
Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Let's get started.
Scott in Amsterdam: I think most people (including myself) considered Cobi Hamilton one of the easier WR cuts, but now I'm not so sure....your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Hamilton had a nice game against the Giants and he's played pretty well in camp overall. But for me, I remember the AFC championship game when he didn't play very well. That's who he is. Justin Hunter or Sammie Coates, or even Darrius Heyward-Bey, are better options in my opinion.
Scott in Amsterdam: Why was Justin Hunter no where to be seen against the Giants? I didn't see any reports on him being injured...
Ray Fittipaldo: He's been in and out of practice for the past week or so with a knee issue. Doesn't seem like anything major, but obviously was enough to prevent him from playing Friday night.
Scott in Amsterdam: Who are the lesser known guys that advanced their case the most in that first preseason game?
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: Mike Hilton, the slot corner who is second-team behind William Gay right now, was very good against the Giants. I thought Terrell Watson, the undrafted RB, was pretty good too. I think Hilton is earning a pot on the 53-man roster. Watson could be ticketed for the practice squad.
Scott in Amsterdam: Tomlin's post-game comments seem to imply that Arthur Moats is in the doghouse...am I wrong?
Ray Fittipaldo: I didn't read them that way at all. It was Tomlin trying to say that's what an eight-year veteran should do against mostly backup offensive linemen. Moats was in a unique situation because Joey Porter only had three OLBs at his disposal due to injuries and James Harrison not being active yet.
Dionsteelernation4life: Hi ray love your chats I read them every Monday 2 questions. One where do u think Brian Allen ultimately winds up on the 53 or ps with the cb injuries not much other than Hilton as comp question 2 are the Steelers real players in trading for Johnson from rams or its more rumor than truth I don't think so but I do think we need another established cb on the roster cockrell can't play man all that well
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they'll try to get Allen on the practice squad. As for the Trumaine Johnson rumor, Keith Butler was asked about that Sunday when I did an interview with him. He said he's heard the rumor, but he never gets excited because he hears all kinds of rumors every year during camp.
Scott in Amsterdam: What did you think about the performance of Knile Davis against the Giants? To me, it confirmed my suspicions: he doesn't have the speed or the footwork to break for big gains.
Ray Fittipaldo: They're looking for a third-string RB. He doesn't have to be Gayle Sayers. I thought he has been OK in camp. If he makes the team it will be because of his ability to return kickoffs, too. I don't think they signed him only to play RB. Their kick return game has been lacking and Davis has a strong track record in that department.
Tom M88: Hi Ray, What is the likelihood of Terrell Watson making the team?
Ray Fittipaldo: Better than three weeks ago but still not great. It'll be Bell, Conner and either Davis, Toussaint or Watson. He's at least put himself in the conversation for a roster spot. Could be around on the practice squad too.
Lee: Hey ray do you really think a deal will get done with bell next year with the amount of money he wants?? Or do you think they will tag him or let him walk??
Ray Fittipaldo: Tag again or let him walk. I don't think they'll do a long-term deal with him unless he lowers his asking price.
uk AD: Hi Ray, Do you think that Hilton will make the team?Also Allen what have seen from him so far?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I think Hilton will make the team. The injuries to Sutton and Golson gave him an opportunity and he's made the most of it. Allen has been OK. I think he'll be on the practice squad if he clears waivers.
charles demarr: Any chance they can keep 6 WRs and 4 RBs?
Ray Fittipaldo: Doubt it. They'll keep three and Roosevelt Nix.
charles demarr: Final CB to make the roster? Seems like a 3 way battle between Allen, Hilton and Senquez.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Hilton has a decided edge.
charles demarr: Jerald Hawkins looked slow and sluggish Friday. Has he showed any better in camp?
Ray Fittipaldo: I thought he was much last summer as a rookie. Probably why Chris Hubbard started in place of Villanueva Friday night. Hawkins maybe isn't ready to the top backup tackle.
Jon: Ray. personally I think Levy Bell is overrated. Any chance this ends with him being traded in off season? It would have been nice to move him on draft day. I just knew this guy would would be a ME player and not a team player. Just not a fan of his.
