Ray Fittipaldo: Let's get started.

Justin: If Derwin James or Ronnie Harrison is available which are you leaning towards?

Ray Fittipaldo: Derwin James has been the more highly touted player. I've seen him in the top 15 in most mock drafts. I've seen Harrison mocked to the Steelers at No. 28. But if both are available I'm going with James because he's the better player. He's more athletic and has more range. I just don't expect him to be there.

TEAM: Is Lawrence Timmons returning to the Steelers this season a realistic possibility/is it a good idea?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Reports out of Miami are that he'll be cut March 14, the first day of the new league year. Knowing how the Steelers operate yes it's a distinct possibility. They value players who know the defense and the culture. Plenty of other players have left and come back. It doesn't always work, but if Timmons is willing to play for somewhere around $2 million a year on a two-year deal I think it makes sense for the Steelers. It gives them a quality albeit aging player at a position where they are desperate for depth. But I wouldn't go much beyond $2 million a year for Timmons because I'm not sure that he projects as a full-time starter.

Mr. Ray: Ray, are you going to be in Indy for the Combine? Or is Gerry gonna be?

Ray Fittipaldo: Gerry is driving to Indy tomorrow and will have daily stories every day after that. Kevin Colbert is scheduled to talk Wednesday morning so stay tuned for Gerry's dispatches from the combine.

Shrinkage: How much weight should an NFL front office ascribe to a one year trend? Referring specifically to Pats and Eagles getting to SB without a feature back / people using that in L. Bell argument.

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, considering the Patriots have had the same philosophy for most of the past two decades and have been to eight Super Bowls in that span I'd say it's more than a one-year trend. And, it should be noted, the Patriots and Eagles are not alone in the way they approach the RB position. Plenty of other teams have no clear-cut No. 1 and have multiple players who fill a variety of roles within their offense. The Steelers like having their bell cow in Bell, but there are other ways to fill the void if they cannot come to an agreement.

Advertise with us

PGH: So, areas of need in the draft/free agency in order of need...1. ILB 2. safety 3. then what? THANK YOU

Ray Fittipaldo: Assuming Bell is on the team, WR. If they let Bell walk, then RB becomes next immediate need after ILB in first round.

MItchell fan : Is Mike Mitchell definitely not returning this season?

Ray Fittipaldo: They have not cut him yet, but it's certainly a possibility they will.

Guest: Losing Chris Hubbard (probably) will be tough. Who is the guy best-suited to replace him?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Chris Hubbard played center, guard, tackle and tight end. There is no one on the roster who can do all of those things. So they'll have to rely on different guys to fill his spot. Jerald Hawkins now becomes the top backup tackle and perhaps the third TE is they keep that package as a staple under Randy Fichtner. The top interior backup is BJ Finney, who is back on a one-year deal.

Guest: What do you think a Randy F. offense will look like as compared to the Todd H. offense?

Ray Fittipaldo: He has been given a directive from Art Rooney to improve in the red zone and in their situational play-calling on third and fourth downs. So I would expect some wrinkles in those two areas. The rest of the offense I would expect to remain very similar to Todd Haley's offense. That's the main reason they kept Fichtner. They wanted to keep things rolling in the same direction.

TEAM 2018: If Mike Mitchell is released, are there any FAs out there who might be able to fill in well for him and are affordable? Thank you, Ray.

Ray Fittipaldo: Vaccarro from the Saints will be out there. He's a former first-round pick. But honestly, I would expect a draft pick because right now with Bell's situation up in the air I'm not thinking the Steelers will be all that active in free agency. That might change if they decide not to retain Bell, but their intentions are to keep him and he'll eat up a good portion of the remaining cap money, especially if he gets the franchise tag again.

Advertise with us

Guest: How do you expect Keion Adams to contribute this season? Will he make the team?

Ray Fittipaldo: He was injured fairly early on in camp last summer so I don't have a lot to go on. I do know they kept him on IR all season, which means they like his potential. But he'll have to show that he can play in prseason games to warrant a spot on the 53-man roster.

