Ed Bouchette: Good afternoon, let's begin

Troy: Ed, your coach Tomlin who do you put on Odell Beckham JR? Cockrell or Burns?

Ed Bouchette: I'd play them straight up, keep them on their sides rather than follow him around.

Adam: Ive read about the end of the Ravens game and it seems what the Ravens did was both totally legal and also illegal at the same time, but only if they had to run the same play a second time. Why can't the NFL prevent things like that to happen more effectively?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: They'll probably come up with a rule now. But how do you know what is intentional holding? I mean, it was obvious Sunday because they were tackling guys. It doesn't happen that often, though, that there needs to be a new rule.

Teams have allowed other teams to score so they can get the ball back quickly. It happened in a Super Bowl. Why is that any different? In fact, that may be worse.

Leo Lee: Great chat as always Ed, now that Jarvis has 0 sacks through 11 games, are you finally prepared to call him a bust? No more excuses of injuries, playing time, etc, please level with us at this point.

Ed Bouchette: He's been a disappointment. I've seen some real busts and they make Jarvis Jones look like Lawrence Taylor.

Andy: I love how everyone is picking the Steelers in this game, like they were in the Cowboys game, even though the Giants like the Cowboys are the superior team with a superior record. Didn't work out so well for the Steelers last time. Who are you picking Ed?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I will let you know Sunday before the game. I have to watch video of the Giants all week first.

Karl: Thanks for another chat, Ed. So, the defense has looked better over the last two weeks. Is Cleveland and Indy really that bad, or could we be getting a little better? Thanks again!

Ed Bouchette: It probably is a little of both.

ssa76: I saw two Cowboys do exactly what Ab and Bell did and not get flagged. Every game some player does something that AB would get penalized for. Don't you think he's getting extra scrutiny?

Ed Bouchette: Probably, which means he should be extra cautious about that stuff.

Advertise with us

Adam: Should Butler triple team OBJ

Ed Bouchette: Quadruple maybe

PGHfaninCali: If the Steelers can't beat the Ravens and the Ravens D is better than the Steelers, How can the Steelers win the division?

Ed Bouchette: By beating the Ravens on Christmas Day and winning more games than Baltimore does.

Theo: Do you think L. Green is still shaking off rust or is this what he is, a 2-3 catch a game guy?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: If two catches are going to get you 67 yards, maybe that's enough. Give him a break, he could not practice for half the season, not in camp, not even in the spring. He's not going to catch 10 passes a game in his first few games back.

Fort Worth Mike: Hi Ed, is Ben fed up with AB's penalties for celebration?

Ed Bouchette: Not as much as the fans and media seem to be.

GSK: Hi Ed, enjoyed "Chuck Noll A Football Life" it was long overdue and well done...what an interesting man... what were thoughts on the piece?

Ed Bouchette: The same. Very well done.

Advertise with us

Andy: We really need Coates to step up big the next five games. What's the latest with his finger?

Ed Bouchette: It's healing. You saw him a little more vs. Colts and I think that will increase vs. Giants.

Leon: Could Jarvis make a move inside? He does seem fast and with a nose for the ball, just not for sacking the QB

Ed Bouchette: The Steelers drafted him to sack the quarterback.

KingintheNorth: Long time reader, first time chatter, Do you think Tomlin gets pressured by ownership to make a change at D-coordinator after this year, a la Arians?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: No, I think they are happy with Keith Butler.

Adam: Which game are you more concerned about, the Giants this weekend or the Bills on the road? It seems to me that if we win our remaining division games we should win the division.

Ed Bouchette: I don't worry about game outcomes. But I think the Bills on the road may be the more difficult one for the Steelers.

Derek: What's your guess as who gets left out of the OLB rotation? Jarvis seems to make the littlest impact

Ed Bouchette: I would say Jarvis Jones for several reasons, including the one you mentioned. However, Arthur Moats had the fewest snaps of the five last week, just 17. Bud Dupree has played mostly on the left, where Anthony Chickillo plays. Jones and James Harrison are on the right.

Advertise with us

Rob: What are Alan Faneca's chances of getting elected to the Hall of Fame in February?

Ed Bouchette: I would say 50-50

Andy: What's your prediction now on the Steelers final record and whether they make the playoffs? I think you were at 11-5 esrlier in the season

Ed Bouchette: Yes, down from that. 10-6 or 9-7. I think they will win their final two at home.

Ryno: What do you think the odds are of signing DeAngelo Williams to another contract next year? Same question for James Harrison.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I would think they'd go younger at RB. If Harrison wants to come back and finishes as strong as he's playing now, he can come back.

Jensen: You think they're happy with Butler? What team have you been watching all season?

Ed Bouchette: Have you seen the talent they've given him? What players have YOU been watching all season. You like that secondary before the rookies were finally healed and ready? How about the outside linebackers?

