Ray Fittipaldo: OK let's get started.

Moose: It seemed like S Davis couldn't cover Gronk at all. With that being said, I still loved the fact that we played a lot of man coverage. What say you?

Ray Fittipaldo: Obviously a much better game plan than the one they had in the AFC title game in January though after a while I, like many others, wondered why defensive coordinator Keith Butler wasn't giving Davis any help. That's a tough assignment for Davis. Gronk is the best TE in the league. I'd have made Brandin Cooks or Amendola beat me.

Moose: Ben has to take the blame for the last play, don't you think? Even if the sideline is saying don't clock it, you can't throw the ball in traffic. He had to throw it where only his wr could catch it, or it goes incomplete.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I suppose you're right, but when the bullets are flying and the clock is ticking it's a much different story. I have no problem with the Steelers trying to win in regulation. We all would have criticized them if they had kicked a field goal and lost in overtime. I just have a hard time blaming Roethlisberger entirely there. Does he deserve some blame? Sure. He could have overruled the coaches and just spiked the ball or thrown it away. But that's easy for fans and media to say. They're out there making those decisions in real time.

Moose: The catch rule is officially ridiculous. How on earth did the NFL get by prior to year 2000 without it? Another failure under Goodell if you ask me.

Ray Fittipaldo: If they were ever going to change the rule it was going to be after a playoff game between Green Bay and Dallas was decided by a very similar play to the one that took place last night. Dez Bryant caught a pass, took three steps and fell into the end zone while stretching the ball across the plane. The pass was ruled incomplete and the Cowboys lost the game. If you're not going to make a rules change when it cost a team a playoff game, then when are you going to change it? Does something like this have to happen in the Super Bowl to make a change? I've written about this. NFL officials don't like the rule. They don't like that replay is involved. But the owners and the competition committee failed to come up with a better rule. That's on them,. Mike Tomlin is on the competition committee. He knows this better than anyone. Art Rooney II obviously has involved in those talks. I'm sure they'll be asked this week why the rule remains the same.

Rick: Thought I saw Jessie"s right hand go under the ball while his left hand slipped on top of the ball when he hit the ground. Yes the ball moved but I still thought he had "possession" of the ball. Is the ball not allowed to move?

Ray Fittipaldo: Depends on what game it involves and how Alberto Riveron is feeling that particular day. He ruled a touchdown in favor of the Patriots when Brandin Cooks trapped the ball against the ground after he fell to the ground. The ball not only moved, but it hit the ground. Then there was the call the NFL said he got wrong in the Jets-Patriots game earlier in the season. That call also favored the Patriots. Austin Sefarian-Jenkins would have had a touchdown, but it was ruled a fumble. I've asked the NFL to make Riveron available this week to explain why the calls have no consistency. We'll see if the make him available.

Advertise with us

mtsteel: Hi Ray and thank you. So the last play. First, wouldn't it be better to spike after the big play then have three shots at end zone with a time out? I feel like they self destructed, one player ran a route, James would have been wide open if he runs a route. Lastly, Ben should have winged it out of bounds and go to OT. What say you Sir?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes and hindsight is 20-20. I don't think they were well-prepared on that final drive. I would have hurried to the line and run a play after the long JuJu Smith-Schuster play to the 10. There were 34 seconds left. If you get a playoff off at 20 you'd have 15 seconds or so, which is enough time to run two plays before settling for a field goal. Plus, you'd preserve your timeout and give yourself the option to call a run on one of those final two play calls.

Moose: The Pats have won SB's due to the tuck rule, spygate, deflate gate, and maybe now because the NFL wants to make a catch more complicated than rocket science. Will they ever correct this stupid catch rule?

Ray Fittipaldo: Like I said earlier in the chat, if you don't change it after it costs a team a playoff game then when are you going to change it? I mean, can you imagine the uproar if this happened late in a Super Bowl?

Rick: Why no help for Davis on Gronk? Especially on the 2 point conversion! Davis looked like a middle school kid covering Shaq! I thought Hilton might have been a better option as he is a more physical player.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Hilton is three inches shorter than Davis. I think that's why they shied away from doing that. That being said, if they see the Patriots again they should definitely rethink their Gronk strategy. It didn't work well enough.

Israel : Ray, are we playing our starters these last 2 games?