Guest: Is Cedric Wilson's son really as good as some of the local media are making him out to be?

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not sure what others are saying about him, but I had him as a fifth-round pick in my first mock draft. I think he'd be a good option then. Not really sure that qualifies as making him out to be really good.

Cam: As a big Hawks fan I’d love to see the Steelers draft Jewell, do you think there’s any chance he slips to us in the third round? I couldn’t see them taking him in the second.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I guess it's a possibility. He's not a guy who is going to test all that well this week. But honestly, he's a good player, and expecting him to fall toward the end of the third might be wishful thinking.

Utah Jim: Hi Ray, if Spence was better than Matakevich then why wasn't he on the roster in the first place or was the latter injured?

Ray Fittipaldo: Matakevich was injured in the same game as Shazier. He was able to come back and play on special teams, but his shoulder was not healthy enough to play as a linebacker. They still like Matakevich, but I don't think they view him as a starter, certainly not a long-term starter.

Moose: Good day Ray. Only 2 RB's over the age of 26 have rushed for over 1k. Factor in Bell's past off the field issues, serious injuries, and that it is a passing league, shouldn't the Steelers tag Bell and let him walk at age 27?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think your stat is correct. There have been plenty of players 26 or older to rush for more than 1,000 yards. But your final suggestion that they franchise him again and let him walk after next season remains a possibility. The Steelers are keeping that option open if they can;t sign him long term.

Advertise with us

Moose: Realistically, what is the highest draft pick could you see us getting for MB? Would you trade him for a 4th?

Ray Fittipaldo: Realistically a fifth, maybe a fourth. But that's not worth it for the Steelers. In Bryant, they are getting a cheap player in the final year of his rookie contract that can help them be a contender. Not to mention that he'll be motivated because he'll be in the final year of his deal and eager to play well for potential 2019 suitors in free agency.

question from last week: Ray, per your chat from last week I was able to connect the dots a little bit on the theory that Trey Griffey was signed as part of a publicity stunt with the Mariners designed to play off the fame of HOFer Ken Griffey Jr. It turns out that Jack Zduriencik, who until just recently was the GM of the Mariners, is from New Castle, PA and went to Cal U of PA for college. Presumably, he is a Steelers fan and if we connect the dots I'm betting he had a hand in getting Trey Griffey to the Steelers. The publicity will pay off even if Griffey doesn't make the team. Thanks for the great chats, Ray! Think Griffey will make the team?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure it was a publicity stunt, but he has an uphill climb to make the 53-man roster.

Franco : Hi Ray, Franco from Canada.................any chance the Steelers look into signing Tyler Eifert. He has been cleared and would be a fantastic weapon if healthy. I know a big if but might be worth the risk! Your thoughts?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Vance McDonald was a very good receiving threat when he got healthy late in the season. I honestly see a need for the Steelers to sign a TE in free agency or draft one in the first few rounds of the draft. Maybe in the fifth round or later but not before then.

Moose: I really like the kid at ILB from Boise State. He, like TJ, just looks like a football player. Will he be gone by the time we pick in round 2?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, Leighton Vander Esch will be gone by the time the Steelers pick at the end of the second round. But he might be an option in the first round, especially if he tests well and interviews well at the combine. I like Rashaan Evans a little better than Vander Esch, but I am starting to think he might be a guy the Steelers consider at No. 28. He only had one really good season in college, but TJ Watt was sort of the same way. He didn't have a ton of college production. The Steelers saw traits they liked and pulled the trigger. Could be a similar scenario this year with Vander Esch. He's definitely a player to watch this week at the combine.

Guest: Why don't the Steelers just adopt the same mindset towards Leveon Bell that they have towards Chris Hubbard? That is, he's too expensive for us, so let him test the market and we'll all move on towards solving our defensive deficiencies and replace Bell via the draft.

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, mostly because Chris Hubbard is a backup who has filled in admirably as a starter. Bell is an All-Pro, and the Steelers like to keep All-Pros when they are in their prime years. And at 26, Bell certainly remains in his prime. I'm not saying it's the right move by the Steelers. Paying a RB double what any other RB makes would be a bold move. I'm just telling you the philosophy the Steelers have on star players who are still in their prime.

