Once upon a time, the Jacksonville Jaguars were in the same division with the Steelers, beginning with their expansion season in 1995 and lasting for seven years. They met twice a year as part of the five-team AFC Central and produced games that were not only physical, but spiced with enough bizarre moments to fill a “30-for-30” documentary.
In the course of 23 lifetime meetings, their budding rivalry saw accusations of threatening phone calls and kicks to the groin, an unconscionable spike of a live ball, a shockingly quick hook of a season-opening quarterback, six field goals by a newly signed kicker, an intrusive mascot who paid for getting too close to the opposing huddle and a coach getting ready to go all Woody Hayes on an opposing player who had just ruined his team’s chance at victory – and on the same field, no less.
While the Steelers had a nasty rivalry with the Oakland Raiders in the 1970s and a slightly more civil rivalry with the Houston Oilers in the 1980s, the 1990s brought the dawn of a twice-a-year competition with the Jaguars that never had the same level of postseason significance but certainly was just as contentious and equally as strange.
“There were just a lot of weird games down there for sure,” said former Steelers coach Bill Cowher. “Every time we went down there, I just always felt like something was going to happen.”
Probably because something always did.
Cowher had an 8-9 lifetime record against the Jaguars, one of only two losing records he had against NFL teams in which he has met at least five times.
Read More
In 1994, the league gave the expansion Jacksonville and Carolina franchises a full year to prepare for their debut season. So Jaguars Coach Tom Coughlin spent an inordinate amount of games in the Three Rivers Stadium press box, scouting the Steelers and studying their methods for success.
It worked. The Jaguars stunned the Steelers, 20-16, the first time they met in 1995. After that, the Steelers lost four more times in Jacksonville before finally winning their first-ever game there on Oct. 1, 2000 – a game remembered for rookie receiver Plaxico Burress jumping to his feet after a key reception and excitedly spiking a live ball that the Jaguars recovered as a fumble.
Despite the loss to the Jaguars in their first-ever meeting, the Steelers advanced to the Super Bowl that season. One year later, the Jaguars reached the AFC title game in just their second season of existence and followed with records of 11-5, 11-5 and 14-2.
“They were one of the better expansion teams that came out,” Cowher said the other day in a phone interview. “I think who they got — (left tackle) Tony Boselli in the draft, Mark Brunell from Green Bay, they got Jimmy Smith, (Keenan) McCardell, Fred Taylor — they were a very good team. Obviously, they went to the AFC championship game. But those were always very physical games for sure.”
“It was a good one, it started off very intense,” former Steelers safety Carnell Lake said of the rivalry. Lake got to experience both sides of the competition, leaving the Steelers in free agency after the 1998 season and playing two years with the Jaguars. “They were always very tough for a young franchise and a new team. It was surprising. They came in and did quite well.”
The Jaguars (2-2) and Steelers (3-1) meet at 1 p.m. Sunday at Heinz Field and much has changed. They have not beaten the Steelers since they did it twice at Heinz Field in a three-week span of the 2007 season, culminating with a 31-29 victory in an AFC wild-card playoff game. However, dating to their inception, the Jaguars hold a 12-11 lifetime edge on the Steelers.
After going 17-63 the past five seasons, the Jaguars brought back Coughlin in January as executive vice president to oversee football operations, hoping he can re-ignite past success.
“It ended up being a pretty good rivalry,” said former Steelers quarterback Jim Miller, who played an integral role in one of the early meetings between the teams. “There wasn’t a whole lot of love lost between the teams.”
One-half quarterback
Before the 1996 season opener in Jacksonville, Cowher reacted to what he called a “gut feeling” and started Miller, a third-year quarterback, over veteran Mike Tomczak and Kordell Stewart. The Steelers were coming off a Super Bowl appearance and the Jaguars were 4-12 in their inaugural season.
It was so hot that day the Steelers had a dozen players leave the field during pregame warm-ups to receive IVs. One of them was Jerome Bettis, who was having a severe asthma attack.
“I told Kordell I need you at receiver right now for another year and no one really won the [quarterback] job,” Cowher said. “When you go into a two-quarterback decision and say, ‘Who’s the best guy to give me a lift coming off the bench?,’ you don’t have many positive thoughts going in if that’s the basis of your decision.”
Miller led the Steelers to two field goals on the opening five drives and was 9 of 17 for 83 yards, but the Steelers trailed at halftime, 14-6. That was enough for Cowher. He yanked Miller at halftime and inserted Tomczak. The Steelers still lost, 24-9, but Tomczak was the starter for the remainder of the season and the team managed to make the playoffs.
The Steelers had an even bigger loss that game. Outside linebacker Greg Lloyd, their emotional leader, sustained a torn patella tendon in his left knee and would miss the remainder of the season. Before the game, Jaguars guard Brian DeMarco accused Lloyd of kicking him in the groin the previous season.
