The Steelers have one of the rising defenses in the NFL. They’re coming off a victory against the Lions when they didn’t allow a touchdown. They finished the first half of the season second in the league in scoring defense, allowing an average of just 16.4 points per game, and they’re also among the top five teams in the league in total defense, pass defense and sacks.
And yet, as the Steelers take a breath at the midway point, there is an old question that dogs them: Can they defend elite quarterbacks?
That’s the same question the Steelers faced after Tom Brady made them look silly in the AFC championship in January. And it’s the same question they face now after Detroit quarterback Matthew Stafford threw for 423 yards and made them look vulnerable against the pass for the first time this season.
“We played a lot of zone, not all zone,” defensive coordinator Keith Butler said. “Some of it was fire zone, which is matchup. We didn’t play very well. We just didn’t play very well at the positions we normally do play very well. They got us a little bit.”
Stafford picked apart the Steelers’ zone defense much in the same way Brady did nine months ago. He found the voids in the soft part of the zone between the corners and safeties. He took advantage of mistakes and blown coverage. He threw deep, intermediate and short routes with equal amounts of success. The only thing he didn’t do was convert in the red zone and score touchdowns.
“There were a few missed assignments, but he’s a great quarterback,” cornerback Joe Haden said. “I would say on a lot of those he was throwing into the holes of the zone. There were a lot of hole shots. There wasn’t a lot of space for him to throw the ball in there, but he was able to hit them. He’s a special quarterback.”
Read More
Stafford’s surgical precision against the Steelers’ zone, which was so reminiscent of Brady’s success against them, brings up another question that was much-discussed over the offseason.
Whatever happened to the promise of more man coverage?
That was arguably the biggest offseason storyline. Steelers coaches said they needed to play more man coverage to be more diverse and thus more effective against the best quarterbacks in the NFL. But that hasn’t taken shape through the first eight games. In fact, the Steelers are playing less man than they did last season, according to Pro Football Focus.
The website that tracks advanced statistics says the Steelers are playing zone about 85-90 percent of the time. They played zone 75 percent of the time last season when they had Ross Cockrell as one of their starting corners. They replaced Cockrell with Haden — a former Pro Bowler — and they’re playing man coverage less.
“When we were talking about playing more man it was just in the event that when we do play man that we practiced it and had the ability to dial it up when we needed to, and I think that’s still the plan,” defensive backs coach Carnell Lake said.
Here’s the dilemma the Steelers face: there are only a small number of quarterbacks in the NFL who can take apart their zone with pinpoint accuracy and decision-making. They just played one of them Sunday night and don’t have to play Brady until Dec. 17 at Heinz Field.
Due to injuries, they won’t have to face Aaron Rodgers of Green Bay or Andrew Luck of Indianapolis. Playing primarily zone against the Brett Hundleys and Jacoby Brissetts of the world — even the Andy Daltons and Joe Flaccos — makes sense because it might be the best way to defend them.
“If we don’t feel like we have to play man to beat you then we’re not going to play man to beat you,” second-year corner Artie Burns said. “We do what we have to do to win to win.”
But there will come a time when playing man coverage might make more sense such as the December home date with Brady and his receivers that don’t always deal well with man coverage.
One of the ways to beat Brady is by getting pressure with four rushers and by playing man coverage, which allows cornerbacks to disrupt their rhythm passing game by jamming and rerouting their receivers at or near the line of scrimmage.
The Patriots, like the Steelers, have two losses this season. One of them came against the Chiefs, who lead the NFL in man coverage percentage. Brady had his worst game of the season against the Chiefs when he completed just 16 of 36 passes for 267 yards with no touchdown passes.
The Falcons, before their coaches handed Super Bowl 51 to the Patriots on a silver platter, had success for the large majority of that game by playing man coverage.
“We’ve kind of been experimenting with a bunch of different things, but coming down the stretch when it starts to get real tight, you might see more of it,” Burns said. “It will depend on who we’re playing.”
When that time does come, Lake won’t be fretting about it.
“I’m comfortable with it,” he said. “I really am. We’ll continue to evolve in that area. The thing about it is we have a full playbook at our disposal now. It helps that Joe has man-to-man coverage ability. If you have guys who can play man you feel comfortable about playing it.”
“Man is probably one of the simplest coverages as far as understanding what you got,” Haden added. “It’s man to man. You got your dude and everyone else has their guy. When you play zone you got guys passing through zones, and it’s a little tougher. In man, you know your assignment. You have to be able to stay on top of your guy.”
Whether the Steelers are good enough in man coverage remains to be seen. Check back in mid-December.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.