POLL: What should the Steelers do with Le'Veon Bell? A. Tag him and sign to long-term deal (59%) B. Tag him and let him walk after 2017 season (10%) C. Tag him twice and let him walk after 2018 season (31%)

Larry: I really don't see any draft pick making us that much better next year - any chance they make a splash with a couple of free agents, especially with the cap space?

Ray Fittipaldo: You must have forgotten about the 2016 draft already. Javon Hargrave was a starter for most of the season. Artie Burns and Sean Davis earned starting jobs midway through the season. All did well for rookies. I'd much rather build through the draft and sign my own impending free agents rather than signing other team's free agents to contracts that often end up being bloated due to the mismanagement of other teams. The Steelers might add some depth players through free agency, but I'm not a big proponent of finding starters there. Just look at what happened with Ladarius Green last year. Buyer beware.

Guest: Ray do you think the steelers may have interest in Victor Cruz? He's injury prone sure, but has great hands

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I actually think the Steelers are OK at slot receiver. Eli Rogers played 51 percent of the offensive snaps in his first season. That was the second-most on the team behind Antonio Brown. Rogers was productive and the Steelers like him. I think the Steelers have to draft a receiver in April, but I'd like to see them draft another big receiver in the event Martavis Bryant is not reinstated or slips up again. They did that in 2015 with Sammie Coates, but he just hasn't done enough in two seasons to prove to me he is a capable replacement for Bryant. They desperately need another receiver that can make defenses pay whe they decide to double Antonio Brown. The Steelers didn't have that last season. I mentioned Rogers playing the second-most among receivers last season. Do you know who played the third-most snaps? Cobi Hamilton. They really need more quality depth behind Brown. Drafting a receiver in the first three rounds would solve that and would serve as insurance for Bryant.

StillerFanInClevel...: At OLB, to help pass rush and the secondary, wouldn't it be better to go into FA and get someone who can make an immediate impact like Perry or Ingram? A rookie is going to take a year or two to learn the system, etc. Thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: I just think free agency's is fool's gold more often than not. Yes, you can find guys like James Farrior every so often, but the way to build your team is through the draft. And when those players come up for second contracts you use your cap space to sign them to long-term deals. The Steelers have dabbled in free agency and have signed starters such as Mike Mitchell. But if you look at their history they've mostly used it to add depth to their roster.

Chuck: Could you comment on the play of Tyler Matakevich this past season.

Ray Fittipaldo: Solid special teams player, good depth player at ILB. Should be better in 2017.

Advertise with us

Jud: Likelihood that a 2017 drafted CB starts by Week 8?

Ray Fittipaldo: That depends on what round the CB is selected. If it's a first-round CB then you could see something along the lines that we saw with Artie Burns last season. It also would depend upon Senquez Golson. If you saw Kevin Colbert's quotes about Golson last week it hardly sounds like they're counting on him. He hasn't played a down of football in more than two years. But I definitely think they'll add a CB in the first few rounds in April. It's such a good class for CBs and the NFL remains very much a passing league. You need quality CBs and the Steelers don't have enough of them.

Jud: Obviously we'll be targeting second tier (dollar wise) talent for Free Agency...who do you think / know is on the Steelers radar?

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe a reserve DL. Not sure if they'll re-sign Ricardo Mathews for another year. They could draft a DL as well to provide depth. Maybe a TE if they don't re-sign David Johnson. People don't realize how much Todd Haley likes to use his TEs. After Jesse James, David Johnson logged the second-most snaps among TEs this year.

Jud: When do you feel that we should consider finding Ben's replacement?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: One or two years before he retires. The Steelers have a good enough relationship with Roethlisberger that they should be able to make that happen as long as he is honest with them.

Jud: Why the struggle with Special Teams? Seems as though it's been the Achilles heel for a couple years now.

Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers were 20th in the NFL in special teams this year, according to the Dallas Morning News rankings. Those rankings are well-respected throughout the NFL. So the Steelers aren't great, but there are 11 other teams in the league that are worse. My biggest problem with the special teams is the kickoff return team. They continually made bad decisions taking the ball out of the end zone. When they did bring the ball out they weren't very good at it. Maybe they need to commit better players to play on special teams. And maybe they have to change things up with their scheme.

