
Gerry Dulac: OK kids, lets get our chat started. I see questions lined up like a gas station offering $1.79 per gallon
Scott in Amsterdam: Santonio Holmes obviously deserves to retire a Steeler. However, isn't the timing of this announcement bizarre? He hasn't played in an NFL game since 2014...
Gerry Dulac: Scott, you're first in the store...and yes it is. I think Dan Kreider is going to announce his retirement tomorrow.
Brice: Ed, I have watched the Steelers my whole life, and one thing I have noticed during the "Big Ben" era is that when we are a front runner, we fall short. When we are the underdog that's when we surprise the NFL world. It is my reason for optimism, and I hope the "Ben is done" narrative continues as I beleive this team will thrive on that.
Gerry Dulac: I'll ask Ed
Brice: These EX Steelers coming out and speaking out against the team, are making this drag on even further. THEY NEED TO STOP!
Read More
Gerry Dulac: Yeah!!!
Scott: Mike Tomlin benches Eli Rogers for making a mistake in Chicago and then refuses to take responsibility for his own OBVIOUS errors in the Jacksonville game. Have the players lost respect for him? I could not work for a boss who holds everybody accountable except himself.
Gerry Dulac: No they haven't. But if he believes he did the right thing, even if it was the wrong thing, then he has to be judged for another reason, and it's not accountability
Jacque Strap: Ben had Weds off before the Jax game. Is it common for the starting QB to take practice off, particularly this early in the season? Needs to play better, not enough chemistry with receivers not named AB...well do something about it.
Gerry Dulac: When you're 35, sometimes it's more common. That has nothing to do with anything, trust me.
Carlo: How would you grade Haden and Burns thus far? Seems like teams are not challenging them like years past. Is that due to their play or bc the opposing QB's have been subpar?
Gerry Dulac: I would grade them very well. The longest completion against the Steelers this year is 31 yards, and that came against Jax. Their pass defense is ranked No. 1 in the league. Kinda hard not to say its been best part of their defense.
Carlo: Any idea as to why Eli got benched other than the muffed punt against Chicago?
Gerry Dulac: Have you looked at his numbers? It was time to try something else. You saw how that went, so it's time to go back to Eli.
JerseySteel: Hi Gerry - last year the Steelers started 4-5 and struggled while Marcus Gilbert was out with an injury. They started to roll when he came back. Could the same thing happen this year and is he that critical to the team as it might appear?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think their problems are attributable to Gilbert's absence, but there's no question they are much better when he's in the game. He's one of the best in the league
Carlo: What is main issue with the Steelers run D that you see? We have two Pro Bowl caliber DE's and an up and coming DT. Scheme? OLB's not setting the edge and allowing the RB's to break contain?
Gerry Dulac: I think you have a couple young outside LBs, TJ Watt and Bud Dupree, who don't have enough experience with their other defensive mates to be cohesive. Same with Vince Williams, in his first year as a starter. If I started explaining what's happening, I might be here a while. But from everything I gather and i'm told, that's the biggest problem.
JerseySteel: Hi Gerry - the Steelers failed to score in the red zone 3 more times vs the Jaguars. Did the Seven shots throughout training camp make no measurable difference in their red zone efficiency? Is it because the other team knows they will always pass and don't have to defend the run in the red zone?
Gerry Dulac: Training camp drills have nothing to do with trying to score in the red zone against a defense that has schemed against you.
Austin meador: would you say the lack of production from martavis is due to missing a year and trying to get back in rhythm or is play calling hurting him.
Gerry Dulac: I think the play-calling is a result of him missing an entire season. He is not the same player right now
Bob Sugar: Does this team truly lack leadership in the locker room as Hines Ward suggests?
Gerry Dulac: That's easy to say when the team has lost a couple games. How was the leadership in Baltimore after all the nonsense? How was the leadership last year when they were 4-5 and won nine in a row.
Jon: Gerry. Players complaining about game plan or being out coached, flipping over water coolers, posting images on twitter that they don't play. Has Coach Tomlin lost this team? They don't seem to worry about any ramification for actions.
Gerry Dulac: That's today's athlete and that's why fans are turned off by what they are seeing and reading, especially on social media. All the things you mentioned are annoying to the outside but pretty much don't register a blip on the inside. That is not to excuse such behavior. I'm weary of it too. Bell said the Steelers didn't run enough Jax, basically complaining he didn't get the ball enough. Well, he had 25 touches, as much or more than most games, and he didn't do much with his touches. What does it matter if he runs or catches a pass? He's still getting the ball. In fact, those short passes he's catching are designed to get him space and create room for him to run when the defense is stacking the box. Did you check his numbers on those catches designed to get him in space and make plays? Let me give them to you -- 10 catches for 42 yards, or 4.2 yards per catch.
Gerry Dulac: Not to be critical.
Bob Sugar: Too much elevator music and not enough focus? Something is wrong
Gerry Dulac: It's not focus. It's execution. It's not playing. It's not performing. Relax. It's a long season. Again, I will remind you what happened last season.
Jon: If the team gets crushed by the Chiefs this week (Likely will). Is Mike Tomlin officially on the hot seat? Too much talent to go 3-3. Your thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: No
Andy: Greetings Gerry. Thank you for your time. I try and stay away from the finger pointing regarding the criticisms aimed at the Steeler coaching staff. However, after 1st and goal and throwing 3 passes when you have 3 stud backs, I'm going to point a finger!! That made no sense! And what kind of message does that send to your offensive line when it needs a confidence boost? What gives!?
Gerry Dulac: Pay the man! I concur
Kid From SC: Gerry we fans love to compare and contrast as you know, who in your personal opinion (obviously the book is still somewhat unwritten) to this point was/is the better leader/coach for the Steelers Cowher or Tomlin and why?
