The Steelers rank among the best defenses in the NFL. They’ve held seven of their first nine opponents to 18 points or fewer and are equally stingy when it comes to the total number of yards they allow.

But they’re still in search of their first complete game this season. Other NFL teams would sign in blood for the types of performances the Steelers have put forth this season, but the players weren’t happy after the 20-17 victory against the Colts.

“I feel like when the defense is on — when we want to play — man, we’re on,” second-year strong safety Sean Davis said. “We didn’t give up any points [over the final 28 minutes]. We can do that all four quarters. We’re our own worst enemy. That’s how I feel about this defense. I don’t feel like anyone can touch us. When we’re on, we’re on.”

The “when we want to play” and “we’re our own worst enemy” parts of that quote are interesting. Were the Steelers disinterested early in the game against the Colts? Were they having a hard time acclimating to game conditions after being off for a week? Are they simply not capable of being dominant for a full game?

Advertise with us

All are important questions as the Steelers try to secure the No. 1 seed in the AFC over the final seven games of the regular season. It might seem like nitpicking, but given the way the offense has played through nine games, the defense might have to be dominant if the Steelers are going to make it to the Super Bowl.

“We appreciated the W,” defensive end Cameron Heyward said. “We know how critical it is to get those Ws, but at the same time, there’s always a teaching moment. We didn’t have a perfect game. Those are things we can clean up and take it to the next game.

“We have to start faster earlier, be more consistent, tackle better, more turnovers, more sacks,” Heyward continued. “I thought we had a lot of good pressure. We just didn’t finish the sacks. And stay on the run. Even if you’re surrendering 20 yards in a game, that’s too many. If we can get them to zero or negative yards. … Who is to say we can’t do that?”

Mike Tomlin on Sunday's win over Colts

Another positive of this Steelers defense is its timely big plays. The Steelers needed a turnover in the fourth quarter to tip the game back in their favor, and they got it from their most opportunistic player — inside linebacker Ryan Shazier, whose third interception of the season set up the tying touchdown.

“That was a huge play, but that’s what we expect from him,” Vince Williams said. “He’s one of the best linebackers in the NFL.”

Advertise with us

Shazier was supposed to blitz on the play, but he was stuffed by the line and could not find a lane in which to rush Jacoby Brissett.

“Based off film study I knew Jack Doyle gets a lot of targets, especially in check-downs,” Shazier said. “He started to check down and I saw him. I was trying to make a tackle so we could get off the field, and the ball was right there for me to make a play.”

At that point of the game the Steelers were down two starters in the secondary. Joe Haden and Mike Mitchell exited because of injuries. Haden will be out at least for the next game against the Titans and likely more with a fractured fibula. It is unlikely Mitchell, who injured his ankle, plays either.

The front seven picked up the slack Sunday with Shazier’s interception and two more sacks of Brissett. Heyward admitted the front seven might have to pick up more slack in the next few weeks as Haden and Mitchell heal.

“The first half was not indicative of how we want to play,” Heyward said. “If there are injuries, guys have to step up not only in the back end but front end, too. We have to get more pressure. We have to get ourselves in better situations where we can light our hair on fire and get to the quarterback.”

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.