Ray Fittipaldo: Of course. if the Jaguars win their final two games (@ SF and Tenn) the Steelers need to win these next two games against HOU and CLE to get the No. 2 seed.

Sheff: Forget the bad call for a second. The real bad decision was to punt on 4th and 1 from our own 40 with 2 min left. Everyone knows Brady will score in that situation in his sleep and if we failed they'd still score fast enough to have that final chance to win the game. Am I crazy for thinking that?

Ray Fittipaldo: At that point the Patriots only had 19 points. If Sean Davis makes that interception on the first play of the drive everyone is talking today about the great defensive job the Steelers did against the Patriots offense. I think punting was OK there. My bigger issue was having JuJu run a 3-yard route on third-and-4.

Advertise with us

Sheff: I kept thinking on that fake spike, AB would have known to run a fade. Ben clearly forgot he was out of the game as no one save Rodgers ran a route. Why not run a normal play there?

Ray Fittipaldo: Roethlisberger addressed this after the game. He was thinking spike the ball and kick the FG. But the coaches were in his ear telling him to run a play. So he ran a play, and he made the decision to get cute and only have Rogers in the pattern. I think they wanted the look of a spike play with Rogers trying to get open. Obviously, it didn't work. I wonder what the Steelers would have done if the official threw the flag for pass interference on Rogers. Would they have gone for it on fourth-and-1? Or just kicked the FG and gone to overtime.

Sheff: Can AB be healthy for the divisional round?

Ray Fittipaldo: Early speculation is he will be, which is why it's so important to get the No. 2 seed. That extra week of rest will be important.

Sheff: Who can possibly cover Gronk?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: No one player, but certainly teams have done a better job than the Steelers did Sunday night. How about an occasional double-team?

Njsteelers: Hi Ray, thanks for your time. The more I think about, the coaches really blew this game. How do you call a play that no one on the field is prepared for? Haley told Ben in his helmet to not clock it and everyone on O is thinking clock it?? You had no timeouts, take the FG and play your game in OT. Ben throws a pick, but his coaches set him up for failure. Agree?

Ray Fittipaldo: I have no problem going for the win. You can second-guess the play call and how unprepared they were for what occurred. But we'd all be critical of them if they had lost in overtime after going conservative there.

Pants: Hey Ray, do you feel that steelers could be optimistic even in a lose? I actually feel like they learned alot about man coverage and with haden coming back I really think they could win in foxboro in January.

Ray Fittipaldo: The Patriots are 17-3 at home in the playoffs with Tom Brady at QB. They are 3-4 on the road in the playoffs with Brady. Let's not underestimate the importance of last night's game. Home field would have meant something for the Steelers. It was probably their best shot to get to the Super Bowl.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: 11-5 and now worse than the No. 3 seed.

JJ: What is playoff status if Steelers lose to Texans and Browns. They like to lose to "inferior" teams.

Ray Fittipaldo: question to previous answer.

Sheff: Is it harder to beat the Pats twice at home, or once on the road? If we had defeated the Pats they would have come back to Heinz field hungry for revenge. Now the narrative is for us to avenge a bad call and a heartbreaking loss.

Ray Fittipaldo: I said all along the ultimate scenario for breaking the Patriots hex is by winning on their home field.

Advertise with us

heartbroken: News Flash: Rob Gronkowski is hard to cover. Next time (in the playoffs or next year) any chance the Steelers give T.J. a chance to cover him, maybe with safety help? He's got the size, and if he can run with Jordy Nelson, why not give him a chance?

Ray Fittipaldo: Because he doesn't run with WRs and TE in man coverage. He can drop into zones and play the pass well, but asking him to play Gronk man-to-man would be unfair to him.

Daquido Bazzini: Hi Ray, I'm totally sickened by not only the Jessie James play reversed, but all of the officiating last night. Patriots - 2 penalties for 4 yards? Come on!

Ray Fittipaldo: Two penalties for 4 yards. Two missed calls stick out. The no-call on Rowe in the end zone on the final play and Cam Heyward was tackled in the backfield on the Patriots' last drive when they scored the go-ahead TD. They can't make holding calls against the Steelers late and then swallow their whistles on other obvious calls.

