BLOOMINGTON, Minn. — Nick Foles and the Philadelphia Eagles will test the theory Sunday that you need a great quarterback to win a Super Bowl.
There have been other quarterbacks who won’t sniff the Hall of Fame who have won it, Jeff Hostetler, Trent Dilfer, Jim McMahon and Brad Johnson among them.
The Steelers could never win it without their Hall of Famer in Terry Bradshaw or likely Hall of Famer in Ben Roethlisberger.
But half of the four teams in the AFC and NFC championships this year arrived with backup quarterbacks, and a third did so with the maligned Blake Bortles. Jacksonville’s Bortles beat Roethlisberger to reach the AFC title game and nearly upset the great Tom Brady in that contest. Case Keenum, Minnesota’s third-stringer, outdueled Drew Brees to reach the NFC title game, where Foles and the Eagles rubbed out the Vikings.
And now Foles, the backup to injured Carson Wentz, will try to take down the Patriots with Brady.
If he does, might it show again that a great quarterback is not necessarily needed to build a champion?
Read More
“Dilfer won, the Redskins won with three non-Hall of Famers,” Ernie Accorsi said. “It can happen. But if you’re building a football team, I don’t like the odds.”
A little introduction here. Accorsi is the former general manager of the Baltimore Colts, Cleveland Browns and New York Giants. A Hershey, Pa., native, he watched in the stands as Johnny Unitas threw his first NFL pass in an exhibition game in 1956 at Hershey Stadium. He later worked for the Colts when Unitas helped deliver them a victory in Super Bowl V, although he left with an injury.
Accorsi defied owner Robert Irsay and drafted John Elway for the Colts in 1983, only to see an angry Irsay trade him to Denver shortly thereafter. He wanted Eli Manning so badly in New York that after San Diego drafted him first in 2004, Accorsi traded Philip Rivers, the Giants’ first-round pick, along with a horde of draft choices to the Chargers for Manning.
He’s always believed you need a great quarterback to build a championship team, and his experiences have proved him correct.
So what about Foles and the Eagles’ chances Sunday?
“In my mind, he was a rising quarterback when Chip Kelly got rid of him,” Accorsi said of the Eagles’ coach who was fired after three seasons in 2015. “He bounced around, then he came back and got off to a slow start this year.
“He’s a pretty good quarterback. He reminds me of Earl Morrall, who took us [Colts] to one Super Bowl, won another one for us when Unitas got hurt, and basically was the quarterback for the majority of the unbeaten Miami Dolphins in 1972.”
Foles played like a Hall of Famer in the NFC championship when he completed 26 of 33 passes for 352 yards and three touchdowns in a 38-7 rout of the Vikings.
“He’s good enough to win, no question in my mind,” Accorsi said. “He’s not going to the Hall of fame, but he’s a pretty good quarterback.”
As backup quarterbacks go, he’s no scrub.
The Eagles drafted Foles, 29, in the third round from the University of Arizona in 2012. He became the starter during the 2013 season when Mike Vick was injured and went on to make the Pro Bowl after throwing 27 touchdown passes and only two interceptions, the best ratio of TDs to interceptions in NFL history. He also made the Pro Bowl the following year.
But Kelly traded him to St. Louis in 2015. Foles signed in 2016 with Kansas City, where he played in just three games and threw 55 passes. He wound up returning to Philadelphia last March as a free agent, and when Wentz blew out his knee against the Rams on Dec. 10, the Eagles turned back to Foles.
“I think everybody got a little nervous when our quarterback got hurt,” said Pittsburgh’s Tom Donahoe, a senior adviser in the Eagles’ personnel department. “I think Carson was on pace to at least be a candidate for league MVP. We were lucky to have Nick Foles. It might have taken him a couple weeks.
“The biggest problem with Nick is he missed all of training camp with a bad elbow, so he got no time with our top receivers and our line. Initially, I think everybody was struggling just trying to help him get comfortable. But obviously, if you saw the championship game, he was comfortable.”
If he can be that comfortable again in Minneapolis on Sunday, the Eagles could very well take home their first Lombardi Trophy and keep Brady, Belichick and the Patriots from their destiny.
“There are exceptions,” Accorsi noted.
Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com and Twitter @EdBouchette.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.