POLL: Should the Steelers sign LB Dont'a Hightower if he asking for $10 million a season or more? A. Yes (37%) B. No, Vince Williams can handle the job (63%)
Ray Fittipaldo: Hightower has started 64 games for the Patriots the past five seasons. He owns two Super Bowl rings with the Patriots. He's already visited the Jets and Titans and I saw a report recently that said both teams expect him to sign again with the Patriots. So it seems like he's attached to the Pats, the team that drafted him and where he's enjoyed a lot of success, but he's also looking around. They'd have to pay him $10 million a year or more if you believe some of the reports that are out there in terms of his asking price. That's be a lot of money tied up on inside linebackers with Ryan Shazier due a new deal next year.
Big D: Why do you think the Steelers didn't go after Stephan Gilmore...makes more sense to me to bring in a shut down corner than another inside LB
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, for one, he's making in the $14-15 million a year range with the Patriots, I believe. That's what they're paying Antonio Brown. I don't think they wanted to spend that much on a CB. The Patriots had more salary cap space to do that signing. Plus, this is a deep draft for CBs. You can get a starter in the first or second round.
BIg John: With Bell having surgery, do you see the Steelers going after Pitt's Connor with their 3rd or 4th round pick?
Ray Fittipaldo: Bell's surgery isn't expected to keep him from participating in training camp. He might even be back for OTAs or minicamp though they certainly won't push him. It's a 6-8 week rehab from that surgery. So I don't think it will change their plans drastically. I think they'll go for a RB in the middle rounds. Conner likely a fourth or fifth-round prospect.
Read More
SteelByDesign: The Steelers brining Donte Hightower in makes me scratch my head a bit. He's a good 3 down linebacker, but my guess is he's going to get somewhere around 8-10 mil per year on average. He's an upgrade over Vince Williams, but he's not 8 mil per season better. Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Right. It's tougher to connect the dots on this one because it seems like the plan all along was for Vince Williams to take over for Timmons. The Steelers would be weakening the Patriots if they signed Hightower, but they usually don't operate that way. They sign a player to a deal in free agency if it's a good move for them, not to weaken another team.
Ninjaskrzypek: After the Steelers stopped inquiring about CBs last week due to asking price why would they fly Hightower in? Isn't he looking for a big contract?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes he is -- in the $10 million a year range. The Steelers have the cap space, but like I said before that's a lot of money tied up in ILBs the next few seasons if Shazier is in your long-terms plans, too.
Bishkek Steeler: They wouldn't have let Timmons go if they had no confidence in VW. They have to draft now to find a long term better solution. Williams can handle the job in the interim. Who do you think they are looking at in this draft to bring in for that roll?
Ray Fittipaldo: This isn't a deep draft for ILBs. There are a few good ones, but they'll go in the first round or early second round. The Steelers need an OLB and a CB much more than an ILB so I don't think they'll have any of the top college guys. Haason Reddick is one of the top LBs in the draft. Can play inside or outside, but he's been moving up draft boards and it's questionable if he'll be available when the Steelers pick at No. 30.
Bill: Should teams, even the Steelers, make a reasonable offer for Malcolm Butler, say $10-11M? They would get a proven, seasoned CB or force the Patriots to have $25M invested in the CB position...
Ray Fittipaldo: Some team will do that, but the Steelers really haven't been tied to Butler at all in free agency thus far. It's interesting the way the Patriots are treating Butler. It doesn't seem like they view him as a true No. 1 CB. They went out and got Gilmore for that role. Butler might be a No. 1 CB on the Steelers or another team though.
Daniel: How about signing RB Jonathan Grimes from Houston Texans? He can run, catch, and of all plays good special teams. He will be a low cost player with high returns.
Ray Fittipaldo: Draft is full of good RBs this year. You can get a good one in the middle or later rounds.
BIg John: With this draft heavier loaded with Defense.. can we see another Defensive draft with a splash if either a Wide Receiver, Running Back and/or a QB?
Ray Fittipaldo: I had four defensive players in the first five picks in my first mock draft. I think it could break that way with offensive players going in the later rounds. But you could very easily see three defensive and two offensive players in the Steelers' first five picks.
Bishkek Steeler: How could they fit Hightower into the cap structure?