Daquido Bazzini: Do you think the AB injury is one that he can come back from in a few weeks? Or is that not really that realistic?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Early indications are he'll be back for the playoffs though nothing official from the team.

Sam: I figure you'll get enough "was it a catch" questions that I'll get my answer there. But we can't let Haley, Tomlin, and/or Ben off the hook for not having 2 ACTUAL plays called in the huddle right? The James review was after first down, giving everybody involved ample time to say "OK if we have to go back out there, here's the play for 2nd down, and if that's not a TD or clock-stopping play, here's what we're hurrying up to for 3rd down. There was plenty of time to run 2 plays before a 4th down FG, and plenty of time to get organized, yet THAT'S what they came up with. To me that's inexcusable.

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree 100 percent. The only explanation I have is that no one actually thought it would be overturned so they didn't think to do that. But at some point, when the referee is under that hood with NYC for five minutes, you have to have that conversation and prepare for the worst-case scenario.

Sam: In your opinion, beyond just going into Foxboro for a potetial rematch, how big a deal is it that now you're going to have to play Jacksonville in the Division Round rather than like KC or Tennessee or Buffalo, or Baltimore? Seems like the rematch isn't even a forgone conclusion.

Ray Fittipaldo: Agreed. The Jaguars beat the Steelers, 30-9, in October. That won;t be an easy game. I'd argue the Ravens wouldn;t be an easy game either. Or the Chiefs. That game came down to the last minute. The only easy game might be one against the Bills or Titans if either sneaks into the playoffs. Other than that, it's not going to be an easy divisional round game especially if Brown is hobbled.

Advertise with us

mtsteel: Hi Ray, did the Steelers really run there 3rd string running back on 2 and 23 on a drive they need to get a first down to put the game away? I'm not a fire Haley guy, but what is he really thinking not passing the ball here, giving the Pats another great shot??

Ray Fittipaldo: I thin they were thinking catch them off guard and get 7-10 yards to set up a manageable third down. I don't think they expected him to get tackled for a short gain.

OKC Dave: Since he wasn't making a dent in the pass protection, wouldn't have dropping Watt back into the coverage in the seam have helped with covering Gronk? Watt's first INT was on exactly those same seam plays.

Ray Fittipaldo: Watt was getting close to Brady. He just didn't finish. And as I explained earlier he's not someone who plays much in man coverage. He plays well in zone defenses, and the Steelers went away from that against the Patriots.

GeeWhiz: Hi Ray. Is it just me, or does it seem that calls almost ALWAYS go the Patriots way? I know they are a good team, but as soon as I heard the Jesse James catch was in review, I knew, because it was the Patriots, it was going to get over-turned... and that was before I even looked at it a second time in slow motion myself. Thanks for the great chats!

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Look no further than the Brandin Cooks TD ruling vs. Houston and the Austin-Sefarian Jenkins ruling in the Jets game. Both calls favored the Patriots. So that's three game-turning calls, all that were reviewed by Riveron. I don't want to get into conspiracy theories, but that seems mighty odd to me.

CM: Hi Ray. Well another Tomliloss to the Patriots. Do you think it's time to move on from him and go after someone like Adam Gase, who has had success beating the Patriots?

Ray Fittipaldo: Right, because Gase has been such a good head coach.

OKC Dave: In Oklahoma City here, but is it gloom and doom in Pittsburgh today? We're still 11-3, #2 seed and can still win out against awful opponents. Showed we can still score without Brown if we need to for a few weeks. It's not ideal with Brown and Connor out, but it's winnable.

Ray Fittipaldo: I'd be shocked if the Steelers lost to either the Texans or the Browns. I think the concern is another star player getting hurt in one of those games. That's why it would have been nice for them to end things early with a win over the Pats.

Advertise with us

Sam: Why do you think player's aren't taught not to lunge the ball near the goal line....it seems like it backfires almost as much as it succeeds. Just look at Derek Carr last night. If James just catches the ball, he's either in the endzone anyway before being down by contact or the ball is at the half yard line where they can either finally run the forbidden QB sneak or spike it to set up a 3rd down try and then a FG.

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think coaches are into teaching players things that go against their gut football instincts. In other words, James made a natural play and tried to score a TD. I don't think you want to tell him not to do that because in another situation it could backfire. It's just a dumb rule. If I'm a coach I'd have a hard time telling my players to not try and make a play.

