Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. We'll get started.

Tim: Since they didn't draft a TE, should we assume the Steelers believe Ladarius Green healthy and ready to go? They certainly didn't get enough production from that position last year....

Ray Fittipaldo: I thought they would draft a TE. Perhaps they had their eye on one or two and another team beat them to the punch. That happens every year. But the fact that they didn't take any TE probably speaks to the fact that they like their depth there. Even if Green can't stay healthy they proved last year they could win with Jesse James as a starter. And remember, JuJue Smith-Schuster is a big body WR who fits the mold of a possession receiver. In many ways, he can win over the middle like a TE would.

Steelers introduce first round pick T.J. Watt

CTSTeeler1: In your opinion, who was the best pick the Steelers made this weekend?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I'll say Smith-Schuster because I like the idea of giving Roethlisberger another weapon late in his career. He's a different kind of WR than what they have too. It's not that I don't like Watt. It's just that he only had one good season in college and he's a bit inexperienced at the position. We'll see about the Sutton pick. They needed help at CB and I don't know enough about him to say he can step in and start in the slot. Hopefully for the Steelers, he can because they need a strong cover man inside and another outside. A lot of national people are loving the Dobbs pick.

Scott in Amsterdam: What happened with Keenan Lewis over the weekend? Ed's tweet was oddly phrased on the subject...made it sound like the player himself was not interested in signing with the Steelers for some reason. Must be an interesting story there?

Ray Fittipaldo: All I know is he was at the facility and left without signing a contract. Anyways, it really doesn't matter now. They drafted two CBs and at least one of them will be on the 53-man roster.

Chiyinz: Ray, obviously the Steelers had a good read on Conner and a majority of the present team saw him go through his battle with cancer. What sort of impact do you think him being in the locker room will have on the team?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think he'll be great for the locker room. But it all comes down to whether he can help this team win and the Steelers were adamant that this was not a sentimental pick. They made that quite clear. Every single person who came into the media room mentioned that. And I think he can help on the field. He runs with authority. He can catch out of the backfield and Colbert said he was excited to see what kind of impact he can have on special teams -- covering kicks, etc.

Advertise with us

Steve: Could Steeler have gotten an equally qualified LB in 2nd and taken a high CB before the "run" in the 1st? Watt was not seen as a sure #1 pick by many analysts..

Ray Fittipaldo: They had their eyes on a few CBs in the first round but the ones they wanted were taken before the Steelers picked, including LSU CB Tre-Davious White. I mocked the Steelers to him before the draft and I think they would have taken him if he was there. And obviously, they didn't feel strongly enough about any CB to trade up because they didn't. From the very beginning, the Steelers said this was a deep draft at CB and OLB and they went with the best player on their board at that point. I'm a little surprised they didn't go with a CB in Round 2, but again there was a run on CBs in that round and they didn't trade up.

Steve: Can you explain not taking a TE instead of a LS? Was the LS a guy that wouldn't have been around as a undrafted FA?

Ray Fittipaldo: People are still trying to figure that out. Colbert and Tomlin were asked after the draft if Greg Warren was OK and they both said yes. Colbert said LS Colin Holba was added to provide competition for Warren. I get the idea there is something wrong with Warren and we just don't know about it yet. Why would they sign him to another one-year contract then? They've gone year to year with him for most of his career and never used a pick to provide competition.

Steve: How would you grade the Steelers draft? How did it compare to your final "mock"..from a positional and talent perspective?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I'd give the Steelers a B. They filled needs. My only criticism is not addressing CB earlier. But maybe Sutton is a sleeper and he'll be a great value pick. They need him to perform or they'll be second-guessed. As mentioned earlier I had them taking Tre'Davious White. In my final four-round mock draft I got two picks right though not in the round I predicted. I correctly predicted they would take James Conner and Josh Dobbs. I had them taking Conner in Round 4 and Dobbs in Round 3. It was the opposite. Getting 2 out of 5 right isn't bad.

PG Live: Analyzing the Steelers' 2017 draft picks

Steve: If TJ's name is Smith & not Watt, is he still a #1 pick?

Ray Fittipaldo: Lots of people are asking that question. I guess we'll have to wait and see. The Steelers are banking on continued development and they love his demeanor and work ethic. He knows how to approach a career in the NFL because he has two brothers playing in the NFL. The Steelers think his athleticism and his approach will help him develop more. But he is inexperienced at the position.

