First NFL preseason games do not often make for lasting impressions because of all the light star power playing for both sides and understudies moving everywhere.
Yet for those who are trying to either make the ballclub or move up in the pecking order, those first looks could validate what they did through the first two weeks of training camp.
Thus, Mike Tomlin came away from the Steelers’ 20-12 win against the New York Giants Friday night with some better ideas about some of his players.
Here are some examples:
• Rookie Josh Dobbs started out looking like just another middle-round draft choice the Steelers have wasted on quarterbacks who failed them through the years. And then came his reaction to throwing two poor interceptions and running out of the pocket too often and too early.
He took control. He threw accurately deep and short. He showed leadership in the huddle. He threw two touchdown passes, albeit one canceled by a questionable holding call.
“That shows you a lot, especially starting off like that,” All-Pro guard David DeCastro said.
“I remember my first preseason game. It’s quite a whirlwind. I like him, I like his composure. He’s a smart kid. He’s the kind of guy who doesn’t make the same mistake twice. He seemed pretty composed, and I’m excited to see his progression as he goes.”
It may be Dobbs’ only chance to get any time with the first team — if you count no Antonio Brown, Le’Veon Bell, Martavis Bryant, Maurkice Pouncey or Alejandro Villanueva as “first team” — but he left everyone wanting to see more.
• Remember Arthur Moats? While T.J. Watt, former No. 1 pick Bud Dupree and 39-year-old James Harrison attract all the attention of the outside linebackers, Moats embarked on his fourth season with the Steelers in style with three sacks and an interception he returned for 20 yards.
“He was like the 11th grader in the JV game there at the end,” Tomlin said. “He’s supposed to dominate under those circumstances and he did.”
Moats has not missed a game in his three seasons with the Steelers and started 25. Dupree moved ahead of him on the depth chart when he returned in the second half of last season from hernia surgery. But the Steelers have to feel good with the depth at outside linebacker behind their two first-round draft choices, Dupree and Watt, and Moats brought that home in a rush again Friday.
• A real opportunity has developed for several sleepers, if you will, to earn spots on the roster and they got off to a good start in their first game. Cornerback Mike Hilton, halfback Terrell Watson and tight end Jake McGee followed excellent training camps with good performances Friday night. Mike Tomlin had a word of praise for all three.
Hilton had a sack for a 10-yard loss, a quarterback hurry, a stop on fourth-and-two, four defensive tackles, two special teams tackles, and his presence may have forced a Giants punt muff that he recovered with 40 seconds left in the first half that led to the first Steelers touchdown on the next play.
With all the injuries at cornerback, Hilton has made the most of his opportunity early on.
“It wasn’t too big for him,” Tomlin said. “Forget the play, I thought the awareness and the communication and stuff in-game was no different from a practice setting, and that’s encouraging.”
Watson is a big, strong back at 6-1, 240. He repeated something Friday he’s done often in the first two weeks of camp – scored from the red zone. It came on a 15-yard run around left end that athletically belied his size. He also led the Steelers with 44 yards rushing on 10 carries.
“It was really positive,’’ Tomlin said. “But it’s not unlike what he’s shown us on the fields of Latrobe. He’s got a distinguishing characteristic: He’s a one-cut, downhill guy and did some nice things tonight.”
McGee (6-5, 250) helped Watson go untouched into the end zone and Tomlin mentioned him twice after the game without anyone asking.
“I thought Jake McGee, whom I mentioned earlier, did a nice job leading the way.”
That earlier mention came when Tomlin singled him out as “guys you don’t know a lot about contributing on offense and special teams.”
The Steelers signed McGee Aug. 2 after waiving rookie tight end Scott Orndoff of Pitt injured. He spent time with three different teams as an undrafted rookie last season from Florida before the Chargers released him in May.
• No Brown, no Bryant, no Sammie Coates and the loss of JuJu Smith-Schuster early gave Cobi Hamilton more chances and he snatched them. He caught both of Dobbs’ deep passes, one a nice leaping grab for a 44-yard gain and the other a 28-yard touchdown that hit him in stride in the end zone.
Can Hamilton make the team again? He is among a group competing for the fifth and sixth spots at wide receiver and he took a giant leap Friday.
They start preparing for their next chances Sunday when they resume practice at Saint Vincent College.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.