Steelers general manager Kevin Colbert said earlier this week the team has not yet decided if the fifth-year option on Bud Durpee’s rookie contract will be exercised. Colbert has until May 3 to make that decision on the outside linebacker who has been held back by injuries and inconsistencies in his first three seasons.

The Steelers have exercised the option on three of the four players they drafted in the first round since the 2011 collective bargaining agreement stipulated that all rookie contracts would be for four years with an option for an additional year on first-round selections. Only Jarvis Jones (2013) did not have his option exercised. Cameron Heyward (2011), David DeCastro (2012) and Ryan Shazier (2014) did.

Heyward and DeCastro were signed to lucrative second contracts. Shazier’s status is on hold as he recuperates from spinal surgery, but by signing his fifth-year option last May, he was guaranteed his $8.7 million salary for the 2018 season.

Colbert said of Dupree this week: “I think Bud is just scratching the surface on what he can be.” The Steelers need to Dupree, who has 14½ career sacks, to reach his potential and quickly. If he doesn’t, the Steelers’ 2015 draft class could be a washout.

Advertise with us

Cornerback Senquez Golson (second round), receiver Sammie Coates (third round), cornerback Doran Grant (fourth round) and safety Gerod Holliman (seventh round) no longer play for the Steelers. Golson and Holliman never played a down in the NFL, and Grant played in just three games.

The inability to hit on defensive backs had a ripple effect in the past two drafts. In 2016, the Steelers drafted cornerback Artie Burns in the first round and safety Sean Davis in the second round. In 2017, the Steelers used a third-round pick on cornerback Cameron Sutton.

Only tight end Jesse James (fifth round) and defensive lineman L.T. Walton (sixth round) remain on the roster with Dupree. Both are entering the final year of their rookie contract and can become free agents next March if the Steelers don’t sign them to second contracts before the start of the season.

It’s possible that none of the seven 2015 draft picks will be on the 53-man roster in 2019. For a draft and develop team, that’s not a scenario the Steelers ever want to encounter.

Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.

Advertise with us

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.

Three years is a logical time to evaluate a draft class because that’s exactly what general managers are doing right now. They’re deciding whether their picks are worthy of second contracts.

The Steelers aren’t the only team grappling with decisions on 2015 first-round picks. Plenty of other teams are evaluating players that have been slow to develop. Eight of the first 18 picks in the 2015 draft have made at least one Pro Bowl, but the final 14 picks of the first round have not. That includes another outside linebacker who was selected with the pick immediately after Dupree.

Shane Ray, the No. 23 overall pick of the Broncos, has similar stats to Dupree and has not yet established himself as a pass-rushing force in the league.

In fact, only one player drafted between the No. 19 and No. 64 draft slots (end of the second round) has made a Pro Bowl. Safety Landon Collins, who was the first pick of the second round, is a two-time Pro Bowler for the Giants.

Advertise with us

That’s nine total Pro Bowl players for the first 64 players taken in 2015. Things can change, but this class isn’t looking all that strong.

Nineteen players from the 2014 draft have made at least one Pro Bowl. That’s not an apples to apples comparison because the 2014 class had one more year to earn Pro Bowl recognition, but it illustrates the 2014 class had more elite talent at the top.

The Steelers needed a safety in 2015 almost as much as they needed an outside linebacker — Troy Polamalu retired a few weeks before the draft — but they opted for Dupree instead of Collins. The Steelers are holding out hope Dupree can harness his potential and deliver a Pro Bowl-caliber season.

If not, they’ll be back in the market for another starting outside linebacker next year at this time. And that 2015 draft class will be looking even worse than it does now.

Targeting the new rule

Advertise with us

The early feedback from players is they don’t like the new targeting rule the competition committee passed this week. The NFLPA didn’t like that a rule that can have a big impact on players was passed without its input. Players also think it will make the game much more difficult.

Heyward called it “stupid” in December when it was first announced the league was considering it. The new rule states players can be ejected from games if they strike an opposing player with the crown of their helmet.

College football has had a targeting rule for the past 10 years. If the NFL follows the NCAA’s lead, the targeting penalty won’t be called all that often. In 2016, the most recent year available, there were 144 targeting penalties called in Football Bowl Subdivision, or about one foul for every six FBS games played.

Much still has to be determined about the way the officials will call the foul. The NFL is expected to get players and coaches up to speed on how it will work before training camps begin later in the summer.

But don’t doubt for a minute this new rule will stir some controversy.There are so many unanswered questions.

Advertise with us

Will the rule be applied equally among offensive players as defensive players? Running backs often lead with the crown of their helmets when they are about to get tackled.

How will officials view quarterback sneaks? How comfortable will they be ejecting players when fouls are egregious? Or will they count on senior vice president of officiating Alberto Riveron to make those calls from New York?

Get ready for more drama this fall.

NFL experience not required

Mike Tomlin hasn’t shied away from hiring college coaches during his tenure as Steelers head coach. His new offensive coordinator, Randy Fichtner, was a lifelong college assistant until Tomlin hired him to his original staff in 2007. Tomlin promoted him to offensive coordinator in January.

Advertise with us

Tomlin went back to the colleges this year when he made a few more hires. He hired Tom Bradley to coach his defensive backs and Karl Dunbar to coach the defensive line. Bradley had been the defensive coordinator at UCLA and Dunbar had been the defensive line coach at Alabama. Bradley, like Fichtner, had never coached in the professional ranks.

“I love the fact he has no professional coaching experience,” Tomlin said of Bradley this week. “I wanted a teacher, a guy with a teacher’s mentality. We got a lot of young people in the secondary, and the development of those people is critical for us.”

College coaches often are more effective with younger players. Former Steelers coach Chuck Noll also liked to hire assistants with no NFL experience. In the early 1970s, Noll’s entire defensive staff came from the college ranks.

George Perles, Bud Carson, Dan Radakovich and Woody Widenhofer all had no experience coaching in the NFL before being hired by Noll. All they did was help to oversee the building of the Steel Curtain defense.

The modern-day Steelers have been plagued by mental lapses and communication issues with their defense. They remain very much a young defense with six of their projected starters 25 or younger.

Advertise with us

Sometimes a new voice can go a long way in getting through to young players.

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.