Much of the talk leading up to the AFC championship centered on whether New England was a well-tested team. The list of quarterbacks the Patriots faced in the weeks leading up to the game was not impressive, and it was suggested they had come upon their 14-2 record during the regular season because the caliber of quarterbacks they faced had been so weak.
Looking back, perhaps the same could have been said of the quarterbacks the Steelers faced in their nine-game winning streak that preceded the title game. The best quarterback they faced in the second half of the season (by passer rating) was Kansas City’s Alex Smith, who has never been mentioned as an elite quarterback. When the Steelers finally came upon an elite quarterback in the AFC championship, their pass defense was exposed.
Tom Brady is one of the best quarterbacks of all time, and he makes it look ridiculously easy against the Steelers. After throwing for a postseason franchise record 384 yards and three touchdowns Sunday, Brady has thrown 24 touchdowns and no interceptions against the Steelers since Mike Tomlin became the head coach in 2007.
That should prompt plenty of soul searching inside the Steelers offices over the next six months. They finished one step away from their goal, and if they want to get to the Super Bowl next year they had better figure out a way to beat Brady and the Patriots, who just played in their sixth consecutive AFC title game.
As the Steelers prepare for the 2017 season, their top priority should be finding a cornerback to play opposite Artie Burns who can be used in press man coverage schemes. They don’t have to drastically change their defense — their predominantly zone defense has been good enough to make the playoffs three consecutive years — but if they ever want to beat Brady, they need more versatile personnel. And they need Tomlin and his staff to be more creative so their schemes aren’t as predictable.
The Steelers need an edge rusher early in the draft. They could use a receiver and maybe even an inside linebacker if Lawrence Timmons isn’t re-signed, but the path past Brady requires better pass defense.
Steelers Report: Ed and Gerry analyze the 2016 Steelers season
New England doesn’t lose often, but when they do there is a common theme. When the Patriots lost for the only time this season with Brady at quarterback, it came against Seattle, a defense that thrives with its man coverage schemes. And when the Patriots lost to Denver in the AFC championship a year ago, Brady struggled against the Broncos’ top-rated pass defense that also featured man coverage schemes.
When the Steelers beat the Patriots in 2011 at Heinz Field they did it by playing large doses of man coverage. They’re 0 for 4 against the Patriots since playing predominantly zone.
When he was asked Tuesday at his season-ending news conference why man coverage wasn’t an option Sunday, Tomlin said: “I base our matchups on what our people are capable of doing and doing well. The personnel was different [in 2011].”
The Steelers drafted Burns in the first round because he can run, has length and can cover, and they need to utilize his skill set. He said Monday as he was clearing out his locker that he would welcome the opportunity to play more man coverage and believes it would help the defense.
Veteran William Gay, who was demoted from starter to nickel back halfway through the season and was exposed by Brady in the championship game, is unlikely to return. Senquez Golson, the 2015 second-round pick who has not yet played a down in the NFL, is an option to replace Gay, but the Steelers can’t count on him because of his injury history. Justin Gilbert is an option, too, but he barely played after coming over from the Browns in a trade.
The Steelers can’t hope that one or both will be able to step in and play a key role next season. They have to upgrade the position with better talent and give defensive coordinator Keith Butler the ability to diversify his defense.
The Steelers improved their pass defense this season, but they remain below average. They finished the regular season 18th in passing yards allowed (246 yards per game) and 18th in opponent quarterback rating (89.5).
For those who say the Steelers can’t spend their offseason concentrating to beat one team, consider the other quarterbacks on the 2017 schedule. In addition to Brady the Steelers will play Aaron Rodgers of Green Bay, Sam Bradford of Minnesota, Andrew Luck of Indianapolis and Marcus Mariota of Tennessee. All five finished among the top 10 in the NFL in 2016 passer rating. They also have to face Matthew Stafford of Detroit, who finished 13th in passer rating and led the Lions to the playoffs.
The Steelers faced three quarterbacks in the top 10 in passer rating in 2016, including Brady (twice), Dak Prescott of Dallas and Kirk Cousins of Washington. They were 1-3 in those games, beating Cousins. They gave up 27, 36 and 35 points and an average of 308 passing yards in the other three games.
On second thought, forget about getting past New England in the playoffs. The Steelers might not even get there if they don’t find some corners capable of playing in man coverage.
•
NOTE — Fullback Roosevelt Nix will sign his one-year tender Friday for $615,000, his agent Bill Parise said. Nix, who just completed his second NFL season, was an exclusive rights free agent and could not negotiate with another team.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.