Ray Fittipaldo: No tread. He'll either get tagged again or the Steelers will allow him to become a free agent.
Mike Heil: Given Bell's exceptional demands for a new contract, and his propensity to miss multiple games each season, are the Steelers going to try and bring in another high quality back, whether off of waivers or through a trade, this year?
Ray Fittipaldo: No, that's why they used a third-round pick on James Conner.
Jeff: I think that the Steelers are still vulnerable in 2 areas,one at a backup QB and CB,do you see the Steelers possibly taking a flyer on Kap or inviting Reevis to camp?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't see either of the moves you mentioned, but CB remains an issue. I wrote about it yesterday. http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2017/08/13/Pittsburgh-Stee...
CoSteeler: We know how TJ Watt looked vs the pass but how did he look against the run?
Ray Fittipaldo: He looked solid in all facets.
AJ: Read the article about questions remaining about the secondary. My question is, to play man, do all 3 CBs on the field have to do it? Or is there any defensive scheme where Burns plays man and Gay & Cockrell play zone?
Ray Fittipaldo: No, they can play matchup zone with one CB playing man and others playing zone. There are all different types of coverages, but Butler would like to play man across the board if he can.
AJ: Think there's any truth to the rumor the Steelers are interested in a trade for Trumaine Johnson? With Sutton's development so far behind, I can only hope it's true.
Ray Fittipaldo: Trumaine Johnson makes something like $17 million a year. Don't see it happening, but the rumors are out there for a reason. The Steelers remain in search of a CB who can play in man coverage.
Rose: Hi Ray, do you think the Steelers will eventually trade for a cornerback yet again?
Ray Fittipaldo: Sutton is back at practice, at least on a limited basis. So let's see how he does in the next week or so. If he plays well there might not be a need to make a trade.
AJ: The RBs who played Friday did not look good. All hope rests on Conner doing well & remaining healthy. Do you think if Bell or Conner had a long term injury, they would call D'Angelo Williams? Even at his age and with risk of injury he's got to be considered better than Toussaint & Davis.
Ray Fittipaldo: No. Williams is 35 and his best days are behind him.
SteelerFanatic: With overloaded depth at WR do you think Steelers should look to trade one as opposed to just outright releasing?
Ray Fittipaldo: What makes you think anyone would want Heyward-Bey if they release him? Or Justin Hunter for that matter. He was signed in March for the league minimum.
TheStandard: How should Tomlin handle Bell when he does return? Is missing training camp just "business" and Tomlin is happy he is back or does Tomlin deem the holdout unacceptable and do/say something in privte/public?
Ray Fittipaldo: He'll be welcomed back with open arms when he returns.
Devin B: How do you think corner situation pans out? Do you think Mike Hilton has a chance to make the team as well as Brian Allen? They both showed some things on Friday night.
Ray Fittipaldo: Hilton should make the 53-man roster and Allen should be on the practice squad.
IzzySteel43: Will James Conner play against the falcons this upcoming sunday?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would hope so. He needs to start doing something.
Vince: Ray, can you pin point the reasons that the Steelers have had so many injuries this training camp: Perhaps they need to change their off-season training regimen
Ray Fittipaldo: I honestly don't know if there are more than other years. They've just been hit hard in the secondary.
TheStandard: Can Mike Hilton be the Gay replacement or is he not a slot corner?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think he has a shot of unseating Gay. Any CB who makes the roster would have to have that capability. Keith Butler isn't making his plans to find someone capable of playing man coverage a secret.
TheStandard: I hear people complain about Mike Hilton's size, but we did draft Golson, 5'9, in the 2nd round and he hasn't be able to finish camp.
Ray Fittipaldo: Hilton has looked very good, but teams shy away from 5-9 CBs for a reason. When the regular season gets here opposing offensive coordinators will be looking for mismatches and they'll seek him out.
Ju Ju Bean: Love the chats Ray. Are the Steeler coaches as excited about TJ Watt's performance and non-stop motor as the fans are? He looks like the complete opposite of Jarvis Jones.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes they are. Look for a story this afternoon by Ed on this very subject.
