Ed Bouchette: Good afternoon, let's begin our final May chat.

PghPat: Hi Ed, Regarding Troy Polamalu and the Steelers, in your view, could the Steelers have handled parting ways better?

Ed Bouchette: You mean, like they did with Franco Harris and L.C. Greenwood? There are no good ways to part ways if the player is not ready to retire.

PghPat: Ed, Any chance we see 2 halfbacks with Le'veon and James akin to Franco and Rocky? Or is that a bygone era in today's NFL?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: It's a bygone era with the Steelers, who actually were still running two backs into the 1990s -- until Jerome Bettis arrived. After that, they adopted the philosophy that unless one back can block better than the fullback, it's better to just give the ball to the main guy.

Dennis B: Hi Ed. Any news on the Villenueva contract talks? Do you forsee a deal being completed before the start of the season or do you feel the focus is more on Bells contract?

Ed Bouchette: You can focus on two at the same time, it's not that difficult. I've said it will be tough to get Bell done because of the $12.1 million he'll be guaranteed this year anyway. As for Al V., he might have to realized that at 29 and under the Steelers control for the next 2 years (counting RFA in 2018), that does not put him in a position of strength at the negotiating table. They may not be offering what he and his agent believe he should get, but they also don't have to give him anything more than the minimum this year and then can protect themselves again in 2018 with a relatively low contract. And then, he'll be 31 when he could finally become a UFA.

guest: Ed, provided he remains healthy, do you think the odds are that Golson overtakes Gay as the starting slot CB?

Ed Bouchette: That would be their hope, but he has to show more than his good health, he will have to show some good play because the last time they saw that, he was in college more than two years ago.

Advertise with us

TX_Steeler: How do you feel about Mike Florio and ProFootballTalk quoting your answers from this chat as a source for what the Steelers are thinking?

Ed Bouchette: I have great respect for the job Mike and Pro Football Talk does.

GregLeaper: If Golson impresses, would the plan be to have Sutton eventually replace Cockrell?

Ed Bouchette: The plan is to find the best players. If Sutton is better than Cockrell, he ultimately will replace him. If Cockrell is better, he'll stay put. There's pressure to play first-rounders perhaps a little early, not so much third-rounders.

GregLeaper: Any scenario where you see Steelers ta king a QB in the first round next year?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: All kinds of scenarios. One would be if Ben retires or has a serious injury. Another would be if it comes their turn and they see a QB who possibly could be their starter after Ben.

Ed Bouchette: Yes, there may be even a good chance.

GregLeaper: Is Jerald Hawkins looked at as an eventual starter?

Ed Bouchette: They like what they see, but they haven't had much time to watch because he opened last season on IR and you cannot practice on IR.

Josh from SoCal: Do you know of any correlation between WR height and QB performance? With the additions of Bryant and Juju, and a presumably healthy Coates, Ben's got some pretty good size at WR this year and we all know how much he likes big receivers.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: That is true, but I bet Ben would have been thrilled to throw to Lynn Swann, who stood only 5 feet 11

TX_Steeler: Are any Steelers' offseason surgeries expected to impact training camp?

Ed Bouchette: Not that I am aware of. Le'Veon Bell would be the one. Stephon Tuitt had the cast/wrap taken off his left hand, where he had surgery on a finger(s). Sammie Coates is practicing after groin surgery. Sean Davis is semi-practicing after shoulder surgery.

Josh from SoCal: In terms of snap count percentage, what would you consider a successful season for TJ? Does he split time at ROLB with Harrison similar to Jones or does he only come on the field as a situational pass rusher?

Ed Bouchette: I think he'll split time, but it's not so much snap count as it is production that spells success

Advertise with us

Josh from SoCal: 2nd year player you're most excited about? I'm partial to Hargrave.

Ed Bouchette: Sean Davis

Scott in Dallas: Since I do not think it is possible to come to terms on a Reasonable contract with Bell due to the franchise tag, what is the likelihood that they have to let him test the FA market to set his value next year?

Ed Bouchette: They can still put the franchise tag on him next year too if they want. It should not rise that much.

mrbig: Hey, they eliminated the 75-man cut down rule I believe. Teams go from 90-man rosters down to 53 in 1 day. That should make for a wild feeding frenzy of free agents when all 32 teams cut 40+ players each in 1 day... no?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Yes. It's a long way since they used to start cutting in training camp and we'd get up early in the morning to see who was leaving.

Bj : How is Sutton looking in OTA s and do u think he will start on the outside or in the slot

Ed Bouchette: I haven't concentrated on him, but from what I've seen, he's very aggressive to the ball.

mike: Do to the need to continue to improve the secondary, do you see the possibility (if healthy) that Golson and Sutton could be on the field together?

Ed Bouchette: That is a long shot but never out of the realm of possibility

Advertise with us

Joe: I had been read the hamstring injury of Conner. It is bad? The OTAs is a great opportunity to gain confidence and with the absence of Leveon well I will suppose Conner will be train.

Ed Bouchette: James Conner's hamstring injury is not serious.