Ray Fittipaldo: They still have $21 or 22 in cap space. They can make it work if they want to.
Bill: Having not played a down, where does Golson's contract situation stand as far as time left on his rookie deal? Does he have time of service after being on the IR?
Ray Fittipaldo: He has two years left on his rookie deal.
Griffin: Any tidbits on Green and his health concerns? Will we be waiting until training camp and drills like last season to get a clue?
Ray Fittipaldo: We'll get a sense of where he is in May when they start OTAs. If he's out there it's a good sign. If not, I think there will be rampant speculation that the Steelers will release him. But all signs thus far is that he is preparing to practice this spring.
JON: So, Pit gets crushed in title game. I read how Pit needs more weapons to help out Ben. Coates, Hamilton etc. Just not good enough. Need a CB. Gay was terrible. Need pass rusher to pressure Brady. Then the Patriots get the exact positions that Pit needed. Ben is starting the slow decline and heading toward end of career. No time to wait for young players through draft to come around. Meanwhile NE sets up to get Brady #6. UGGH So I guess my question would be: Why shouldn’t WE Steeler fans be upset and disappointed that they are doing nothing?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers are doing what they always do in free agency. They're looking at guys in the second wave. They've never been big early spenders. So you can be disappointed if you want, but it's the same mode of operation they've had for years.
John Stamos: If cockrell gets a better offer, who is on the roster besides artie and golson at the CB position? Seems very thin
Ray Fittipaldo: Al-Hajj Shabazz. And Will Gay is still around.
Big Chuck: What do you think about Lawson from Auburn? He has a history of injuries, and from highlights that I have watched, I wasn't impressed.
Ray Fittipaldo: I really like Lawson. He is a big strong guy. Will have no trouble setting the edge in the running game. He plays hard. The only questions are his injury history and his pass-rush ability. He's a better run defender than rusher at this point. Do the Steelers or another team think he'll develop those traits in the NFL in order to take him late in the first round? But to answer your question I think he'd be a good pick at No. 30. I would have no problem with that pick.
Bishkek Steeler: The Pats and Brady have a team friendly contract that gives them a lot of flexibility. Why couldn't we have done the same with Ben?
Ray Fittipaldo: You'd have to ask Roethlisberger. Brady has lots of endorsement deals that bring in additional money for him. He's also married to the world's highest-paid supermodel. Roethlisberger has no such endorsement deals. There's your answer.
Big Chuck: Have you heard of any draft prospect that the Steelers are in love with? Maybe even someone who blew them away in the interviews?
Ray Fittipaldo: We'll find out soon when the predraft visitors start to come in.
Eli: If we draft a safety in the second round per say and he perform extremely well during the rookie camp, mini camp and training camp, do you see the Steelers favoring him over Mike Mitchell?
Ray Fittipaldo: No I think Mitchell is the starter for next season no matter what. Unless, of course, he gets hurt.
Tom: hi Ray, enjoying your Chats every weekfrom Vienna, Austria! why is so hard for the Steelers Front Office to find a good (not too expansive) CB in FA? House from JAX or Brandon Flowers are available! grab one of them and one in the draft (round 1 or 2) And you have a nearly perfect backfield!
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, House in the house today. So maybe he will sign.
SteelByDesign: Let's assume the Steelers find their FA cornerback (Davon House?). Do they still draft one? Seems like a crowded group with Burns, House, Cockrell, Golson, and Gay. Or, do you see one of the guys I mentioned not being around?
Ray Fittipaldo: No I think the plan is to draft one in April.
AJ: How is last year's defense - minus Timmons and plus a few rookies who will need time to develop - in any way an improvement for next season? To me this draft-only approach means the defense will be good a few years from now.
Ray Fittipaldo: They drafted three guys last year and all three were starters by midseason. Let's wait to see what happens this spring.
Big Chuck: Do you think that it is a must to draft 2 CB's if we lose Cockrell? I think that is the one position that you can never have enough of. It can be a long season if a starting CB is lost due to an injury.
Ray Fittipaldo: If they lose Cockrell probably, but maybe that's why House is here.
