The $1 billion National Football League concussion settlement is facing an eleventh-hour challenge from former players who say the deal is leaving them behind.
Among those who are quietly lending their support to the cause is Anthony Hamlet, the superintendent of the Pittsburgh Public Schools, who had a brief career in the NFL.
A petition filed with the U.S. Supreme Court in September argues that the concussion settlement is flawed because it provides no benefits for players yet to be diagnosed with chronic traumatic encephalopathy.
Mr. Hamlet is one of 135 former NFL players listed in a friend-of-the-court brief urging the Supreme Court to hear the case against the settlement.
“Although [the former players] favor a settlement, they do not believe that the current structure of the settlement is fair and reasonable,” according to the Oct. 31 brief. “Specifically, [they] are class members who are suffering from the symptoms of CTE or fear that they will someday suffer from those symptoms.”
Tim Howard, a Tallahassee, Fla.-based lawyer who represents the 135 former players, said he wasn’t sure Mr. Hamlet would benefit from the settlement “because he’s doing fine.”
“He’s a tribute to the best of football,” Mr. Howard said, “and his public service shows it.”
Mr. Hamlet declined to comment for this article. This spring, in an interview with the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, he described his football career as “a whole different life.”
●●●
Mr. Hamlet is one of several former players — from individuals who have been able to build successful post-football careers, like the schools administrator, to those who struggle to hold down a job — who worry that the concussion settlement will not adequately protect them from future health problems.
Lawyers for several former players have appealed to the Supreme Court to hear their concerns about the concussion settlement between the NFL and retired players.
The petition to the Supreme Court contends that the concussion settlement treats different groups of former players unequally.
That rubs the petitioners the wrong way. In addition to the friend-of-the-court document involving Mr. Hamlet, two other briefs have been filed with the court in support of this petition.
“That puts a human face on this problem, and it puts some numbers on the problem,” Deepak Gupta, a Washington, D.C.-based lawyer whose firm represents the appellants, said of the group of 135 players. “That’s not a small number, and people can assume there are a lot of people out there who are like them.”
●●●
At each juncture of his football career, Mr. Hamlet thrived on proving others wrong.
Growing up in Delray Beach, Fla., he was “a surprise” recruit to the University of Miami, a football powerhouse, according to the Palm Beach Post. He joined a formidable defense that produced stars such as Cortez Kennedy, Russell Maryland and even Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson, who graduated three years after Mr. Hamlet.
At 6 feet 3 inches and 265 pounds, Mr. Hamlet, known to teammates as “Hambone,” was small for a defensive lineman but strong and fast. Miami was a tough team known for taunting its opponents, and Mr. Hamlet was no exception.
“Hamlet could trash-talk with the best of them, believe me,” said Leon Searcy, Mr. Hamlet’s teammate at Miami, who is also listed in the friend-of-the-court brief and played offensive tackle for the Steelers from 1992 to 1995.
But the Hurricanes backed it up, winning three national championships in five years, including Mr. Hamlet’s final season in 1991.
While he didn’t necessarily have as much talent as some other Miami players, Mr. Hamlet did his homework, said Dennis Erickson, the Hurricanes’ former head coach.
“Probably over half of them played in the National Football League, but he fit in extremely well with them,” Mr. Erickson said. “He was more of a self-made player than a lot of them.”
In the 1992 NFL draft, the Seattle Seahawks selected Mr. Hamlet in the 10th round, and he signed with the team that summer. But his prospects, first with Seattle and then with the Indianapolis Colts the following year, were sidelined by knee injuries, and he never played a regular-season snap.
While playing at Miami, he was not prone to injuries, so he took the unlucky streak in football as a sign that he needed to shift gears, he told the Post-Gazette in May.
“I like the people I work with and I like the work I do,” he told the Palm Beach Post in 1996, when he was working at a high school in Florida. “I like to show young people that athletes can be positive role models and that teachers and the school can help them make a difference in their lives.”
●●●
Under the settlement, only players diagnosed with CTE prior to April 2015 will receive compensation specifically for that degenerative disease. Otherwise, players must have a qualifying disease, such as Lou Gehrig’s disease, dementia or Alzheimer’s, to receive benefits. The appellants argue that the settlement ignores the possibility that CTE — which, as of now, can be definitively diagnosed only after death — eventually could be identified in living people.
“Courts have to be especially careful that the results of those deals are fair for everyone,” Mr. Gupta said. “It’s a pretty fundamental question that goes to the legitimacy of how class actions are resolved.”
Mr. Searcy, who lives in Orlando, Fla., said he has long been involved in efforts to get former players compensated for their injuries. He also expressed concerns about his own brain health, and said he can be forgetful and experiences short-term memory loss.
Class counsel Christopher Seeger believes the Supreme Court should deny the case, arguing that the settlement has already survived several legal challenges and that the appeal merely delays the distribution of benefits to ill former athletes who sorely need them.
“The settlement was specifically designed to compensate those exhibiting symptoms of the most severe conditions associated with CTE — dementia, Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s and [Lou Gehrig’s disease],” he said in a statement.
Getting the Supreme Court to consider the petition is a long shot. But for critics of the concussion settlement, it is also the last shot. The court could decide whether to hear the case next month.
“This is the end of the line,” Mr. Gupta said. “If they don’t take the case, it’s over.”
Staff writer Molly Born contributed. Elizabeth Bloom: ebloom@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1750 and Twitter @BloomPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.