Jared Thomas: Hey Ray! Question... with our pass D being ranked terribly for the last 5+ years, and this draft being so OLB deep, why not go with Obi Melinfonwu in the first round. We could put him in sub packages immediately and help our pass D, NOW!! Mike Mitchell can't cover. TJ Watt is good but we could've just grabbed Derek Rivers in the 2nd round! I'm frustrated bro... help ease my frustration with sound knowledge please. Lol. Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, Obi didn't get drafted until late in the second round so a lot of teams didn't have first-round grades on him. You never reach in the first round. You get the best player available on your board. And the pass D was terrible in 2014 and 2015, but they improved to be middle of the pack last season. Listen, I'm the writer who said immediately after the AFC title game that they needed to add a cover CB to compete with New England. I'm not sure if they did that. But the pass d did improve last season. It just has to get better. That's why the Sutton pick will be the pick everyone looks back on this draft. If he turns out to be good the Steelers will have filled a need. If not, we'll be singing the familiar refrain about this team needing better DBs.

Advertise with us

Scott in Amsterdam: Assuming that the James Conner pick signals the end of Deangelo Williams? They usually keep at least 3 RBs on the roster right? I'd rather bring Deangelo back than keep Fitz Toussaint.

Ray Fittipaldo: You're forgetting about Knile Davis. If Bell, Conner and Davis are all healthy it's the end for Williams and Toussaint.

Jon: Ray, overall I was pretty happy with the first 2 days of draft but disappointed in some of the later picks. I didn't like the Dobbs pick in the 4th and LS was a ridiculous pick. Shouldn't they have continued to pick DB's or D to see if they can get better in secondary? Am I wrong for thinking this way?

Ray Fittipaldo: They drafted two CBs. Brian Allen is a big 6-3, 215-pound prospect. They got him in the fifth round.

Jon: Ray, which pick do you think will pay off and help the team in the shortest time frame?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I'd say Smith-Schuster or Sutton. I think Watt can help as a situational pass rusher as a rookie, but James Harrison will be the starter. I can see Smith-Schuster helping though I'm not sure if it will be at the beginning of the season. If Sutton can play right away that'd be huge for them. They need a better slot CB.

Scott in Amsterdam: While his comments were in poor taste, do you think Martavis is right about Sammie Coates being on the chopping block? I figured him being a high draft pick with some proven potential would make him safe for at least one more year, but the addition of Justin Hunter and Juju makes for a pretty crowded WR room...

Ray Fittipaldo: Colbert said sorting out the WR situation will be "fun". If Bryant stays on the straight and narrow there is no need for Coates. So you'd have Antonio Brown and Bryant as starters with Eli Rogers in the slot and Smith-Schuster trying to carve out a role as possession receiver. That leaves DHB, Ayers, Coates and Hunter fighting for the fifth WR spot. Even if they keep six that's a crowded WR room.

Scott in Amsterdam: I was expecting the Steelers to take a middle linebacker in the 4th or 5th rounds....I guess this draft was not deep at the position?

Ray Fittipaldo: You are correct. There were a few good ILBs that got scooped up in the first two rounds, but this was not a deep draft for ILBs.

Advertise with us

Scott in Amsterdam: Colbert didn't exactly give Vince Williams a ringing endorsement after the draft....do you think they are truly comfortable with the depth at the position? I'm not even sure who the top backup would be.

Ray Fittipaldo: I actually thought it was a nice endorsement. He's been saying things like that for a while now. But their actions say otherwise. They went after the top ILB in free agency and they brought in several of the top draft prospects for 30-visits to their facility. Williams is not your long-time starter alongside Shazier. He's a bridge player and a decent one at that. He's not a bad player. I just think he'll struggle in pass coverage.

Rich V C: Do you think that TJ Watt will have any impact on this years defense?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I do. I think they can use him as a pass rusher. That's why they drafted him. He won't sit the bench as a rookie.

Rich V C: Don't you think that the Steelers could have found a TE because of the uncertainties or at least bring competition to the position?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe they targeted a few and it just didn't work out the way the draft unfolded. But as I said earlier, they like their depth at the position.

Scott in Amsterdam: What do you think about the corners they drafted? Assuming they both can play in man coverage?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes they're both guys who did well with man coverage in college. The knock on Sutton is he's too small and the knock on Allen is the inexperience. He wasn't even a starter at Utah to open last college season. He earned that job about a month into the season.