Ju Ju Bean: Tyson Alualu looked impressive when he got in. IS he strictly an end, or can he spell Javon Hargrave too?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think he can play nose, too, but he's mostly played DE in camp.
Austin: Is there any chance the Steelers and Stephon Tuitt come to terms on a long term deal by the end of camp?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I think there is a chance.
Anthony in GA: Hi Ray! Love the chats! Read an article in the Post a few days ago debating which players were the top 10 Steelers of all time. How high or low would you rank James Harrison? Not in most's top 10, but top 15?
Ray Fittipaldo: Top 20 probably off the top of my head. I'd have to sit down and make a list to be sure though.
Lambert"s Gang: Hey Ray, What do you think the fan's reaction is going to be once Bell is back out there? Do you think there will be a backlash if he comes out and doesn't perform well in his first few outings?
Ray Fittipaldo: If he doesn't perform well there will be all sorts of negative reaction from fans. But his track record suggests it will be the opposite.
Johnny: In your opinion which Steelers team had the best secondary...also when are the final cuts to get to the final 53
Ray Fittipaldo: The final cuts come the day after the final preseason game... As for the best Steelers secondary that one with Woodson and Lake in the 1990s was pretty good. So was the one with Blount and Shell and Wagner in the 1970s.
Charlotte John: Ray, Can you tell me more about Cornerback Mike Hilton? Is he someone that could shock the league by coming from nowhere and be a viable starter OR is he strictly a nice story to possibly make the team and provide some depth?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would guess the latter, but who knows? Sometimes all it takes for a guy is the right team, the right defense, the right time, etc. Maybe he turns into something more than a nice story.
Hard Head: This is the year if the defense falters it will be on the coaching staff. It's been 10 years now not playing press man coverage even with elite players. The coaches will own the blame. Even if Keith Butler and Tomlin feel due to injuries the proper personnel wouldn't be in there they need to play a lot of press man coverage. What's the worse that can happen in the Playoffs, we get beat again by Brady or another elite QB??? What are your thoughts Ray? Thank you.
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, they know they need to play man against certain teams (New England, for example). But I also think they know playing man with Will Gay would be disastrous. That's why they didn't do it much in the title game. So you do need personnel. I suppose you can blame the coaches, but the front office would bear some responsibility, too. The coaches coach who is on the roster.

John: Hamilton, Severin and Tucker all made poitive plays against the Giants, yet I hear nothing at all about them from any source except a very small nod to Severin from Mike Tomlin. Are they really that far down the pecking order that no one even gives them a little love?
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, Severin was cut a little while ago so that's probably all you need to know.
John: Butler came out and said if you can't get on the field we can't keep you about Golson, yet we know he has a hammie that is not going to allow him on the field anytime soon. Is that the farewell speech?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's looking that way, yes.
Guido: I'm rooting for him, but Dobbs arm did not look particularly strong. Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: He had some positive and some negative moments in the game. At least he bounced back after a tough start. I don't know about you, but I didn't necessarily have high expectations.
John from Va.: Thank you for taking my question, with the first preseason game in the books. T.J. Watt had a nice game with the 2 sacks. Watson looks like he could be a beast. Do you think both may see some first team reps?
Ray Fittipaldo: Watt yes. Watson no.
MikefromVA: Hi Ray, Cobi Hamilton looked great on Friday. Between him and Demarcus Ayers, who's had the better camp? Any chance they cut DHB and keep both of the young guys?
Ray Fittipaldo: About the same.
John: I like Dirty Red and his nose for the ball. How confident should I be about him being the primary back up at both ILB spots?
Ray Fittipaldo: I thought he played well. He's been solid call camp.
Y-TownSteeler: I am so excited for the return of Martavis Bryant. Do you think we could see 2 - 1,000 yard receivers with 10 touchdowns each? AB obviously being the other.
Ray Fittipaldo: If they both play 16 games, yes.
Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for all the questions this week. We'll do it again next week.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.