James Saglimbeni and his fiancee, Gabby Parks, sat on the sidewalk outside Heinz Field’s Gate A at 9:30 Sunday morning, their legs crossed and Ms. Parks’ Starbucks iced coffee almost gone. They were the only ones in line for the Steelers’ home opener, eagerly scouting the best spot to watch warm-ups and to get Ms. Parks’ selfie with Antonio Brown signed.

The couple arrived in Pittsburgh, one of maybe three trips they make here each year, anticipating a repeat of January’s American Football Conference wild card game, the slugfest that saw penalty markers flying everywhere, a total of 18 for 221 yards.

“I think that’s what we all want to see,” said Mr. Saglimbeni, 22, of Schenectady, N.Y. “The helmet-to-helmet hits are ugly, but you kind of want to see that style of football.”

No such luck Sunday, although it’s doubtful Mr. Saglimbeni will complain given the result. Nine months after that brutal display, one that might have made some cursory fans cringe, actual football returned to the North Shore on a soggy Sunday afternoon with a 24-16 Steelers win against the Cincinnati Bengals.

Advertise with us

This game was supposed to be a rematch from that 18-16 Steelers victory to open the postseason, the AFC North rivals’ first chance at some retribution. Only that storyline never came close to fruition.

Both teams behaved. Only 10 penalties were called for a total of 85 yards. Nobody fought during warm-ups or chucked beer bottles at the players as they retreated to their respective locker rooms. The only questionable hit that was flagged was Javon Hargrave’s horse-collar tackle, a non-issue. Bengals cornerback Adam Jones walloped Darrius Heyward-Bey with an unpenalized hit to the head early, but even after that, not a peep out of either side.

“Both teams were trying to win,” Steelers defensive end Cam Heyward said. “They didn’t want to cost themselves any penalty yards, and neither did we.”

Ben Roethlisberger threw three touchdown passes. DeAngelo Williams rushed 32 times for 94 yards and caught one of Mr. Roethlisberger’s scores. And Robert Golden recovered a Tyler Boyd fumble late to thwart a potential Bengals comeback.

Entertaining, sure. Although this one’s not likely to further the discussion that the Bengals have replaced the Baltimore Ravens as the Steelers’ primary rival.

Advertise with us

“It’s getting bigger,” Shane Cottrill, 21, of Cecil said. “But it’s not like the Ravens yet.”

Sunday’s game also was played without polarizing Bengals linebacker Vontaze Burfict, whose helmet-to-helmet shot on Mr. Brown ended the wide receiver’s season with a concussion. Mr. Brown later accused Mr. Burfict, who’s serving a three-game suspension for a history of illegal hits, of “trying to kill” him.

Steelers linebacker Ryan Shazier did play. He flung himself at Bengals running back Giovani Bernard in January and later saw the National Football League make a change to its rules regarding players leading with the crown of their helmet, as Mr. Shazier did.

Nothing even close materialized Sunday.

“We understand what to do and what not to do,” Mr. Shazier added. “We’re not going to put our team in a bad position.”

Advertise with us

The temperature at kickoff was 72 degrees, a perfect fall teaser for the 65,072 in attendance. A morning mist turned into heavier showers by afternoon, and the change made for some slick playing conditions.

Outside Heinz Field, Steelers fans had no problem knocking off the rust. Kim Shanahan, 49 of Whitehall was as prepared as anyone.

Six years ago, Ms. Shanahan and her family purchased an ambulance to use for their ice cream business. Various mixers, cups and supplies occupy the glass cases where medical supplies were once stored. A drink gun spewing four different kinds of liquor hung out the back.

“We got tired of trashing our own vehicles,” said Ms. Shanahan, who arrived early enough to grab a premium spot outside Gate B. “The lights work, too, although we had to switch them to yellow because you’re not allowed to ride around with red lights.”

Expectations of a Bengals-Steelers blood fest grew at the intersection of Reedsdale Street and Sproat Way. That’s where a stuffed “dummy” of Mr. Burfict was hanging from a utility line in the lot outside Rivers Casino.

Advertise with us

John Nigro and Jim Botti have been doing that every home game since 1980, and picking Mr. Burfict for this particular honor didn’t require much deliberation, Mr. Nigro said.

“He’s the most hated, so that’s what we try to do,” Mr. Nigro said. “Either the most hated or the quarterback.”

Mr. Burfict might have been hated nine months ago at Paul Brown Stadium, but what boiled over there barely bubbled Sunday.

As fans bottlenecked outside Gate C, Bengals fans Colt Kinnatt, 30 of Indianapolis and Rob Welke, 27 of Cincinnati walked down North Shore Drive in fluorescent orange Bengals jerseys.

Crickets. Not a word directed at Mr. Kinnatt, proudly wearing Mr. Burfict’s No. 55.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kinnatt lauded the communal atmosphere among tailgaters.

“Our first two times here haven’t been too bad,” Mr. Kinnatt said. “It’s a lot worse in Cleveland. We got treated pretty bad in Cleveland.”

Cliff Riley, 32, of Florence, Ky., can relate. Mr. Riley and his Bengals fan buddies bought a yellow school bus for $2,200 and fixed it up. They’ve driven to Pittsburgh numerous times with no issues, but lost the facemask to their giant, inflatable Bengals player in Cleveland.

“Brutal fans in Cleveland,” Mr. Riley said.

“The fans are fantastic in Pittsburgh. They’ve been nothing but class acts. I’ve had nothing but good experiences.”

Advertise with us

The same can be said for what transpired on the field between the Bengals and Steelers on this particular Sunday.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.