Rich V C: With the draft over and looking at what we got do you think we're any closer to beating the Patriots?

Ray Fittipaldo: Ask me in the fall. Let's see how these rookies play.

Advertise with us

Tim from Tyrone: Hi Ray. I don't understand why the Steelers would draft a quarterback unless the organization thinks he will be Ben's replacement. If not it doesn't make sense. What do you think.

Ray Fittipaldo: They've been very open about wanting to add another QB to the mix. Roethlisberger has three years left on his contract and Dobbs is a developmental QB. He's not ready. So at the very least he can be a backup QB in a year or two, or if he develops well, they might have hit the jackpot and become a starter.

Matt: Ray, are the Steelers being considered for "Hard Knocks"? Because it seems like our draft strategy was guided by personal interest stories over helping the team the next 2-3 years (Ben's final few).

Ray Fittipaldo: No. They don't want to do Hard Knocks and the NFL can't force them to this year because they made the playoffs.

ALLJACKEDUP: Sign Barnidge and cut Green?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Barnidge turns 32 this fall. He's no spring chicken.

Mike C.: Do you see any of these picks making an immediate impact to a team that's so close to winning a title? I would say maybe the wide receiver pick but that's about it.

Ray Fittipaldo: It's all speculating, but I think the first three picks can contribute. The first three picks contributed last season. In fact, all three were starters by season's end.

Dorkmen: Why do the Steelers never seem to trade up or down. Do they not believe in it.

Ray Fittipaldo: They believe in it for a special player like Troy Polamalu. And I don't know where you get they never do it. They also traded up for Shamarko Thomas. How'd that work out?

Advertise with us

Charles D: With the comments made about Ladarius Green pre-draft, and the fact they did not add a TE during the draft. (UDFA Orndorff doe not count). What are the chances they bring Barnidge in for a visit?

Ray Fittipaldo: I'd be a little surprised.

Opie: I have nothing against the Watt selection, but I believe Reuben Foster was rated higher. Do you feel the Steelers passed on him because of his diluted sample during the combine?

Ray Fittipaldo: 30 other teams passed on him too. It wasn't just the diluted sample. He had that confrontation with the nurse at the NFL combine and was sent home. Many had him as a top 10 talent in the draft, but obviously there were some red flags GMs had concerns with.

Steve: According to Chris Burke SI Browns, Ravens & Bengals all got a grade of A- ....so they win the draft...that's fine, but did any of these teams get better than the Steelers as a whole with FA & the Draft? Things change quick in NFL (parity) these days excluding the Patriots.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I like what the Bengals did. There are some big injury risks with John Ross and Carl Lawson and there is and big character concern with Joe Mixon. But if Mixon can stay out of trouble that's a great pick. Many had him as the best RB in this class. And if Lawson and Ross can stay healthy they'll be contributors in Week 1. Lawson falling to the fourth round tells me there are major concerns about his hip or his knees. He's a borderline first-round talent and at the very least a second-round talent. The guy can play. I guess his medicals worried a lot of teams.

Dexter: do you think Steelers will regret not drafting an ILB? And what is our current depth at that position?

Ray Fittipaldo: After Shazier and Williams, they have Steven Johnson, LJ Fort and Tyler Matakevich. The depth is great. That's the one position they'll be praying they don't have any injuries to starters.

Dave: Hi Ray, do you think Smith-Schuster will have much of a role on offense this year, or will he be buried behind AB, Bryant, Rogers and maybe even Coates?

Ray Fittipaldo: They'll find a role for him. If he picks up the offense, he'll make a big impact, too.

Advertise with us

Pat Fussy: Did Watt truly deserve to be first round? Injuries and limited time as a linebacker worry this amateur GM. What say you? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: Of course, those are worries. But the Steelers checked out the knees and were satisfied they won't be problematic. And they're banking on him developing more. Colbert and Tomlin said he's only scratching the surface of what he will be.

Brian : Do you think they add a vet CB before the season?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not unless there is an injury.

Jojo: JuJu in the slot? I think so

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: He can play inside and outside, but the Steelers mentioned him working over the middle and in the red zone specifically. They'll find room for him.

pdxJaxon: Good morning Ray. With the Pick of JuJu in Round 2 AND with the unfortunate Tweet immediately afterward, I am actually hoping they just cut ties with M.B.......Not the team mate or character we need.....thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Too good of a player to do that. Colbert and Tomlin indicated they didn't have a big problem with the Twitter thing after the draft.