T. Lazarus Link, aka, The Bishop: I think this game was lost @ the 4 minute mark, when the Steelers couldn't eat clock and ice the game. But so many "what ifs:" What if James gets tagged down at the 1? What if Brown is in the game for that final drive? What if the Steelers could generate more pass rush? Ray, what did you see as the turning point?

Ray Fittipaldo: The turning point was Alberto Riveron making the ruling from NYC. Let's not lose sight of that. Sure, there were other plays that factored into the loss, but that was the play. I'm still not sure if he made the right call even though the so-called experts say he did.

Chris: Why are people saying that the rule requires you to survive the ground? It does not. The rule requires that the receiver maintain possession after his "initial contact with the ground," which was his knee. He maintained possession and then did a football move (tuck and turn up field). Nowhere does the rule state "survive the ground."

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Right. It's not in the rulebook. I do think it's something the officials talk about among themselves. That's where the problem comes in. The rulebook does state that he has to possess the ball to the ground. So there are people in the NFL who say he made the right call by the letter of the law, and there are others who believe he should have let the officials on the field decide the game. Alberto Riveron decided that he wanted to make the decision on his own and that's what he did. Just as he did in the Patriots-Jets game and just as he did in the Patriots-Texans game earlier in the season.

Guest: isn't there a decent chance Pats lose to Buffalo and Steelers get home field?

Ray Fittipaldo: The Pats play Buffalo at home. I give the Pats a 99 percent chance of winning that game as I do the finale against the Jets, also at home.

Glenn: On one of the last drives, Bell was nowhere to be found. Connor then Toussaint were in. Was Bell getting a breather or was he getting medical attention. I found it odd he was out at that point in the game.

Ray Fittipaldo: I found it odd, too. And I didn't see Bell in the locker room to ask him.

Advertise with us

Florida Steeler: Hey Ray, wondering from what you saw last night (given that rule that made Jesse James TD catch not a catch) do you think this team will be able to beat the Pats in the AFC championship game if we play them? Watching the game I thought the Steelers were the better team and ended up beating themselves instead of actually getting beaten by the Pats

Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers will have a chance at Foxboro, just not as good a chance if the game was at Heinz Field.

T. Lazarus Link, aka, The Bishop: Ray, a lot of people are declaring the race for the #1 seed to be over, but NE still has to face a hungry Buffalo team and a surprisingly good Jets team. Can you see them losing either game?

Ray Fittipaldo: No. Both are at home.

Tony C: I can buy Ben saying Haley said run a play but when nobody was lined up what was Ben thinking or is he just dumb doing what he was told..I mean he's not a rookie

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm sure he went over that in his head a thousand times last night. But again, we're criticizing him when he's making those decisions in a split second. It's hard. I think the biggest problem is someone in the press box not seeing the James replay and notifying the coaches on the sideline that it might be overturned. If that happened then maybe they could have gotten together sooner and devised a better game plan for those final seconds.

jim: I know it's tough to call a penalty on the last play of a game, but wasn't Rogers tackled? Should that be reviewable in your opinion? I know it would slow down the game, but should the goal be to get it right?

Ray Fittipaldo: I thought there was interference there, but they're never going to make that a reviewable play. You just have to count on the officials to make the judgment calls.

angry fan: Will somebody stop the cheatriots from another super bowl?

Ray Fittipaldo: Is that guy from the 2008 Chiefs still playing?

MarkM: I was very disappointed in big Al last night. We went from a first down run of about 8 yards back to 1st and 20 because of his obvious hold. Then he cost us another 5 yards on the next play. We could have a time consuming drive there. What did you think of his performance last night?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not a good sequence for Villanueva. It was an obvious hold. They official called. Heyward was tackled in the backfield a few minutes later on the Patriots' go-ahead drive. It wasn't called. All people want is consistency. The Patriots had two penalties for 4 yards the entire game. The Steelers had six for 63. That's too much of a difference.

I Have A Coupon: Ray just for fun will you put "Corrente Steelers" in a search engine and report back to us on the fun video history you find?

Ray Fittipaldo: Oh good. Some fun after the chat ends.

JC: Did the offense go too conservative in the 4th quarter? I get that AB was out, but Ben was on fire, and they had multiple chances to put the game away before Brady's two minute drill.