Advertise with us

zero: Did the Steelers expect to get Compensatory picks or is this ruling of zero picks a non-surprise to the organization?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think there was much expectation about getting compensatory picks this year. Kevin Colbert knows the formula and he had to know it wasn't a strong possibility given how active the team was in free agency last year.

mtsteel: Hi Ray, thanks for your time. I'm hearing the rumblings about a Bryant trade. I feel like if he's moved, it would put us in a "need" spot at WR and we have too many defensive needs to address in the draft and cannot afford a FA receiver. That being said I say we keep him this year on the cheap. Plus he will be playing for a big contract! Agree?

Ray Fittipaldo: You are exactly right. See what I wrote above.

Rob : Its been explained to me that the 3-4 Defense is typically adopted by teams with Strong LB unit, however in order for that to be effective the OLB's must come up and set the edge against the run and pressure the passer. Based on the current personell and strength in the D-Line, wouldnt a 4-3 make more sense in this pass happy league?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: They are only in their base 3-4 defense about 25-30 percent of the time. The rest of the time they are in some form of a 4-3 with one of their OLBs stacked behind the line. I don;t see them committing to a 4-3 full-time because they've drafted OLBs in the first round in two of the past three years. I think they want to see if these guys produce, and if they do, their outside pass rush will improve.

DaquidoBazzini: Hi Ray - If the Steelers traded Martavis Bryant (which I personally would not for less that a 3rd Round pick), how high do you think they'd go WR in the draft?

Ray Fittipaldo: I could see them taking a WR with their third-round pick regardless.

Joel for the defense: Better to get 50 catches or so from Bryant this year as the number 4 receiver and watch him walk away a FA next offseason or trade him now and get some Def. help/draft pick?

Ray Fittipaldo: They'll get a compensatory pick next year if he leaves after his rookie contract. Unless they know he's going to be a big-time in the rear end again there is no need to trade him. His attitude was positive in the second half of the season, and he played better.

Advertise with us

Rob : Due to the decline of Mike Mitchell and the necessity to prevent the long pass, wouldnt a ballhawking free safety be the biggest gap to file on D, especially considering it has been a glaring weakness, year over year....Would you agree? and do you think it could be the single most impactful pick for the D in this years draft? Who do you like?

Ray Fittipaldo: I still think ILB is the biggest need because they need an every-down player to replace Ryan Shazier. But they need a safety, too. Not only was Mitchell one of the reason they gave up so many big plays, but he didn't produce turnovers, either. They need a ball-hawking safety, but they'll draft the best safety available and make adjustments if necessary. In other words, if there is a really good strong safety they like they'll draft him and convert Sean Davis to free safety, where he might be better off.

Hunter: Shazier should get every penny owed to him from his fifth year option. But isn't the rule a little ridiculous in that he counts against the cap for the upcoming year? It would be a lot easier to find his replacement with the extra cap space.

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes it is ridiculous, but that's the way the NFL rule is written. It's not going to be changed for one catastrophic injury. It's not a good situation for the Steelers, but it's one they have to deal with.

Joel for the defense: Like your thinking on the Steelers drafting to ILB's in the draft. What about help at interior DL?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Definitely a possibility but not until later in the draft. I don't see them using one of their first three picks on a DL unless a really good one falls to them in one of the first three rounds. Even then, it would have to be a nose tackle.

Joel for the defense: Do you see the Steelers signing one veteran def. starter before the draft?

Ray Fittipaldo: I can see Timmons signing once he is cut. Would he replace Vince Williams, or would he merely be quality depth behind the starters? I'm not sure at this point.

Vegas Steeler: What round draft pick you think it would take for the Steelers to accept a trade for Bryant?

Ray Fittipaldo: Third or higher. And I don't think that happens.