SteelByDesign: Should we assume with the team in "win now" mode that Sydney Jones is likely off their draft board?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah unless they see value in the third or fourth round. But that's taking a guy who will definitely miss the year and you're hoping he returns to previous form from a bad injury.
Alan: What does it say that we got blown out by the patriots with one of the reasons being our secondary and the patriots are the team that's being aggressive in free agency in order to improve?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Patriots are always turning the roster over. They're not afraid to ruffle feathers even if it means making their own players such as Malcolm Butler feel uncomfortable.
BIg John: I actually like what the Steelers plan of building thru the draft.. it keeps enough money to resign the core players and constantly infusing youth//as always thank you for your wisdom
Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah I'm fine with it, too. They've been successful with this approach.
Guest: Is the OLB class in this draft deep enough to justify going after Malcolm Butler and giving up our #1 to the Pats since he is a restricted FA w/ a 1st-round tender? I know there are
Ray Fittipaldo: There will be good ones available in the second round, but there will be a drop off from the guys in the first round. But they could easily find a solid OLB in the second round. As for Butler, I don't know if the Steelers would make that move. We'll have to wait and see. All depends on how their pro scouts and coaches feel about Butler. If they think he's a No. 1 CB then maybe. But if they feel he's a No. 2 CB then probably won't spend over $10 million a year to sign him.
Paul A: What are the chances we see D Williams back next year?
Ray Fittipaldo: Don't think the chances are good. I think they want to get younger at the position.
SteelByDesign: Any update on Martavis Bryant? Has he applied for reinstatement yet?
Ray Fittipaldo: He has reapplied. No news yet. The commissioner makes that call whenever he is ready.
DW: Ray, were you surprised with the size of Wheaton's contract Chicago offered him? Seemed very high to me coming off the injury during a contract year.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes very surprised. The Bears must be banking on him to return to his 2014-15 form but even then he was just a decent No. 2 WR. Bryant passed him as the Steelers' No.2 That's why it's a free market. Some teams value other players more. Good for him though. He cashes in despite not living up to expectations of a third-round pick.
Bill jones: Any other players coming in for visit besides Hightower and House?
Ray Fittipaldo: I heard a few over the weekend. That's two. Maybe one more but don't know the name yet.
JW: Do you think they can afford a Tuitt extension and signing Hightower this offseason?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, I think they could make that work, but don't get excited about Hightower just yet.
Pat: I see people complaining all the time about "what the Patriots have done", but don't the Steelers do the same thing in not putting too high a value on FAs? The Pats picked up Cook, but there's no way they should spend a #1 on a WR and Gilmore was too much money....
Ray Fittipaldo: Patriots are in a unique position. Brady is 40. They can win three Super Bowls in four years for the second time, another mini-dynasty if you will. They're clearly in go for it mode.
Kris in La Mirada: Is Donte Hightower a legitimate possibility for the Steelers or are they just driving up the price for the Pats?
Ray Fittipaldo: People seem to think he's heading back to the Pats, but maybe he'll get overwhelmed with an offer somewhere else.
Pat: Ray, Brady took $30m up front on his last deal and is now a $22M cap hit for the remainder of his contract....Ben's contract is in that range....no?
Ray Fittipaldo: Brady is below Ben in the pecking order. Also behind guys like Russell Wilson and others.
SteelByDesign: What do you think of taking Budda Baker at 30? I think he could be a slot cornerback and 3rd safety immidiately, and be your Sean Davis bash brother in a couple of years when Mike Mitchell moves on.
Ray Fittipaldo: He's a good player. If you take him in the first round he had better be ready to contribute as a rookie. They need help in the defensive backfield and at OLB.
Steeler Joe: Defensive line--late pick for depth? Or might they have the position a little higher on the needs list?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think fourth round or later is a good estimate. They can use more depth.
Steeler Joe: The Steelers have the money for Donta Hightower...do you think there's more than passing interest there?
Bishkek Steeler: So it's possible to bend salary cap rules endorsements and wives salaries?
Ray Fittipaldo: What rules were bent? He gets endorsements on his own through his agency and his wife her her own career...
JON: What is your opinion on Williams replacing Timmons? Good move or risky one>?