I think that the S...: I think that the Steelers whent from a "choose your poison" offensive team to a "one demention" offense" team at the end os the season. On the other side of the ball we badly need an edge rusher and a second CB. Do you think that we should deal the offensive problem thru free agency, and the defensive problem thru the Draft?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think you can deal with both through the draft. They can easily select their OLB and CB in the first two rounds of the draft and get a capable receiver in the third round. Or they can get their receiver in the second round and take their OLB or CB in the third round. Here's another example of how free agency is fool's gold. Remember Lance Moore? He was signed and never developed a chemistry with Roethlisberger. He was gone after one season. The Steelers like to develop their own and I expect they'll continue to do that.

Advertise with us

Marty: Against New England I feel that the dropped passes and penalties were as much reason for the loss as the defense maybe next year

Ray Fittipaldo: For me, the defense was the biggest problem. That was no contest against Tom Brady. He picked them apart. They had no answers for him. Sure, the drops and penalties didn't help the Steelers, but they could have played mistake-free football on offense in that game and still might have lost by two touchdowns.

Chuck: I think we should skip drafting a RB or WR in the draft. I think we have enough quality at both. Shouldn't we stock up on OLB's, CB's, DL, and other positions rather than a RB or WR who probably won't see the field?

Ray Fittipaldo: See previous answer on the receiver. If you want to go into next season with Cobi Hamilton as your No. 3 receiver then fine. But if you actually want to have a good offense you need to find better depth than him. And don't tell me Bryant is coming back. We don't know that for sure. And even if he is reinstated you don't know if he'll be available for all 16 games.

They need to get younger at RB behind Bell, too. DeAngelo Williams was productive for his two years with the team, but he missed six games with a knee injury this season. He's 34 and players' bodies start to break down as they age.

Advertise with us

Guest: In general I agree with your point about building through the draft - how that is the way to go. However, with that in mind, the steelers drafting Jarvis Jones which was a failure and before that J. Worlids decided to leave the NFL. Given those misses, I think maybe a move in free agency might not be a bad idea at OLB.

Ray Fittipaldo: If they do that it's probably a stop-gap move unless you find a young and ascending player. And usually those guys are the most expensive players in free agency. Bud Dupree is going to start and play most of the snaps at LOLB. James Harrison will start at ROLB. He is probably best served at playing 50 percent of the snaps so you need to find a player that can come in and play half the snaps as a rookie or in free agency. I just think they'll try to find that player through the draft.

Steelers fan4life: Hi Ray thanks for the chat. Do you see the Steelers drafting more on the defensive side, the offensive side, or more balanced this year?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think it'll be fairly balanced. The obvious needs are at OLB and CB when it comes to the high draft picks, but they'll probably draft a receiver, a running back and maybe another tight end, maybe even a developmental QB.

Guest: Thank you, I really liked your in-depth analysis of the red zone failures. How much do you think those failures can be attributed to Ben's desire to have his receivers 'college open'?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks. If you read the analysis you saw that blame can be shared. Roethlisberger had some mistakes, physical and mental. But so did others. Some offensive linemen missed blocks or had missed assignments. Some receivers had missed assignments or drops. It's never one person's fault, but QB is important because he is the chief decision-maker and has the ball in his hands so often. Roethlisberger didn't have one of his better seasons and that was especially the case in the red zone. He needs to improve in that area but so does every other player on that offense.

Guest: What was your impression of Gilbert? That he did not like football and wasn't committed to the craft or that he had a bad attitude? all of the above?

Ray Fittipaldo: It's hard to say. I can watch practice, but I don't know what goes on behind closed doors. Is he getting the playbook down, etc. Those things are harder to know. But it doesn't speak well for him that two organizations have given up on a player with that much physical talent.

Steelers fan4life: Does Timmins like being in Pittsburgh? If so would he be willing to do a hometown discount?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think he likes playing for the Steelers, but it looks like the Steelers are going to let him test the market. As Tomlin said after the season free agency is free for the player and the team. I think the Steelers would like him back, but at the right price.

Advertise with us

SteelerFanatic: Ray, the Steelers scored the same amount of points as the Bills and just a bit more than Wash... they don't have the talent we have... wouldn't it make sense to just build quality defense with afditions this draft? Ben is not elite enough to carry this team imho.

Ray Fittipaldo: I do think the defense has to get a lot better if the Steelers are going to win another Super Bowl with Roethlisberger at QB. That's not a knock on Roethlisberger. This defense just struggles too much against the really good QBs in this league. They need to get back to where they were last decade when it comes to their defense. That being said, Roethlisberger needs better weapons around him to be more successful.

Do you think Ben l...: Is there any indication of the Steelers feelings about Shamarko Thomas play? I know he has had his share of injuries this past season.

