Doug Whaley never envisioned a job in professional football, much less becoming a general manager of a National Football League franchise.
He planned on being a stockbroker, and had even begun to fulfill his intention by moving to New York and working for a small brokerage firm on Wall Street.
That’s where Whaley made a wise investment.
He returned to football and never looked back.
In February 1995, Whaley got a phone call from then-Steelers general manager Tom Donahoe, asking him if he’d be interested in an internship in the scouting department. Because he was allowed to take a one-year sabbatical at his brokerage firm and still retain the option of returning, Whaley accepted Donahoe’s offer.
“They told me if it didn’t work out [with the Steelers] I could come back in a year,” said Whaley, who played football at Upper St. Clair High School and Pitt. “But that was the year we went to the Super Bowl with the Cowboys. I thought it was always going to be that easy. You quickly realize it’s not going to be that easy.”
Whaley never went back to Wall Street.
More than two decades later, he is in his fourth season as general manager of the Buffalo Bills, who are fighting for a wild-card playoff spot thanks to several daring trades made by the Upper St. Clair native. Standing in their way is Whaley’s former employer and hometown team, the Steelers, whom the Bills play Sunday in Orchard Park, N.Y.
After his one-year internship was over, Whaley went to work for three seasons as a northeast scout for the Seattle Seahawks, who hired him on the recommendation of Tom Modrak, the Steelers former director of college scouting. In 1999, he got another call from Donahoe, this time offering him the position of director of pro personnel with the Steelers, replacing Charles Bailey.
“I’ve known Doug since when he played at Upper St. Clair and he stopped in at the offices one Christmas and said I really want to get into personnel,” said Donahoe, who is a senior director of player personnel for the Philadelphia Eagles. “I said Doug, your parents know you’re in here talking about this? You out of your mind? He said he had the desire to do this and he really wanted to do it.
“I told him to give it a lot of thought. There’s a lot of highs and a lot of tremendous lows and it’s a difficult lifestyle. If you want to do it I’ll be glad to try to help you, but I think you need to give it a lot of thought.”
Whaley did. For a good second or two.
He spent 10 seasons in that role with the Steelers and learned much of everything he applies today with the Bills. Whaley left the Steelers in 2010 to become assistant GM to Buddy Nix in Buffalo. When Nix retired after the 2013 draft, Whaley was promoted to general manager.
“I learned from everybody I came into contact there, with the Rooneys, Tom Donahoe, Kevin Colbert, Bill Nunn and Charles Bailey,” Whaley said. “The basic philosophy I live by in this business is the things that make you win in this league never change and the only things that change are the excuses why you lose.”
One of Whaley’s first significant moves in Buffalo was not very popular: He said he had an “integral part” in drafting quarterback E.J. Manuel with the 16th overall pick in the 2013 draft. At the time, Whaley was still second-in-command to Nix. Even though the Manuel selection failed miserably, Whaley showed he is not afraid to make tough decisions.
Since then, he has:
• Traded productive linebacker Kiko Alonso, a No. 2 draft choice in 2013, to Philadelphia for running back LeSean “Shady” McCoy, who was oft-injured and had fallen into disfavor with the Eagles. When healthy, the former Pitt star remains one of the best all-purpose backs in the league and is averaging 77.9 yards rushing and 99.1 scrimmage yards in 22 games with the Bills.
• Traded up in the 2014 draft to take wide receiver Sammy Watkins, a move that was decried by some because of what the Bills had to give up to get him. Whaley traded his ninth overall pick in that draft plus a first- and fourth-round pick in the 2015 draft to the Cleveland Browns to move up to the No. 4 overall spot to take Watkins.
• Signed quarterback Tyrod Taylor in free agency in 2015, an unheralded move at the time because Taylor was a backup with the Baltimore Ravens. Even though head coach Rex Ryan wanted Taylor, Whaley still had to sign off on the move.
• Acquired rush linebacker/defensive end Jerry Hughes in a 2013 trade with the Indianapolis Colts that might be one of the best deals in Bills history. Hughes has 30 sacks in 44 games since coming to Buffalo.
“All our moves were to get top-flight, quality players,” Whaley said. “We want to get the best players out there. The best players win.
“My owners, myself and the coach, we want to build something where we are consistently in the conversation to win a championship. It’s not easy to do. We’re still building. That’s what you want to be — always in the conversation. We haven’t been there for a long, long time. I think we’re on our way.”
Whaley’s background in pro scouting has had a significant impact on the Bills roster since he took over as general manager four years ago.
Some of the other notable players he acquired are guard Richie Incognito, a risky move given his problems in Miami with “Bullygate;” tight end Charles Clay; running back Mike Gillislee, tackle Jordan Mills, linebackers Manny Lawson and Zach Brown, and cornerback Corey Graham.
“I learned one thing as a scout — get the best player available,” Whaley said. “It doesn’t matter what position sometimes. You can never have too many good players. Don’t pass one up.”
Neither did Donahoe when he had the chance to hire Whaley.
“He’s got a great eye for talent and he has the right type of personality where he can get along with people,” Donahoe said. “He’s very engaging, very hard-working. He has a great fan in his corner in me.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.