“From my perspective, if you name me the guy, I think I should have got more time to settle in,” Miller said the other day over the phone. “We were a veteran team, we had a good defense, we had a good run game. With all the injuries, he felt that Mike Tomzcak was better suited for the team to not go through the growing pains of a young quarterback.”
One year later, things got really hot in Jacksonville again, but this time is wasn’t so much the temperature.
Trailing 23-21 with only seconds remaining, Steelers kicker Norm Johnson lined up for a 40-yard field goal that would have won the game. But the attempt was blocked and returned for a touchdown by defensive back Chris Hudson. As Hudson was running down the sideline in front of the Steelers bench, Cowher took a step toward the field and cocked his arm as though he wanted to slug Hudson as he raced past him. He didn’t, of course.
“It was the same sideline Woody Hayes punched that guy, almost the same spot on the field,” Cowher said.
He was referring to the incident in the 1978 Gator Bowl when the former Ohio State coach slugged a Clemson player who had just intercepted a pass and ran in front of the Buckeyes bench. Hayes was fired by the school the next day. That same playing field was retained when the Gator Bowl was refurbished and reopened as Jacksonville Municipal Stadium (later Alltell Stadium), the new home for the Jaguars.
On the Steelers’ next visit to northern Florida, there was another incident from the sidelines that threatened to turn ugly. The Jaguars’ mascot, Jaxson de Ville, came onto the field near the Steelers huddle and began taunting their players, angering, among others, owner Dan Rooney.
For his part, the mascot was the target of what he called “not so nice words from the players” and having “bodily fluid projected toward me.”
That same year, Lloyd crushed McCardell with a vicious blindside hit in a 23-17 overtime victory at Three Rivers Stadium, retaliation for what Lloyd claimed was a threatening phone call made by McCardell to his house the week of the game.
“I don’t know if it’s the chemistry,” former Steelers safety Lee Flowers once said, “but for some reason, when Jacksonville and the Steelers get on the field, there’s just all kind of drama going on.”
Steelers get their kicks
It took five years, but the Steelers finally won a game in Jacksonville in 2000, overcoming Burress’ inexplicable gaffe for a 24-13 victory. Still, they lost six of their first seven road games to the Jaguars, setting the stage for what happened in 2002 — the game Cowher remembers most of all.
Two weeks before the game, the Steelers held a tryout at Heinz Field to find a replacement for injured kicker Todd Peterson. The winner was Jeff Reed, 23, who played at North Carolina but had never kicked in an NFL game.
All Reed did in his second NFL game was tie a single-game team record with six field goals, ranging from 25 to 50 yards, in a 25-23 victory that raised the Steelers’ division-leading record to 7-4-1.
“We had three kickers [at the tryout] and he was the youngest,” Cowher said. “He said to me after we picked him, ‘Can I go home and get my stuff?’ I said no, stay here, you’re on a one-game trial basis, one game at a time.
“He went down to Jacksonville and kicked six field goals and we won. I told him the next day, you can go home and get your stuff, you’re going to be here a while.”
Ben Roethlisberger won his first game in Jacksonville during his 2004 rookie season, and it was typical of the performances he engineered that year. Trailing with 1:55 remaining in a Sunday night game, Roethlisberger led the offense 56 yards on six plays with no timeouts left, setting up Reed’s winning 37-yard field goal for a 17-16 victory.
One year later, Roethlisberger did not play against the Jaguars at Heinz Field because of a knee injury, giving Tommy Maddox the start. With the score tied at the end of regulation at 17-all, the Steelers began overtime at the Jaguars 26 following a 74-yard kick return by Quincy Morgan. But, on third-and-11, Maddox fumbled and the Jaguars recovered, ending the threat.
One possession later, Maddox threw his third interception of the game and cornerback Rashean Mathis returned the pick 41 yards for a touchdown and a 23-17 victory.
The Steelers had similar bad luck at home just two years later when they lost to the Jaguars, 29-22, on Dec. 16, and then again, 31-29, in an AFC wild-card playoff game on Jan. 5. Fred Taylor ran for 147 of the Jaguars’ 224 rushing yards in the regular-season victory; and Mathis had two more interceptions in the playoff victory, including a 63-yard touchdown return.
Since then, the Steelers and Jaguars have met three times. The Steelers have won all three, including two at the site where they always seemed to be tormented.
“It seemed like we were always going down there in September and we had to wear our black jerseys and we had a 1 o’clock game,” Cowher said. “Jerome [Bettis] had his asthma, he’s dealing with that with his oxygen, and I’m like, every year I got to deal with this in September.”
All part of what made this one-time rivalry so intriguing.
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.