It was the beginning of one of the most successful and legendary careers in the National Football League, a game that launched one of the greatest quarterbacks of the modern era, and it happened in Three Rivers Stadium 33 years ago.
On a pleasant, 73-degree Western Pennsylvania day in September 1983, John Elway made his highly anticipated and tremendously hyped debut for the Denver Broncos against the Steelers, starting and winning what would be the first of his 148 NFL victories in a 16-year career.
Elway didn’t really beat the Steelers that day; backup Steve DeBerg did, replacing an injured Elway (elbow) in the second half and leading the Broncos to a 14-10 victory. Elway had aggravated a previous elbow injury in the second quarter and had completed just 1 of 8 passes for 14 yards with an interception when he was replaced by DeBerg.
Elway was the first overall pick in the draft that year, a class that also included Jim Kelly (Buffalo) and Dan Marino (Miami) in the first round. But it was the Baltimore Colts who drafted Elway, not the Broncos. However, Elway said he would never play for Baltimore and threatened to play baseball, forcing the Colts to trade him to the Broncos.
Surprisingly, the Steelers have not had much success when they faced rookie quarterbacks who were the first overall picks in the draft that year. But they have fared much better when facing rookie quarterbacks who were first-round draft choices.
They get another chance today when they face rookie Carson Wentz, the No. 2 overall pick in the April draft, who is drawing comparisons to Ben Roethlisberger already because he is the first quarterback since 1970 to win his first two starts without throwing an interception for the Philadelphia Eagles.
Read More
Steelers vs. first overall
Since 1983, 17 quarterbacks have been selected with the first overall pick in the draft, the most recent being Jared Goff by the Los Angeles Rams in April. However, many coaches, general managers and scouts thought Wentz, who played at North Dakota State, might have been the best quarterback in the draft.
The Eagles certainly thought enough to trade with the Cleveland Browns and move into the second spot to draft Wentz.
“I always thought he should have been No. 1,” Mike Mayock, a draft analyst for the NFL Network, said the other day.
Since Elway’s debut, the Steelers have faced only three rookie quarterbacks who were the first overall picks in the draft that year — Eli Manning of the New York Giants in 2004, Houston’s David Carr in 2002 and Cleveland’s Tim Couch in 1999.
Surprisingly, they lost two of those three matchups — to Carr and the expansion Texans, 24-6; and to Couch in the second meeting of the Browns’ return to the NFL, 16-15.
The loss to Carr, though, should carry an asterisk. The quarterback to beat the Steelers that day was their own— Tommy Maddox, who had two interceptions and a fumble returned for touchdowns. Carr completed just 3 of 10 passes for 33 yards and the Texans had only three first downs and 47 yards offense — the fewest yards by a winning team in NFL history.
The only time the Steelers beat a rookie quarterback who was the first overall selection was in 2004 when Manning lost a duel with another rookie first-round pick that year, Ben Roethlisberger, 33-30. Manning threw a pair of touchdowns and passed for 182 yards, but that happened to be the most productive day of Roethlisberger’s rookie season, passing for 318 yards and a touchdown.
That was the only 300-yard passing game and one of just four with more than 200 yards that season for Roethlisberger. He has added 48 more 300-yard games since that day.
Wentz, who is 6-foot-5, 240 pounds, is being compared to Roethlisberger for more than just his size.
“Just the physical aspect, the stature, size, arm strength and athletic ability,” said Eagles coach Doug Pederson, a former NFL quarterback. “[They are] smart individuals.
“Carson has the ability to extend plays with his legs. Ben is big, strong, physical in the pocket, hard to bring down and continues to have great vision down the field. I think that’s one thing with Carson’s strength is he continues to have that vision down the field when things begin to break down. There are a lot of similarities there. The fact that they’re both very good throwers outside the pocket is a tribute to both of them.”
Seven for seven
The matchup with Manning in 2004 was the last time the Steelers faced a No. 1 overall pick as a rookie. Since then, they have faced a rookie quarterback who was a first-round selection seven times, winning all seven.
Three of those were against Baltimore’s Joe Flacco in the 2008 season when the Steelers beat the Ravens twice during the regular season and again in the AFC Championship when they won their most recent Super Bowl.
The others were against Jacksonville’s Blaine Gabbert, the 10th overall pick in 2011, 17-13; Washington’s Robert Griffin III (No. 2 overall) in 2012, 27-13; Buffalo’s E.J. Manuel (16th overall) in 2013, 23-10; and Jacksonville’s Blake Bortles (No. 3 overall) in 2014, 17-9.
Wentz will be third rookie quarterback who was a No. 2 overall selection, joining RG3 and Seattle’s Rick Mirer, who beat them in 1993, 16-6. After evaluating him before the draft, Steelers offensive coordinator Todd Haley thought Wentz should have been the No. 1 overall selection.
“I had him clearly the best,” Haley said. “He was in a pro-style offense, [doing] a lot of under-center stuff, which you don’t get to see a whole bunch of these days. The thing that stood out was his understanding of the game. They put a lot on his shoulders in college and you saw him operate every play, whether signaling to receivers or making calls at the line to change the play, he did lot of that. When you see a young guy doing that, it’s an advantage.”
Today will mark the 15th time the Steelers will face a rookie quarterback who was a first-round pick. The Steelers are 10-4 in those games, going back to that day they lost to Elway and Broncos in 1983.
“It doesn’t matter what we’ve done before or what they’ve done before,” said defensive coordinator Keith Butler. “It only matters what we do on Sunday. What’s happened before here, what’s going to happen in the future, we’ll see. I’m not going to make any predictions that we’ll fool him or anything like that.”
It’s been a 33-year case study for the Steelers. And it began with John Elway.
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.