TX_Steeler: Shazier vs CJ Mosely is a debate that has been playing out since the '14 draft, with Mosely looking like the better pick (mostly due to durability). Are we going to see the same thing with Watt vs Bowser?

Ray Fittipaldo: I wasn't a big Bowser guy. I watched him a bit and Houston had him dropping into coverage more than rushing in the games I watched. He's a guy who tested very well. I'm OK with Watt over Bowser.

Advertise with us

Barry Halls: Was the smith- schuster pick a gesture to Ben? 2nd round pick on offense , with a few more pressing needs on defense.

Ray Fittipaldo: I think they wanted to give him better weapons. Did you watch the AFC title game? His best WR that day was Jesse James.

JJ: Knowing that in 2 to 3 years this draft class could be labeled good. Did any of the first four picks baffle you?

Ray Fittipaldo: No, not baffle. I was a little surprised they didn't go CB or S in Round 2, but I like Smith-Schuster.

mtsteel: Hi Ray, Do you feel the Steelers should have maybe moved up a bit to get a CB when the run on them was going on? Also, how do you feel about Sutton? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe they tried and the price was too steep. Or maybe they had similar grades on guys and didn't feel all that strongly about any of the guys after Round 1.

ssa76: Bottom line speculation: How many of these guys make the team and practice squad?

Ray Fittipaldo: Watt, Smith-Schuster, Sutton, Conner and Dobbs are locks barring injury. Allen might be a practice squad candidate if he doesn't carve out a niche on special teams. I think Holba will make it because I'm not convinced Warren is coming back. And I think Keion Adams is another practice squad candidate.

Dave: Why does everyone keep saying TE is a huge need for the Steelers? Sure, Green is a question mark, but Jesse James is a solid starting TE. You could do a lot worse. Plus Grimble is a serviceable backup along with DJ. I didn't see it as a huge need.

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes. Like I've been saying they like their depth there.

TX_Steeler: Is there tension between M. Bryant and S. Coates? Or was that twitter bit jokes?

Ray Fittipaldo: Didn't sound like a joke to me.

Dave: Fans seem to be taking the front office literally when they said Dobbs shouldn't be viewed as Ben's replacement. Seems pretty obvious that that's what they'd say. Otherwise you're putting a lot of pressure on him and making it uncomfortable for Ben when he won't be potentially replacing anyone for at least a few seasons. He's a good prospect you hope can develop into, best case scenario, the future QB. How hard is that to understand?

Steve: I'm confused by using a draft pick for a QB (esp. Jobbs) in this draft..he is compared to E.J Manual(?).....he's a smart person, but not apparently that smart at reading defenses..why use a pick this year on another backup ...

Ray Fittipaldo: Because they think they can develop him.

Ray Fittipaldo: He's going to be the backup RB too. Colbert just said he's excited to watch him play special teams. All young guys make the roster initially because of their ability to play on the coverage teams.

ssa76: To me a good pass rush covers a lot of coverage sins, so if Watt pans out, he's better than the CB talent available in the first round. Agree?

Ray Fittipaldo: Rush and coverage work together. That's what the coaches always say. But you still need someone to stay close to WRs when you face elite guys like Brady and Rodgers.

Michael from MD: Who is your surprise being for not making the 53 man roster?

Ray Fittipaldo: Way too early for that type of speculation, but obviously it's a crowded group at WR.

Dave: Of the UDFA we signed, Ordoff is the only one ive ever heard of. Anyone from that group catch your eye as a potential practices squad guy?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not really. The DT Kallon is someone I can see making the practice squad.

njsteelerfan: Hi Ray! So the Steelers said they didn't take Dobbs to be a future replacement for Ben, if thats the case why not stay with defense or TE and wait until next year to grab a QB? Thank you

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think the Cowboys were saying Prescott was Romo's replacement last year either. You don't come out and say those things. You let things play out. I'm not saying Dobbs is the future long-term starter, but we should give him time to develop.

Kevin in Punxsy: Ray, I watched TJ Watt play for Wisconsin and have seen other footage, that's why I can't understand a number of media people stating that his pick was a reach. He can play immediately, giving JH a breather and learning on the job. Your thoughts, please.

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I agree with you. I think he will help as a rookie. He has raw pass rush skills and he has a high motor. You won't have to worry about this guy taking plays off.

