BALTIMORE — A 15-star, 15-stripe American flag swished in a slight breeze above Fort McHenry at 12:58 p.m. Sunday when four Air Force A-10 aircrafts, flying in formation, screamed overhead. A tour guide pointed skyward and traced the planes’ path toward M&T Bank Stadium, 3 miles northwest, where they were on time for a national anthem flyover.
The story of America’s national anthem began 203 years ago at Fort McHenry. On Sept. 14, 1814, Francis Scott Key watched from aboard a United States truce ship as the bastion fort survived a 25-hour bombardment from the British navy. When the shelling ceased and ships retreated, the Fort McHenry garrison hoisted a large red-white-and-blue, stars-and-stripes flag.
The sight inspired Key to pen “The Defense of Fort M’Henry,” a poem later adapted into a song, renamed “The Star-Spangled Banner” and adopted as the national anthem. The anthem, recognized as a symbol of patriotism and unity, also is a vessel for protest. And few have resonated so loudly as the protests that engulfed the National Football League recently.
Central in the controversy — a protest started by former NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick to bring awareness to police brutality and racism and stirred up by President Donald Trump — is a desire that many people, particularly fans, share for sports to be an escape from reality, a safe haven from politics and other broken systems. They want sports to be sports. Nothing else.
That’s how Jodi Miller feels. She toured Fort McHenry on Sunday morning wearing an Antonio Brown jersey. She traveled from Mission Viejo, Calif., to attend the Steelers-Ravens game with friends from Severn, Md., Army veteran Chris Siemens and Kim Caldwell, a civil servant in the Air Force. Ms. Miller, whose father served in the military, asked to visit the fort before the game.
“I love history,” she said, “and this place is part of history.”
Read More
Ms. Miller wished the Steelers hadn’t been pulled into the protests. She believes their stance was misconstrued by the media. Players should be permitted to stand, sit or kneel during the national anthem, she said, as it is their right to protest peacefully. Still, she would prefer that sports stick to sports.
“Twenty years ago, this probably wouldn’t have been an issue,” Ms. Miller said. “Times are different now. We just want to watch sports. We just want to be entertained. to escape and have a good time. That’s how it should be.”
She paused, then added, “We’ll see what happens today in the stadium.”
An hour later, a plane above M&T Bank Stadium tugged a sign that read, “Stand & Respect Our Flag.” Fans booed when the Ravens players knelt for a pregame prayer. Both teams stood, as they had said they would, for the national anthem. The public address announcer reminded an antsy crowd that the anthem was “written right here in Baltimore.” Key’s original draft is on display a short walk away at the Maryland Historical Society’s museum.
Elsewhere in the NFL Sunday, dozens of players knelt during the national anthem and a few raised their fists in signs of protest. At some stadiums, fans were encouraged to link arms. In Denver, Oakland Raiders running back Marshawn Lynch wore an “Everybody vs. Trump” T-shirt before the game, then sat during the anthem.
In Washington, D.C., the city where the flag flown above Fort McHenry’s ramparts in 1814 now resides at the National Museum of American History, the Pirates and Washington Nationals concluded the regular season Sunday afternoon. No players protested during the national anthem. Only one Major League Baseball player, the Oakland A’s Bruce Maxwell, has taken a knee.
The Nationals’ Dusty Baker, one of two black managers in the majors, was a Marine Corps reservist from 1968 to 1974. When asked Saturday whether spectators are wrong to seek sports as a sanctuary, he replied, “Well, it’s a sanctuary for us, too.” There is inherent conflict: Fame offers athletes a platform for protest, but many fans don’t like when they use it.
“Sports can’t be silent,” Mr. Baker said. “They want you to be silent, but this is a microcosm of our whole society. It’s more of a microcosm than probably any other occupation in the world. How many different jobs have as many Latin Americans, blacks, whites, Europeans, Asians — American and from Asia — Africans. You understand? So how can it be separate?
“These guys have ideas. They’ve all been raised differently. They’ve got some Republicans in [the clubhouse]. They’ve got some Democrats. They have some Trump supporters. They have some Hillary Clinton supporters. … So how can it be separate? They’re actually like the fans themselves, but they’ve just got a baseball uniform on, and you go watch them play.”
Mr. Baker, born in Riverside, Calif., was raised reading the Pittsburgh Courier, an African-American newspaper, and Ebony, Jet and Sepia magazines. He said he didn’t tell his players whether they should protest during the national anthem. Their opinion is theirs, he said. It seems to him there were more protests when he was young, but that makes this situation no less serious.
“There was anti-Vietnam. There was riots. There was segregation,” Mr. Baker said. “There were more things then than there are now. Things have improved in many ways, but they’ve regressed in many other ways. We have a problem. Anybody who doesn’t think we have a problem, they need to look around and ask the young people. And we do have a problem.”
Noah Seth is a young person. He is 16. He studies at Gilman School, a private school in Baltimore, and dreams of one day attending Stanford University. He is a Ravens fan. He and his mother went to Fort McHenry at midday Sunday to walk around. He initially was wary when Mr. Kaepernick’s protests seemed to draw more attention than the issues he was protesting.
But as a black teenager, Noah is aware of those issues. He’s bothered by the stereotypes that paint black people as violent or aggressive, and he’s horrified by how that has materialized in police brutality toward black people. Much of the general public, he said, seems shrouded by a certain ignorance — willful or otherwise — about the violence and injustice.
Earlier Sunday, Noah and another buddy showed a close friend, a white kid they have known since sixth grade, a 2014 video of Eric Garner being locked in a chokehold by a police officer in New York City. Mr. Garner died on the sidewalk. Noah has seen the video several times.
“After my friend sees [Mr. Garner] saying, ‘I can’t breathe. I can’t breathe,’ my friend asked, ‘Did that guy die?’ ” Noah recalled. “We were like, yeah, that guy died. [The friend] was blissfully unaware, because that was not something societally or culturally he really has to deal with. That ignorance is why I think the protests are worthwhile.”
Noah, like Ms. Miller, prefers to keep sports and politics separate. In this case, he said, the intersection was unavoidable. When Mr. Trump rebuked NFL owners for not firing players who protested during the national anthem, he brought politics to sports. The vacation was over. Noah believes there are better ways to protest — and the target of the protests has changed, morphing into a rally for overall unity — but the league had no time for another answer.
“I think the president brought this on himself,” Noah said. “He started attacking NFL players who are protesting, calling them sons of [expletive]. That is now his fault. This became a political issue, where all of the NFL is like, look, these individuals are people who under the First Amendment have a right to protest these issues that they want to bring awareness to.”
Behind Noah, beyond the four cannons aimed toward Chesapeake Bay, a man wearing a Ravens jersey tossed a Frisbee with his son. Nearby, a tour guide told of the Americans in the War of 1812, an underdog army in an un-winnable war. And for one sun-soaked day at Fort McHenry, the birthplace of the national anthem, sports, politics and harmony converged.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.
Want in-depth Steelers coverage all season long?



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.