Gerry Dulac: I don't do that and I won't. They are both 1-1 in Super Bowls. Cowher went to the postseason 10 times in 15 seasons. Tomlin has gone six in 10. Both had a similar quality -- their teams didn't quit on them. You decide
Jonathan Mason: Based on Bryant's play thus far, wouldn't you rather see Eli Rogers and JuJu get more routes to open up the intermediate passing game? The majority of what I've seen from Bryant has been screens and shallow crosses.
Gerry Dulac: No, I wouldn't. The only way Bryant is going to regain form is to play, even if his level of play is nowhere near what it used to be.
Kid From SC: In the days of Casey Hampton I remember the heavy weight NT eating up two blockers and freeing our linebackers to chase the ball, how do you feel Hargrave has done freeing up Shazier? I personally see Shazier getting blown up by guards just like he did at OSU and feel the NT play has been poor.
Gerry Dulac: You are right about the Hampton part. That was the key. But you are wrong about Hargrave. He is very good. You see what he did the other day when he finally got to play a lot (33 snaps)? Led the team with 10 tackles. And Shazier's strength is not filling gaps, it's running thru them. If he doesn't, look out
Joe: How can Tomlin defend his challenges on Sunday? Ray Charles saw the ball hit the ground on the throw to AB.
Gerry Dulac: I agree. Admit you goofed. Or that someone did. It's OK.
Bob: I believe Marty Morningweg earned a game ball for the Steelers win over Baltimore. Had he stuck to the outside zone runs a bit more the Steelers would be 2-3. Do you agree?
Gerry Dulac: What if, what if, what if
Larry in KY: Of Ben's 3 picks, two were tipped and Jesse should/could have come back to the ball to prevent another. What say you?
Gerry Dulac: It's football. Stuff happens. Excuses.
Joe: Ben does not seem to do a lot of film study of opponents compared to his peers. Brady, Manning did a ton. I don't think he's a compulsive worker on his game and these habits are showing up as he gets older. Agree?
Gerry Dulac: How do you know this?
Brice: Gerry, apologize for putting Ed name in first question. Watching the All-22 tape, Martavis is getting open, and Ben is for whatever reason not able to get him the ball. Do you think this is O-Line not holding up long enough to push the ball downfield, or is Ben looking these plays off too early?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think protection is the problem. And other critics complain he is staring down receivers. Easy to nit-pick when you lose. he played poorly against Jax. He knows it. His teammates know it. It happens.
Jonathan Mason: Why is Bryant being used so much in the horizontal passing game? He's best with intermediate to deep routes.
Gerry Dulac: Bingo, hold your cards!
Bestmike : As a die hard Steelers fans the pattern under Tomlin is fairly easy to read , Example we Play well Against Ravens then no show against a team we should beat and now we go to KC and will probably silence the critics with a win.....Seems like a lot of ups and downs with Tomlins when it comes to Schedules...Thoughts ?
Gerry Dulac: Yeah, it also looks like a lot of wins, a lot of postseason appearances, the third-best winning percentage among active coaches, two Super Bowls. Could it be more because of those losses to lesser teams? Sure. But it could also be less if he didn't beat those good teams. I'm not defending him, just pointing up the Steelers win a lot of games under him, no matter what you think of him. And, yes, I think they go to KC and win.
steeler fan from toronto: Hey Gerry, I traveled with my family from Toronto on sunday to see this game, and obviously very disapointed in the steelers play. But i got a gut feeling they pull out a win Sunday in KC.
Gerry Dulac: You might be right
Guest: If Ben still has "it," what do you think is the cause of his poor play this season?
Gerry Dulac: I'd say it's because he's playing poorly.
Jeff: Hi Gerry, how divided do you think the locker room is? Too many I's and not enough we's?
Gerry Dulac: Not at all. The defense sits with the offense and the offense sits with the defense. Everybody plays nice. No division.
Joe: The Jags seemed to suggest, as did Jesse James, that the Steelers' offensive play calls were predictable. Do you think they need to be a lot more creative offensively and scheme to get other WRs not named AB open? If so, is that an indictment of Haley, or of Ben for changing the play calls?
Gerry Dulac: They are so many factors that go into what play is called, how it is read and how it is executed. Do you really think Ben goes in the huddle and says I'm going to throw to AB on this play and it happens? It doesn't work that way. Pre-snap and post-snap reads of the defense will dictate what he does with the ball.

Chuck: Yes, Ben has been bad this year but the passing game decline started last year. Look at his WR's (outside of Ab) from last year and where they are today - Ayers, Hamilton, Rogers, DHB, Coates and Wheaton. Total of 5 catches in 2017. This years addition of Bryant, Hunter and JuJu havent really been consistent. Do you see a lack of talent at WR as part of the reason for Ben's decline?
Gerry Dulac: Hey, I thought this receiving corps was supposed to be one of the greatest of all-time?????
Chuck: ESPN showed highlights of Pitt's LB's out of position and not holding the edge or over running plays which led to the long Jax runs. Do you think Harrison should dress vs KC based on his ability he showed in last years game? I get he doesnt play special teams but you cant tell me hes not one of out 53 best players. Eric Fisher will be so happy w Tomlin if 92 doesnt get a hat.
Gerry Dulac: Agreed on both points. But one thing the Steelers don't want to do is retard TJ Watt's development by letting Harrison play. That's what happened to a large degree with Jarvis Jones. They don't wanty to do that again. And it's not as though Watt is the sole problem. But he's young and learning and gives you so much more than what Harrison can give at age 39.
Gerry Dulac: Well, kids, that's all the time we have today. Thanx for the questions. Bye now.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.