It’s not true the unluckiest creatures on earth Thanksgiving Day are turkeys. It’s the Steelers, who have been stuffed, carved and served as holiday meals for the better part of their 83-year existence.

When President Obama issued his annual Presidential Turkey Pardon earlier this week he should have pardoned the Steelers from ever playing on the holiday again. Steelers chairman Dan Rooney, his former Ambassador to Ireland, might have appreciated it.

The Steelers have played seven times on Thanksgiving and won once. That victory came 66 years ago against the Chicago Cardinals before 11,622 fans at Comiskey Park.

The Steelers never have played at home on Thanksgiving, and that tradition will continue tonight when they face the Indianapolis Colts at Lucas Oil Stadium in the final game of an NFL tripleheader.

Advertise with us

It’s not that Thanksgivings involving the Steelers haven’t been memorable. It’s just that they’ve been memorable for all the wrong reasons.

There was a 42-point loss in Detroit 33 years ago when Cliff Stoudt and Mark Malone combined to throw five interceptions in a 45-3 drubbing at the hands of the Lions. If ever there was a game that defined the transition from the Steelers’ dynastic years to the 1980s it was this one. Frank Pollard outrushed Franco Harris, 82-16, and leading receiver was Greg Garrity, who had two receptions for 31 yards. Defensive starters included John Goodman, Tom Beasley and Rick Woods, and they had no answers for Lions quarterback Eric Hipple or running back Billy Sims.

There was Phil Luckett and Jerome Bettis starring in the most infamous coin toss in NFL history 15 years later in Detroit. At the coin toss before overtime, Bettis called tails. Luckett, the referee, said Bettis called “heads-tails” when the coin was in the air and awarded the ball to the Lions, who went on to kick the winning field goal on their first possession. It was the first of five consecutive losses to end the season after a promising 7-4 start.

“It was a ridiculous call, and we lose the game because of it,” Bettis said after the game.

Fifteen years after that, in 2013, the Steelers lost in Baltimore, 22-20, in a game that is remembered most for coach Mike Tomlin stepping onto the field and narrowly missing Baltimore kick-returner Jacoby Jones. He was later fined $100,000 and became the favorite NFL meme of the season.

Advertise with us

“I remember looking up at the Jumbotron and seeing coach Tomlin getting off the screen,” running back Le’Veon Bell said this week.

The memory still brings a smile and laugh from Bell. “I had forgotten about it,” he said. “We gave him a hard time about it back then. There was stuff on social media, him doing his dance getting out of the way.”

Jones got his revenge against Tomlin last season when he signed with the Steelers, well past his prime after being released by San Diego, and fumbled his way back to unemployment.

The game three years ago also is remembered for Bell getting knocked out after scoring an apparent touchdown in the fourth quarter. Bell’s concussion was so violent tight end Heath Miller blocked NBC cameras from coming onto the field from the end zone to capture the aftermath.

Bell didn’t remember the play and had to be told what happened after being helped to the Steelers bench.

Advertise with us

Steelers fans can only wish they had no recollection of the Steelers on Thanksgiving. The number of people who can remember the last time the Steelers won on Thanksgiving is dwindling by the day. Harry S. Truman was president in 1950 and Dan Rooney was 18, having quarterbacked North Catholic to the Pittsburgh Catholic League championship the previous fall.

Bell and other Steelers were surprised to find out this week about the long and losing history of the franchise on this day. And Bell, who figures to play a pivotal role in the outcome tonight, would like nothing more than to put an end to it.

“We’re 1-6 on Thanksgiving?” Bell said. “That’s crazy. Whether they’ve been on the road or at home, that’s just crazy. We definitely need to win to put that behind us, move forward and start a trend of winning of Thanksgiving.”

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.