Ray Fittipaldo: I wasn't a big fan of the third down call to JuJu SMith-Schuster.

angry fan: Playing man seemed better than the soft zone mess we've put in front of brady for the past 17 years, but it still resulted in them going 70-some yards in 70 seconds when it mattered most. How is that ok?

Ray Fittipaldo: Hay maybe it would have been 70 yards in 40 seconds if they were in zone. And then the Steelers would have had more time at the end... That's it. That's the ticket. Go back to zone.

Chris J.: I don't argue that they applied the rule correctly, however I thought there had to be indisputable evidence to overturn a call? As it was ruled a TD on the field that means that they had to see the ball hit grass with 100% certainty. I have not seen one angle that showed that, have you?

Ray Fittipaldo: You see the ball hit the ground, but the question is whether he loses control. That's a judgment call and it's one Alberto Riveron made from the NFL offices in New York, where he made several other controversial rulings this season. There was even one in the Raiders-Cowboys game last night. There was a guy for the Raiders who bobbled the ball before he hot the ground, then trapped the ball against the ground, and it was ruled a catch by Riveron. It has the appearance that he's just guessing and making it up as he goes along, which very well might be the case.

Renny: Last evening was the classic example of why a team should hurry up and kick the extra point before the referee gets “buzzed” to review the touchdown play. Several weeks ago I was watching another pro game and there was a possible question if the receiver had both feet in bounds. They quickly kicked the extra point and thus the review could not take place.

Ray Fittipaldo: There is no buzz. All TDs are reviewed.

I Have A Coupon: Coaching blunders greatly contributed to yesterdays loss: 2-23 HoF QB hand off to 3rd string RB, Not covering Gronk at all off line/blitz Brady in Shotgun, The slant on the "fake spike" Is Tomlin going to switch from Teflon to Copper Top soon?

Ray Fittipaldo: What would have said if Roethlisberger threw an interception on that second-and-23 play and set up the Patriots with possession in Steelers' territory?

jim: Any chance that the Ravens or Chiefs go to Foxboro and beat the Pats? I like the odds, they both have stout defenses that are better suited to beating Brady than ours.

Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure I'd call the Chiefs defense stout. I actually think the Ravens would have a better chance with their defense. I just don't have any confidence in the Ravens scoring enough to win that game.

Jud: Did the Steelers tip their hand any with their scheme in this game? Do they have enough wrinkles to keep NE guessing the next time they play?

Ray Fittipaldo: So you wanted the coaching staff to hold some things back just in case they might play in the playoffs? They had a chance to secure home-field advantage throughout the playoffs with a win. You empty your playbook in that situation and do everything you can to win.

Jeezy: My biggest issue with the incompletion was that James clearly had control and made a football move (stretching out to cross goal line). Had his arms been outstretched during the catch and not after the catch, I have no issue. Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: I wonder what they would have ruled if James stayed on his knees and stretched the ball across the plane for like 3 seconds. Then the Patriots player knocked him over and the ball came out. In other words, what is the time frame for the catch, you know? There was no Patriots player near him at the time of the catch.

SteelCity21: If they meet again in New England and Brown and Haden are healthy. Would you give the Steelers a chance?

Ray Fittipaldo: Right now, I'd give them a 20 percent chance to win in New England even if Haden and Brown are available. They have an advantage there. Teams go there and have issues with radio communication. They've deflated footballs in cold weather to gain an edge. Who knows what they're up to now. So no, I don't like the Steelers' chances.

Badger: Why no taunting penalty on Gronk after the two point conversion?There seems to be no consistency with any of the officiating in the NFL anymore.

Ray Fittipaldo: Better question: What was Sean Davis doing on that play?

JRCIII: The rule is the rule. Why can't the focus be on there is no CLEAR visual evidence of the ball hitting the ground? The ruling on the field must stand!! Was it New York or Head ref who made that interpretation?

Ray Fittipaldo: Alberto Riveron in the NFL offices overruled the referee on the field. This change was made a few years ago. It used to be Dean Blandino making the calls from NYC. Riveron is in his first year doing the job.

Ray Fittipaldo: OK we went overtime this week. Thanks for all the questions. No chat next week because it's Christmas.