Advertise with us

Joel for the defense: Is the CB situation on the outside settled with Hayden and Burns for 2018 or could the they be looking at putting Sutton in Burns spot?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think Sutton becomes the top backup CB, which is basically what he was once he came off IR. He's also a solid candidate to play in the dime, assuming Willie Gay does not return.

GENE: Hi Ray, I just read where the attendance at Heinz Field was down for the second straight year. I understand the National Anthem dilemma but that seemed to resolve itself with the Steelers. Any other reasons this is happening?

Ray Fittipaldo: Football is the best sport to watch on TV. And with so many of these late-season games played in less than ideal weather conditions, I think that's a part of it. They've tried to make the game day experience better for fans, but it's a game that translates very well on TV.

Vegas Steeler: If Bell is not tagged or re-signed, do you envision the Steelers going running back with their first-round pick?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Won't rule it out, but more likely second or third round in that scenario you gave.

Joel for the defense: Saw a list of QB salaries. How does Brady get only 15 million a year on the books? Could the Steelers work out something like that for Ben to get cap space?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not unless Roethlisberger is willing to take less than market value. Brady is the rare case and New England has been lucky he's been willing to do it. I guess it helps when your supermodel wife pulls down $50 million a year or whatever Giselle does.

Matt: Hey Ray, do you think Marcus Wheaton is an option for a return to Pitt? He knows the offense and should come very cheaply.

Ray Fittipaldo: I suppose, but he didn't exactly excel in his first go-round here, and the Steelers draft and develop receivers very well. Honestly, I'd rather see them draft one and let that guy develop behind 84, 19 and 10.

Advertise with us

NC Steel: Ray, Let's talk defense. The Steelers 56 sacks set a new team record, but this disguised the fact that the pressure on the QBs was very inconsistent last season. Part of the reason is b/c they dropped the OLBs in coverage so much--more than in years past. Why run a 3-4 that takes away so many opportunities for the OLBs to put pressure on the QBs? Has this been done in part to offset the weakness of the secondary?

Ray Fittipaldo: They did it because it was effective for so much of the season. It did not allow opposing play callers to get a bead on who was dropping and who was rushing. It didn't work out so well vs. Jacksonville in the playoffs, but it helped them go 13-3. I heaven't heard anything along the lines of them changing that next season though there is plenty of time for the coaches to change their minds. That's what they're doing now. Figuring out what worked well in 2017 and what did not.

Joel for the defense: Agree 100 percent they should get something done with Bell so they can see what they have to work with on the cap. Do you think this will drag on like last year or will they get something done soon.

Ray Fittipaldo: The desire for both sides is to get something done so they won't have an ongoing negotiation through the spring and summer. I don't think either side liked how that unfolded.

dmac: Why couldn't they cut Shazier and void his contract and rehire him as a "coach" and pay him the same money off the cap?

Ray Fittipaldo: That would probably viewed as circumventing the cap and would be flagged by the league office. Plus, Shazier has been vocal about returning to play. There are no indications he'd be willing to do such a thing.

Kris : Sutton a viable option to test at SS if we move Davis to FS and cut Mitchell?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes but he played pretty well at CB from what I saw in a limited number of snaps last season.

Ken Ward: Ray, do you think Timmons would be anything but a back up at this stage of his career? I always liked him, but he has obviously lost a step. Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: That's the thing. He's not coming back to replace Shazier. He'd be coming back to replace Williams or provide quality depth.

AK: Also, isn’t it likely the Steelers will get comp picks next year for losing Hubbard and Bryant?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, but in separate years.

Lousy John: Ray, can you explain what Pittsburgh's defensive philosophy is? OLBs are spending more time tin coverage. We've stocked up on CBs. Feels like we only rush three most of the time, and if the DLs aren't moving the pocket, there's no pressure on the QB. Then, if the QB runs, we seem to give up long gains. What exactly are we looking at?

Ray Fittipaldo: They want to get pressure with four and drop seven. That's the ideal scenario, and with dropping OLBs into coverage they were able to create some confusion as to which players were coming. That's the good thing about their philosophy. The bad is when you don't have consistent pressure from your two OLB spots it creates scenarios where QBs can get comfortable and pick apart your defense.