Steelerfan: Why are we assuming Smith-Schuster is already better than Coates? just because he's their 2nd pick?

Ray Fittipaldo: He'll have to earn it, but he has traits that none of the current WRs have. He's known as a blocker, which Todd Haley specifically mentioned in terms of the running game. He's also known for his work ethic. I'm not saying Coates stopped trying last season, but they're clearly not happy with his development and the way he worked through those injuries. That's why Smith-Schuster is here, along with Bryant's tenuous situation.

Jared Thomas: Thanks for that in depth analysis Ray.... I'm excited about Brian Allen and if I'm correct, Artie Burns only started one year at corner in Miami right? Allen could make the roster. Thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: He's much more of a project. I can see him making the roster if he's a great special teams player. If not, he's a guy you can develop on the practice squad if you can sneak him through waivers.

Mark: Do you think the Steelers will average over 30 pts/game this season? They should score more than last year.....

Ray Fittipaldo: If Bryant and Brown plays 16 games they should challenge that 30 ppg threshold.

Craig M: Any possibility that we keep DeAngelo for another year. Toussaint isn't the answer and when healthy DA is a great option.

Ray Fittipaldo: Not unless there is an injury.

SteelerFanInMD: what happens when a college player announces early for the NFL draft but doesn't get picked? Can he play again in college? Can he at least attend classes and continue degree work there?

Ray Fittipaldo: He cannot go back to college once he declares. I don't like that rule. That player should be able to go back to college.

Kevin in Punxsy: Ray, do you think that the Steelers might have talked to AD Lynn Swan about Ju Ju's ability to play WR in the NFL? He might know a think or 2 about playing that position!!

Ray Fittipaldo: I am sure they did. They also had a relationship with Paul Chryst that helped with Watt.

atown jason: I say Watt is the starter by week 10. Allows Harrison to just rush the passer and we get even moee athletic on D. Crazy or about right?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not a bad call. All depends on how he develops.

atown jason: My dad always says you can never reach for a player that fits and a compensatory pick is a fancy name for the beginning of the next round. For those 2 reasons I love the Conner pick and where it happened. Or is the logic way wrong

Ray Fittipaldo: The middle rounds are the rounds where the Steelers have sometimes gambled on players with risks. They took Bryant in the fourth round. They took Dri Archer with a third-round compensatory pick. The Conner pick is safe. And that's OK. I think they've had their fill of players who are in the drug program.

atown jason: Will/can Moats play more ILB? I thought that was his position primarily in Buffalo

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe in an emergency. But he's been strictly an OLB since he got here.

Steelerfan: Hi Ray, would you have preferred Kevin King from Washington at 30 over Watt? Thank you!

Ray Fittipaldo: King is a guy who might be a CB and might be a safety. If the Steelers didn't know how they would use him then I can see why he fell to the second round.

Smitty : Do you think the JuJub pick is becuase the Steelers have no plans of re signing Martavis when his contract is up?

Ray Fittipaldo: That's probably true.

67 camaro: Anyone in this draft class going to contribute in the return game, punt or kickoff?

Ray Fittipaldo: Sutton was a punt returner at Tennessee. I think he had three TDs on punt returns.

atown jason: What was the Worst trade of the draft in your opinion? I really didnt like the Chiefs more than the Bears just for the loss of the 2nd 1st Rder but obviously they had to go 15 picks not 1

Ray Fittipaldo: I think the Bears gave up way too much to move up one spot.

TX_Steeler: Prediction on whether Gay makes the final roster? Golson?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think they would have cut Gay by now if they were going to cut him. With Golson, we'll have to wait and see how much the injuries have taken a toll on his athleticism.

Neal: Would you have supported picking up another rotational pass rusher earlier in the draft. Ravens got Bower and Williams. Cinci got Willis and Lawson. AFC north opponents had really good drafts in my opinion.

Ray Fittipaldo: They're hoping to develop Keion Adams. Plus they have Moats for one more year and Chickillo as well. Not great depth beyond this year but I think they're OK for this year at OLB

Grady: Is this the year we have a Steeler with 10 sacks for the season

Ray Fittipaldo: They're hoping. It's been a long time.

atown jason: does gay get to play some safety? He has good ball skills if he can just play a deep third. Wouls have to be in sub packages but him as the 3rd safety in the dime might be ok

Ray Fittipaldo: I think he has that versatility.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for the great questions this week. We'll do it again next week.