Deep in the bedrock of American jurisprudence, even the plainly indefensible are entitled to a defense, and anyone who doubts the full gravitas of that principle needs to understand that this is an unalienable right extending all the way to fans of the Philadelphia Eagles.

Many of those fans are headed to Minnesota for Super Bowl LII, while millions more will remain in and near the City of the Not Infrequent Brotherly Shove and Full Beer Can Projectile, watching helplessly as the international sports punditry re-heats their various, um, indiscretions.

Oh my God did they really boo Santa and whip snowballs at him 50 years ago?

Um, yeah.

Advertise with us

Did they really punch those police horses this month?

Um, yeah, but just twice.

Did they really have a court and a jail in old Veterans Stadium in their own unique if slightly truncated application of Philadelphia jurisprudence?

Um, yeah.

But, in general, are they really that vile in some singularly brainless way?

Advertise with us

Um .... depends on whom you talk to.

I started with 26-year-old Pittsburgher Jordan Thompson, who, in September 2016 purposely infiltrated the South Philadelphia Eagles nest with several of her girlfriends for a Steelers game. Jordan selected a road white Polamalu 43 jersey for her game day ensemble, and lived to tell about it.

“It was mostly good,” she recalled the other day. “We walked through a lot of tailgates, a couple of bars, no trouble. Don’t know if it was because I’m a girl and I was with all girls, but nothing bad happened. There was a little borderline behavior once the Eagles started beating us, but I grew up in Harrisburg and I was familiar with both the Steelers and Eagles atmospheres.”

The Eagles won 34-3 that sunny day, but the barometric pressure of the crowd veers with the weather, the Birds’ performance, its relationship with the current coach, the critical TAC metric (total alcohol consumption), and various additional caprices.

For last weekend’s NFC championship, things were a little different.

Advertise with us

“It was outrageous,” said Brendan O’Malley, a Philadelphia attorney who once worked three years in Pittsburgh right out of Temple Law. “I reached out to some police contacts, some high level guys, and told them, ‘Hey it’s outrageous down here.’ The (extended) pregame was making people act out. I mean I’m no sissy, but it was getting nuts. Women were just urinating in the street.”

O’Malley, an Eagles season ticket holder since 1999, embodies the full emotional experience of the fan base. His indoctrination came 10 years prior to that, and it lives in his memory with wondrous clarity.

“Uncle Jim took me and I’ll never forget it,” he said. “It was 1989 and it was Raiders-Eagles and we sat in the 700 [highest] level at Veterans Stadium. The 700 level, with Raiders fans and Eagles fans, it was just crazy. If my mom had seen it she would never have talked to my uncle again. Women were taking their tops off.”

It was then that Brendan O’Malley made the only reasonable decision available to a 13-year-old boy.

“I made the decision that wherever I was going to end up, as soon as humanly possible I would move back to Philadelphia because I was going to be an Eagles season ticket holder.”

Advertise with us

O’Malley’s since taken his young son to the games and he’s outfitting his little daughter, though she insists on wearing Eagles gear that comes in pink exclusively. The kids didn’t get to go last week, when some fans whipped unopened beer cans at Vikings fans who were, rightly, horrified.

It’s all part of what the gifted Philly journalist/​Eagles historian/​playwright Ray Didinger regards as a self-fulfilling prophecy.

“I’ve told people I’m done fighting about it,” Didinger said on the phone the other day after he’d returned from a City Hall ceremony in which he was proclaimed a civic treasure or some such thing (which, by the way, he is). “This image is so out there now that you’re not gonna change it. The only thing you can do is not live up to it.

“The thing is, 98.7 percent of them are great fans and it just really bothers them that every time this happens, we go right back to this idea of the Philadelphia fan, which is now accepted as gospel. Then there’s the re-telling. We go back to snowballs at Santa Claus, and we go back to Veterans Stadium with the jail in the basement and back to this is where they threw snowballs at [then Dallas Cowboys coach] Jimmy Johnson. The laundry list.”

Exactly. Like this column.

Advertise with us

Few people know the total narrative arc of all this, but Didinger has essentially lived it. His father owned a bar in Southwest Philly and at one time held more season tickets than anyone in the Eagles data base. He sold them in the bar and chartered a bus on autumn Sundays to Franklin Field (two stadiums ago), where the atmosphere was, by 21st century terms, incomprehensible.

“A lot of people would come straight from Mass to my grandfather’s bar and that’s how I’d get on the bus, in my church clothes,” he said. “I’d put my rosary beads in one pocket, a prayer book in the other, and a scorecard under my arm. We all sat in section EE, in the end zone, almost like one family there. If there was somebody near where we sat who would yell, ‘Hey kick his ass,’ or even something as mild as ‘Hey what the hell are you doin’?,’ one of the adults in our group would yell ‘Hey watch it, there’s women sitting here.’

“I mean it sounds ridiculous. It was G-rated stuff.”

If you think that was quaint, note that the last time the Eagles won an NFL championship — 1960 — the title game was played on a Monday afternoon because Sunday was Christmas. Yes that was a galaxy far, far away. But even in modern times, recent attempts to quantify the fan experience, while not exactly absolving Philadelphia, have suggested there are worse environments. Tracking arrests after the NFL ostensibly cracked down on boorish fan behavior a few years ago, a website called The Sportster listed nine franchises with higher arrest rates at games than the Eagles, including one situated near the confluence of three rivers.

As our final witness, we call former Philadelphia District Attorney and Philadelphia Mayor and Pennsylvania Governor and most importantly Long-Time Eagles pregame host Ed Rendell.

Advertise with us

“Once I was sitting in the first row of the upper deck with four guys who’d had about eight beers each by halftime and they were throwing snowballs,” Rendell said on the phone Friday. “The snow came on Saturday night and the city didn’t get much of it out of there by game time. It was hard-packed snow. So early in the third quarter the Eagles were driving and they were down around the five yard line. I said to those guys, ‘I’ll bet you $20 you can’t reach the field. But if you win, you gotta promise not to throw any more snowballs.’ I knew they could do it, but the players were all down at the end, so I gave them $20 and they left because beer sales were going to end at the end of the third quarter anyway.”

And that was before he was mayor.

“We have some bad fans, especially sometimes with the way they treat opposing fans, but mostly we have passionate, knowledgeable fans who have a sense of humor. Once in the ‘70s, the coach, Mike McCormick, called the Eagles dogs in the paper Wednesday of that week. At that game, which was a Monday night against the Rams, we were on the way to getting beat 42-3, and in the third quarter this chant went up that at first I couldn’t make out. Then it got louder and clear. They were chanting “AL-PO! AL-PO!” The dog food! Then all of a sudden, about four giant inflatable dog bones appeared.”

Your honor. The defense, such as it is, rests.