Free agency in the NFL begins March 9, which also signals the start of another period --- teams can again make trades.

The Steelers may well make one or more but maybe they should just sit this trading period out, judging by their most recent history of swaps – particularly when they give up a draft pick to acquire a player.

Take the past two years, for example, when they used three draft picks to trade for players and all three bombed.

In 2015, they traded a 2016 sixth-rounder to Jacksonville for kicker Josh Scobee. His contributions amounted to helping them lose two of the four games in which he kicked. He missed two field goals in a 28-21 loss at New England and two more in a 23-20 overtime loss to Baltimore.

Advertise with us

Also that season, they traded a 2016 fifth-round choice to Philadelphia for cornerback Brandon Boykin and then proceeded not to use him. He left after one season as a free agent without a hint of an offer from the Steelers.

Then in 2016, they traded a 2018 sixth-round pick to Cleveland for cornerback Justin Gilbert and he played 11 snaps on defense all season. The Steelers cut him Feb 6.

Those two failed cornerback trades had their seeds in 2015 second-round choice Senquez Golson, who has yet to play in a game after spending his first two seasons on injury lists. Had he not been hurt, the failed trades may never have been made.

In October 2013, the Steelers dealt a conditional draft choice to Arizona for left tackle Levi Brown. During warmups before his first game in a Steelers uniform, Brown pulled a triceps muscle, went on injured reserve, collected his money and was waived in March 2014. At least because of the conditions, the Steelers did not have to lose the pick.

During the 2013 draft, they swapped a 2014 third-round pick to Cleveland for the right to draft safety Shamarko Thomas in the fourth round. Thomas played hardly at all on defense during his four seasons with the Steelers, including just five snaps in 2016. He becomes a free agent March 9 and is not expected back.

Advertise with us

Sadly for the Steelers, that’s not all. In 2012, they traded their picks in the fourth and sixth rounds to Washington in order to draft defensive tackle Alameda Ta’amu in the fourth round. His failures would take as long as Carson Street to describe.

If they somehow still insist on trading despite that sorry history over the past six years, they need to find the magic they had when general manager Kevin Colbert first joined them at the beginning of the 21st century.

A look back, with the help of Pro Football Reference:

Colbert made a successful splash in his second NFL draft. His first trade was to move three spots down in the first round of 2001, swapping position with the Jets and selecting Casey Hampton while also adding picks in the fourth and sixth rounds.

Next in that draft, he sent Steelers choices to New England in the second and fourth rounds to move up in the second and grab linebacker Kendrell Bell, who became 2001 NFL defensive rookie of the year.

Advertise with us

In 2003, the Steelers moved up 11 spots in the first round by sending the Chiefs picks in the first, third and sixth rounds to snap up Troy Polamalu at No. 16 overall. No need to elaborate on the success of that deal.

A few tough ones followed, though, when the Steelers traded their second and fourth-round choices to the Colts and drafted cornerback bust Ricardo Colclough in the second round in 2004 (The Colts used that second-rounder to draft Bob Sanders). Two years later, the Steelers traded away a second-rounder for two thirds from the Vikings to draft Anthony Smith and Willie Reid.

But all was not lost in that 2006 draft when it came to trades. Colbert moved up seven spots in the first round by sending the Giants picks in the first, third and fourth rounds. He drafted Santonio Holmes, who would help eliver the Steelers’ sixth Lombardi Trophy nearly three years later.

Colbert’s best trade was practically a throw-away and it too involved Santonio Holmes. It came in 2010 when the Steelers were looking for another cornerback. They traded Holmes earlier that year to the Jets for a fifth-round pick – which was not a popular swap with their fan base -- after the gifted wide receiver wore out the welcome of his Super Bowl-winning catch.

They then used that No. 5 choice to re-acquire cornerback Bryant McFadden from the Arizona Cardinals. McFadden would go on to start every game in the Steelers 2010 season, their most recent Super Bowl visit.

Advertise with us

But while the objective of the Steelers was to acquire McFadden, it turned out not to be close to the most important part of the trade. The Cardinals tossed in an extra bone, giving up their sixth-round choice in 2010.

Although the Steelers had little idea whom they would pick in the sixth round when they made the trade, they wound up with one of their most valuable late-round players of all time – Antonio Brown.

So if Kevin Colbert, Mike Tomlin et. al. plan to trade again this year, they should go back to their old formula. The one they’ve used lately has not worked out.

---

The Steelers have until Wednesday to use their franchise tag and that almost surely will go to Le’Veon Bell.

Advertise with us

Since Kevin Colbert said last week that the team has been negotiating seriously with only Antonio Brown, we have to assume they are not close to agreeing with Bell on a multi-year contract. Bell would become an unrestricted free agent March 9 if he does not receiver the franchise tag.

The Steelers can tag Bell and then sign him to a long-term deal, but they may be better off just giving him the franchise tag and see what happens next season.

There are three tags teams can use – the exclusive franchise, the non-exclusive franchise and the transition. Almost everyone uses the non-exclusive franchise tag these days because another team would have to give up two first-round picks if they, say, signed Bell and the Steelers declined to match that deal. No team will do that.

That tag would run the Steelers a little more than $12 million in salary in 2017 for Bell, as projected. If he performs as they hope, they could sign him to a multi-year deal in 2018 or tag him again for one year.

Not only would that likely be the cheaper option for the Steelers, it would allow them to determine if Bell a) Can stay relatively injury free and b) Stay smokeless.

Advertise with us

Bell has missed time because of injuries in each of his four season, most recently playing only briefly in the AFC championship game because of a groin injury he says might need surgery. He also missed time to open each of the past two seasons because of suspensions after he failed and/or missed drug tests.

Last season, he touched the ball 405 times, including playoffs – 326 runs, 79 receptions – the most of his career. His previous high was 2014 when he had 373 combined touches.

What the Steelers need to determine is how long Bell can continue at that pace. There was an old theory known as the “Curse of 370” in which it was documented on many occasions that once a back hit 370 touches in one season, a decline soon followed.

Bell is one of the most dynamic backs in the NFL, if not the best, and he just turned 25. What the Steelers must determine is whether he can continue to be that kind of performer over the next several years. They can buy time by giving him the franchise tag, and have the same discussion a year from now with more evidence to go on.