The NFL mock drafts give way to the real thing Thursday, and even the experts cannot predict what might happen.
“It’s a strange draft,” said NFL analyst Gil Brandt, who began working drafts in 1960, the first of his 20 years doing so for the Dallas Cowboys. “There are so many questions.”
PG Live: Who will the Steelers pick in the NFL Draft?
Even the first pick is up for conjecture, partly because it belongs to Cleveland, at least it does at the moment. The Browns and their new analytical cabal in the front office came out last year swinging and dealing; they made five trades in that draft, two in the first round. They have two first-round draft picks this year, 11 overall.
What Cleveland does could affect everything else that goes on in the first round, including the Steelers’ at No. 30 — assuming they stay at No. 30. General manager Kevin Colbert, as he always does, said this week they are open to moving up in the first round or even back into the second. The Steelers have not traded out of the first round in half a century, since the 1967 draft.
Colbert said there is so much unpredictability in this draft that “you are going to see more trade-up and trade-down possibilities — not so much with us but around the league.”
No matter what goes on above them, however, the Steelers and virtually every other team work it the same way. With the No. 30 pick, for example, the Steelers will have their top 30 players so no matter what, they will get one of them, provided they do not trade out of that spot.
Read More
“I am sure there are 30 guys who can help us,” Colbert said. “But this year it’s really more unpredictable than it has been in a long time.”
The Steelers have eight picks entering Thursday, one in each of the seven rounds plus an extra in the third-round, their highest compensatory pick since 2014, when they used their extra third-rounder to draft Dri Archer (after trading away their other third-rounder to Cleveland to draft Shamarko Thomas in 2013).
Teams are permitted to trade compensatory picks for the first time.
The Steelers needs in this draft are well known — outside linebacker and cornerback, primarily. Secondary needs are backup running back and a wide receiver/tight end, although the return of Martavis Bryant could ease the latter need. The draft is strong and deep at all four positions.
Quarterback has become somewhat an issue because of Ben Roethlisberger’s age and his brief thoughts about retirement, but Colbert uncharacteristically might have shown his hand on that topic.
“In our scenario, you are probably going to take a cornerback over a quarterback, as long as they are close,’’ said Colbert, who nevertheless would not rule out drafting a quarterback.
Cleveland is expected to draft one either with the top pick or No. 12, provided the Browns stay at those spots.
If they stay at No. 1 and opt to wait for the quarterback, their choice is supposed to be what many regard as the overall best player in this draft, defensive end Myles Garrett of Texas A&M.
But Brandt has an interesting take on that too.
“There are two guys in the Southeast Conference,” Brandt said about the edge rushers. “Garrett had 31 sacks — 14 came against non-SEC schools. Derek Barnett — the fifth- or sixth- or 20th-ranked guy, depending on who’s looking — broke Reggie White’s record for sacks at Tennessee and 28 of his 32 came against SEC schools. Yet we don’t talk about the guy [as the top pick].”
As the man said, it’s a strange draft. Here’s something else to think about — no matter who the Steelers draft Thursday, he probably will not help them much in 2017 if he plays on defense. Yes, three of them started on defense last season, but that was as unusual as the Steelers trading out of the first round.
Never has an outside linebacker done much his rookie season, although they tried to force-feed Jarvis Jones into it, without much success. Bud Dupree started five games as a rookie. LaMarr Woodley likely came the closest, as a rotational outside linebacker his rookie season in 2007.
Maybe, like last season, they will have one of those rare cases where a rookie comes in and helps their defense immediately. It’s just not the norm, especially when you’re drafting near the bottom of the first round.
Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com and Twitter @EdBouchette.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.