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think Shamarko Thomas will be back. Injury prone and did not show an ability to pick up the defense in his four years here.

Ronald Ocean: AB is wearing thin on me with this "Branding" thing. I think he is selfish and more worried about his image and not the team. Is there any chance that he will knock off the nonsense, or at least save it just for the offseason?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks Ronald. Good to hear form you. The Steelers view Brown's behavior as little annoyances. Art Rooney said as much a few weeks ago. So if you're Brown, what incentive is there to change your behavior all that much? Sure, Tomlin got the message across about the Facebook Live thing, but the dancing, the penalties and the other nonsense don't appear to be that big of a deal to the person signing his paychecks.

elcid97: I read a great summation of the Falcons' defensive scheme against the Pats. They used a "robber" scheme to take away the underneath routes while using press coverage outside and rushing 4. It seems if the offense hadn't left them on the field so long, it was something that would've worked. Are the Steelers interested in finding personnel to run schemes similar or would it be too different from our current 3-4 philosophy? I'm wondering if even with better personnel (which we had in the past), Brady just destroys our scheme.

Ray Fittipaldo: Right. The Falcons had a great scheme for three quarters. They kept Brady in check until the fourth quarter. Give Brady credit for eventually figuring things out. But let's take into account what you said. The Falcons defenders were gassed because the offensive coordinator refused to run the ball when game circumstances dictated he should be running. We'd all be applauding Dan Quinn for his defensive game plan if not for Kyle Shanahan. Yes, their scheme can and did work. You just have to have the right personnel to make it happen. For the Steelers, that would mean getting another CB who can play press/man coverage. And that would mean generating a better pass rush.

SteelerFanatic: Ray, Free agency also produced Will Wofford, Duval Love, Eric Pegram, Jeff Hartings, Kevin Greene, Jerricho Cotchery, Ryan Clark, Fartior, etc. That coin has two sides. I would let Timmons walk and sign a Gerald Hodges type. or draft Riddick and sign a Nick Perry. Your $$$ savings with Timmons would offset Perry. Thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: You're naming guys from 20 and 25 years ago. That's fine. I'm still not spending a lot of money in free agency when there are guys like Brown, Bell, Shazier and Tuitt to sign. The Steelers will be spending a lot of money to sign their own. Doesn't mean they won't sign free agents. They will. I just don't expect high-priced guys who project as starters.

Advertise with us

Scott in Dallas: What OLB's on the roster can split snaps with Harrison?

Ray Fittipaldo: Based on their rotation late in the season no one. Chickillo and Moats are serviceable guys as reserves, but neither are impact defenders. That's why you have to draft someone. He'll be the future starter after Harrison retires and hopefully a guy who can spell Harrison in 2017.

Alan: I agree with you that it's essential that the steelers draft a CB high in the draft? However, do you see any possibility of free agency also being an option to get a CB?

Ray Fittipaldo: This is not a good year for free agent CBs. Much better crop in the draft.

Jack of Splat: I want to think Coates was an answer at WR but learning about his injuiries for the season, it sounds like he should have been on IR. I think I agree there are more questions than answers about him at this point. Drafting another WR in first 3 rounds makes sense.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Agreed.

Guest: Ray, I agree with SteelerFanatic. Brady, Rogers, and other QBs do a lot more with less. BR has arguably the best wr, rb and offensive line. Yet they fail to score points.

Ray Fittipaldo: But if teams double team Brown and take him away you need a viable second receiving option. The Steelers did not have that last season. Jesse James had the second-most catches in the postseason behind Brown. Roethlisberger needs another receiver. If it's Bryant, great. The offense will be really good. If not, they need to find someone who can be better than Cobi Hamilton. And that players ideally would relegate Eli Rogers to a third receiver role. He's a good player, but ideally Rogers isn't your second-leading receiver.

Jack of Splat: Hi, Ray Always a Ben fan but he has the best WR and RB in the NFL. How many more weapons does he need?

Ray Fittipaldo: Good teams like the Patriots can take Brown out of games. The Steelers need a true No. 2 receiver to make teams like the Patriots think twice about their treatment of Brown.

Advertise with us

Scott in Dallas: We currently have a starting, backup (if Jones is resigned), and a developmental QB. Do we really need to draft anybody in the late rounds?

Ray Fittipaldo: Depends what they do with Mettenberger. If they don't like him they could draft someone and cut him.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for all the questions today. We'll do another chat same time next week.