Ray Fittipaldo: That would be OK. Williams is a good two-down run defender. I don't think he'll play a lot on passing downs. So that's why you could see the Steelers select two DBs in the draft. They would be playing with a lot of five and six defensive backs next season.
Eli: Will there be a competition for the back up QB job between laundry Jones and mettenberg? I personally like zach better
Ray Fittipaldo: The more pertinent question: Will there be a competition for third-string QB if the Steelers draft one?
Eli: I think we are a corner and outside linebacker away from hoisting that Lombardi trophy do you agree?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, if those two draft picks can come in and contribute, they'd be in contention in the AFC. They were in contention last year.
RonnieD: Ray, I can't imagine the Steelers spending close to $10M/year on a free agent middle linebacker that isn't one of their own. I know they need a replacement (other than Williams) for Timmons, but if they are going to splash into big FA dollars, wouldn't you rather see that money put to a high profile cornerback than a middle linebacker who is not strong in covering TEs?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, but they didn't go that route. Perhaps they still could with Butler, but there hasn't been any evidence they're interested.
Eli: Now that LT is gone is the Job Vince Williams now or do you see any of the young guys challenging him? I see big red taking that job. His football IQ is very impressive.
Ray Fittipaldo: Matakevich is a good player, but they like Williams too.
Ron from SoCal: Ray- have you heard any talk of interest in former Dallas Cowboys CB Morris Claiborne? Of the second tier corners, he seems the most interesting, most potential
Ray Fittipaldo: He is a mid-tier free agent, but Davon House is here today so it seems like they like him better.
questions: Hi Ray. How is it that every year the Patriots seem to work out these amazing trade and free agent deals, that continue to improve their team, but we don't seem to be able to do anything?
Ray Fittipaldo: Because they don't mind getting rid of players who helped them win. Or ruffling their feathers by making them play on contracts they outperformed. They are ruthless in their pursuit to win.
RonnieD: Any news on possible contract extension for Alejandro Villanueva or Stephon Tuitt?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they're sorting through the outside free agents now. Tuitt will get done this summer and they'd like to do Villanueva, too.
Bryan10s: True or False? The Steelers should be in win now mode?
Ray Fittipaldo: True
mrbig: love the chats, who concerns you most in the AFC North, Ravens?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes the Ravens. The Bengals continue to lose free agents. They lost two of their top offensive linemen last week. The Ravens were close to being a playoff team last year and might have been if not for Antonio Brown.
Chris: What do you think is a bigger priority on offense for the draft? RB or WR? Which rounds do you think we'll pick for that?
Ray Fittipaldo: WR in second or third round. RB in third round or after. Maybe fourth round or after.
brad: does the media get an opportunity to talk to free agents when they visit?
Ray Fittipaldo: Only if they sign.
Ken: Do you see the Steelers spending more money on Hightower than what Timmons got from Miami?
Ray Fittipaldo: He is four years younger.
Ken: Do you know what kind of Money a player like Davon House is looking to get?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would imagine he's in the $2-3 million a year range. Just a guess. He signed for $6 million a year with Jax and they cut him after two years when he lost his starting job last year.
Chris: Good Morning Ray. What is going to get us over the Pats hump next season? All I keep hearing is that we have to play press man coverage? Why cant our offense ever get anything going against them?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Pats had the top-ranked defense last season. They have good players and the best coach in the league.
Ken: With the loss of Timmons, do you find it more likely that the Steelers would draft ILB in the first round? or stick with edge guy or CB?
Ray Fittipaldo: Stick with edge and CB
Bryan10s: You really think the Steelers need another young inconsistent WR? Don't we have enough potential guys at that position? They need a possession veteran to make 3rd and 4 catches more than another young speed guy. Agree or disagree?
Ray Fittipaldo: They need a reliable No. 2 WR because they don't have one now. Preferably he'd be fast and would be able to stretch the field.
Chris: Which rookie defender from last year do you see breaking out in their sophomore season?
Ray Fittipaldo: Sean Davis. But he was the team ROY. I just think he'll settle in this summer and could make a bigger impact. Remember, he switched to slot CB in camp and then they sat him for a few weeks in the middle of the season. He'll just be a safety this season and I think he'll benefit.
Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for the questions this week. I'm on vacation next week so we'll see you in two weeks.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.