answer.

Justin Reid of Stanford visited the Steelers facility Tuesday. He could be an option in the first round.

The Steelers also have shown interest in Jessie Bates of Wake Forest and Ronnie Harrison of Alabama. Colbert and head coach Mike Tomlin attended their pro days. Both are likely second-round options.

Advertise with us

“Ronnie Harrison from Alabama is a classic Steelers-type player,” said Daniel Jeremiah, another former scout for three NFL teams who also analyzes the draft for the NFL Network. “He can play high, play low, he's a force player, he's smart and he's tough. He kind of reminds me of a Steeler.”

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.