Robert Frisby: I see Dobbs is a smart QB and probably will under stand offensebut will his athleticism carry him as a NFL starting QB

Ed Bouchette: Well, he has the smarts and the physical ability. Those are two pretty good head starts.

Bert: Hi Ed - what do you think of the safety the Steelers signed from the TItans?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Ray is writing about him today. Look for that stroy. I concentrated on other things. Apparently, he weighed in too heavy earlier in the FA process but has since lost some weight and the Steelers signed him. He started 6 games for the Titans last year.

Doug in Raleigh: If Bryant & Bell play 14-16 games each, and Juju steps up, I think this offense finally gets to that 30-35 PPG plateau, and is nipping on the heels of NE.........agree?

Ed Bouchette: The Steelers offense will be pretty darn good if all that happens and the others stay healthy.

Ed Bouchette: They are not going to let Vince Williams go anywhere. He is their starting inside linebacker and earned a new contract last summer.

Ryno: In your opinion, what has to happen this season to consider the draft class a big success in the first year?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Draft classes do not always reveal themselves in the first year. It usually takes 3 or so. Last year was different for the Steelers because they had 3 starters.

Ed Bouchette: However, I think they could get contributions from their top 3 again this year, maybe not as starters but as contributors.

Guest: can you elaborate on why it is you think the steelers and bell will not come to a long term deal?

Ed Bouchette: If you were guaranteed $12.1 million in salary this year, what would motivate you to sign a long-term contract that would average less than that? Because I don't think the Steelers are going to give him an average of $12.1 million on a long-term deal. And if you are the Steelers, why would you? You have him this year and, if you want, next year.

Ed Bouchette: Running backs do not last long for the most part in the NFL and he has been suspended twice and hurt every year. So, giving him a big, big bonus would be a gamble in some ways.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Therefore, I do not see a lot of motivation on either side to do a long-term deal.

Kevin in Punxsy: With the Pens in the SC playoffs, I've gotten a little lost with what's going on with the Steelers. Could you please enlighten me in that regards? Thanks

Ed Bouchette: Yes, they open training camp at the end of July and resume play for real in September. Other than that, not much going on.

Ryno: What position or group would worry you the most in case of a couple injuries this season? I guess I'm asking where you see the least amount of depth, perhaps.

Ed Bouchette: Quarterback, offensive line and, of course, all over the secondary

Advertise with us

Mark: Ed, were you in the room when Martavis claimed that he was a changed man, and if so, did it sound sincere?

Ed Bouchette: I was and he did, but words are words. He'll have to show it not tell it.

Ed Bouchette: Yes, I can't think of anyone else.

Steeltyke: With Green gone and no move to sign anyone else like Barnidge for example will the TE position likely be James, Grimble & Johnson barring a late season pickup after roster cuts?

Ed Bouchette: They signed a few young guys who have a chance like Scott Orndoff of Pitt and 6-8 Phazahn Odom, who looks like a pure receiving TE

Advertise with us

steeltexan: Hi Ed, how could the steelers have missed so badly with L. Green? they're supposed to have to pass a physical before signing, right?

Ed Bouchette: Yes, and I assume he did pass.

Ryno: Did you shake your head when you saw Marvin Lewis comment that celebrations aren't good examples to set for young people, when some of his players are one step away from being convicts?

Ed Bouchette: They are apples and oranges, but I know what you mean.

Salvador: Hello Ed, Thanks for all of your chats! How do you compare now Al Villanueva with Kelvin Beachum? We have forgotten Beachum but can we assume he is better than Beachum with two seasons under his belt?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: He probably has more upside, but Beachum did very well for being undersized and is now the starting LT for the Jets.

Scott in Dallas: Any chance the Steelers pursue Kirk Cousins as a replacement for Big Ben next year? Not often a franchise QB makes it to free agency when your team needs it's solution for the next decade...

Ed Bouchette: That would assume that Ben does not play in 2018 and I would not come close to assuming that.

steeltexan: the 2 years that Golson was injured still count on his contract, so he only has 2 yrs left, correct?

Ed Bouchette: Yes. Only suspensions can be tolled. He's like Sean Spence, who missed two and left after 2 more.

Advertise with us

Rob: Will any former Steelers player get a Football Life Feature on NFL Network?

Ed Bouchette: You may want to check with the NFL Network.

Ed Bouchette: They did do one on Joe Greene and Chuck Noll kind of recently.

Guest: Is Bell showing his diva-ness by not showing at OTAs or not a big deal?

Ed Bouchette: No big deal. He knows the offense and cannot participate anyway. He's rehabbing

Chris: Where do you rank big ben if he gets atleast one more ring.

Ed Bouchette: Hall of Fame, but he probably gets there anyway.

Chad B: since Justin Hunter was signed, Bryant has been reinstated and JuJu has been drafted. How many "tall" receivers can they keep given that guys like Eli (slot) and DHB (special teams) have unique skills that add to their value?

Ed Bouchette: DHB's most unique skill really is on special teams. He caught six passes in 10 games last season.

TX_Steeler: who is #1 nose in the base, Alualu or Hargrave?

Ed Bouchette: Hargrave

Ed Bouchette: Thank you for another great chat. See you in June.