Kris : I think Sean Davis should move to free safety this year, I think he would be a better player at the back of the defense with all of the field in front of him. Mike Mitchell has to be gone, from his poor play to his $8 million cap hit. Find a SS in the draft, maybe even give Sutton an opportunity to see how he plays at the position?

Ray Fittipaldo: You might be thinking the same way as the Steelers brain trust.

mtsteel: Ray, I know Timmons knows the defense, but he's older. Wouldn't bringing in a younger ILB make more sense, its not like they don't have a ton of time to learn the defense by September. Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes it would, but a younger LB would cost more in free agency. You might be able to get Timmons for $2 million a year whereas a 26-year old might cost $5 million or more.

Aluminum Curtain: Do we really have the time to wait around for rookie defensive help to develop into the saviors we need to play championship level defense?

Ray Fittipaldo: Their defense hasn't been good enough with the likes of Mitchell and others the past 10 years. Injecting some new blood might benefit the defense at this point. I don't have any problem with the Steelers drafting an ILB and safety in the first two rounds and letting them learn on the job.

Cooper: Are the Steelers confident in Josh Dobbs or can you see them reaching for a Luke Faulk or Mason Rudolph.

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't see the Steelers taking a QB this year. Jones is signed for one more year and Dobbs has three years left on his rookie contract. The big thing to watch this spring and summer is the development of Dobbs and whether they think he can be the backup in 2019.

Scott in Dallas: What is the harm in Letting L. Bell see what the market will bear for RB's? I really do not believe any team will come close to his $15 mil/year and if he comes back with even $12 mil/year that is better than what was on the table last year right?

Ray Fittipaldo: There are a few teams with money to burn that would pay that much for Bell. The Browns and a few other teams have to spend money to get in compliance with the cap.

Kris : What kind of contract do you see Bell being worth according to himself, and what kind of contract do you see the Steelers believing he is worth? Seem those two may be way to far apart for long term deal.

Ray Fittipaldo: I tend to think he is worth somewhere around $12 or 13 million a year because he is such a good all-around back. The Steelers indicated they were willing to go to $14 million a year for the first few years last summer so I assume they'd be willing to do that again. Bell hinted that there might be more to the negotiation than the money so it likely has to do with how the later years of the contract are structured.

slashsteel: I don't feel it is wise to just draft a ILBer, as in they should also bring in a free agent. So not to put all their eggs in one basket so to speak. Agree or disagree?

Ray Fittipaldo: If you're drafting an ILB in round 1 you're inserting him into the lineup on Day 1. That's just how it works nowadays. It's sink or swim. Very rarely are first-round picks groomed behind others in this day and age, unless it's at QB.

Justin: The Steelers moved up to grab Troy in 03. Do you see them taking that chance again for maybe a Derwin James or Minkah Fitzpatrick?

Ray Fittipaldo: They'd have to move into the top 5 or 10 to get Fitzpatrick and the top 15 or 18 to get James. That's too expensive to come from 28 and do that, so don't hold your breath.

Ryno: Lots of people seem down on Jesse James, but it looks to me like he is improving every season. Am I imagining things? I'm a fan of JJ!

Ray Fittipaldo: James ideally is a No. 2 TE, not a starter. He's been solid but there not a lot of room for more development there. What you see is what you get -- a possession receiver with little potential for YAC and an adequate blocker. Some people will tell you he's a below average blocker.

moose: I'm sorry, only two RB's over 26 rushed for over 1k LAST SEASON

Ray Fittipaldo: OK got it. But my point is Bell is special and I don't think that factors into their thinking.

Daniel from Ohio: Ray, What happened to the February 20tg deadline for L. Bell?

Ray Fittipaldo: That was an artificial deadline. It was the first day players could be tagged. March 6 is the day to watch. That's the final day players can be tagged. And Art Rooney admitted the real deadline is the one that sparks movement from both sides.

Ray Fittipaldo: That's for the questions this week. We'll do it again next week.