JerseySteel: Hi Ed - how do you rate the play of the top 3 picks so far this season?

Ed Bouchette: After the first two were slowed by injuries, they're coming on, and Hargrave is improving.

Advertise with us

Adam: Of the three rookies starting, who have you been most impressed by? Are they starting due to lack of talent/depth or because they truly earned time?

Ed Bouchette: I think you would say both -- lack of talent and depth and because they have earned it. I said from the beginning I thought Sean Davis could be their best player in the draft, and I'm sticking to it. But I also like how Artie Burns and Hargrave have played.

Adam: Should an NFL kicker be expected to make a 55 yard FG? Steelers kickers always seem to be reliable under 50, but many (not all) kickers around the league have the leg for 60 yarders and I think that puts us at a disadvantage.

Ed Bouchette: There are not many 60-yarders made nor tried in the NFL.

Andy: So if the Steelers sole defensive problem is talent, why does Volvert still have a job?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Where does Volvert work?

Tom: It sure seems to me that if Baltimore wins this weekend, the Steelers and Ravens are going to have the same record coming into their matchup on Christmas. Your thought?

Ed Bouchette: A Christmas Showdown!

GSK: Hi Ed, does the NFL have something against the Steelers...having them back to back road games on a Sunday then a Thursday?

Ed Bouchette: First time since 2007 any NFL team had such a schedule and they became first team since 2004 to win both.

Advertise with us

Adam: Can the Steelers continue to rely so heavily on Brown and Bell for 60% of offensive production? I am worried one fluke play could bring everything crashing down since we have no depth left on offense.

Ed Bouchette: So, you want to use them less? Rest them?

Sorry, Ben Roethlisberger plays every play. You going to worry about him too? All the offensive linemen play every play. Most of the defensive players play every play.

Joe: From your reporting, who would/can/should tell AB to knock the BS off? Tomlin, Harrison, Ben?

Ed Bouchette: Mike Tomlin. The buck stops there.

Advertise with us

Big Meany: The Packers came out, last night, and really set the tone for that game with a no huddle look. It seems like we always hear from the Steelers how much they like it, but rarely use it on gameday. Have Tomlin and co. Mentioned it lately?

Ed Bouchette: Steelers use plenty of no-huddle, especially at home.

Steeler in Charlotte: Is Bell getting any extra "off days" in practice after being the workhorse the last two weeks, or does this mini-bye take care of things and keep him fresh? I cringe every time he goes down ackwardly

Ed Bouchette: The Steelers do not live in their fears.

Jarvis: Do you still believe the team shouldn't give Bell a big extension? Shazier, AB, & Tuitt are the only other guys I can think of that will need big extensions soon. Doesn't seem like it will be a big cap issue

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I think he will be here next season, but it may be under the franchise or transition tag.

Steeler in Charlotte: When Bell came back from suspension, they lined him up wide a lot and put Deangelo in the backfield that first game. See that coming back when Williams is healthy?

Ed Bouchette: No. You did not see that much and I would keep lining Bell in the backfield more than out wide.

Rich: Ed do you see next years starting outside line backers on this team right now?

Ed Bouchette: Yes

Advertise with us

JPR: Steelers WR's in 2017…. Brown, Bryant, Coates, Rodgers, DHB?

Ed Bouchette: That sounds about right. They'll probably draft one too. Markus Wheaton is not likely to return.

Adam: Will the Steelers need to score 30 to beat the Giants?

Ed Bouchette: The Giants do not score a lot.

Adam: Do the STeelers expect Bryant to come back and play next year or is his drug problem still holding him back? Has he been sober?

Ed Bouchette: I have no idea what Martavis Bryant is up to. He hasn't been around. The Steelers would like to have him back next season but I don't think he can be counted on.

Andrew: Who plays ILB next year?

Ed Bouchette: Shazier and Vince Williams, barring other pickups.

Troy: Have the Steelers maybe discovered something with having Cam Heyward out. It seems that Hargrave can play pretty well, when sifted to end. Could the Steelers be heading the way of a base 4-3? Could Tuitt and Heyward play 4-3 Defensive ends?

Ed Bouchette: I think they could play those spots but you really don't have enough linemen to play those positions and your outside linebackers are more 3-4 types than 4-3.

Andy: If the Steelers sole defensive problem is talent, why does Colbert still have a job?

Ed Bouchette: Because it's not his fault that 2015 top picks were hurt -- Dupree and Senquez Golson. That Artie Burns was hurt for most of camp and it delayed his progress. That Cam Heyward is out with an injury. That Jason Worilds quit the game at his peak. That those great Steelers defenses of this century got old together. That they keep drafting near the bottom of the rounds because they've been so successful.

Tom: How do are our special teams stack up vs an average NFL unit?

Ed Bouchette: Below average.

Ed Bouchette: Thank you for another great chat. See you next Tuesday.