The night before his pro day at Michigan State, Kirk Cousins went to dinner at a seafood restaurant in East Lansing, Mich., with Steelers coach Mike Tomlin and quarterbacks coach Randy Fichtner. The Steelers were in the market for a backup quarterback for Ben Roethlisberger and they really liked what they saw of Cousins.

The feeling turned out to be mutual.

“They were the only coaching staff to do that,” Cousins said. “[Tomlin] was the only coach who really related to you to that degree during the predraft process. I have great respect for him and coach Fichtner. I really like them as a coaching staff and I can see why they’ve had tremendous success consistently for many, many years.”

The dinner lasted for two hours. Both sides lost track of time. Eventually, the Steelers coaches had to let Cousins go and get some rest for his pro day.

Advertise with us

“You know how you’re with someone and, next thing you know, two hours have gone by?” Fichtner said. “That’s how it was with him. He was really an engaging kid. We enjoyed talking with him.”

Feeling out Cousins

The Steelers, of course, never got Cousins. The Washington Redskins surprised a lot of teams when they drafted him in the fourth round in 2012, just three rounds after they selected quarterback Robert Griffin III with the No. 2 overall selection in the draft.

At the time, it seemed like such a curious pick. But, as it turns out, it became a fortuitous one. Griffin burst into the league as one of the most dynamic players in the past four decades, amid hosannas his style of play will change the landscape of the game and the way quarterbacks are typecast for the NFL. One year later, beset by injuries and an attitude that clashed with his coaches and management, Griffin’s star tumbled just as fast as it rose.

Enter Cousins. He threw for 4,166 yards and 29 touchdowns and completed an NFL-best 69.8 percent of his passes in 2015, leading the Redskins to the NFC East Division title.

Advertise with us

“We were fighting through a lot of quarterback issues and some off the field, and I don’t think there was ever any controversy within the organization, but outside of it, with the news and all of that stuff instilling a little bit of doubt, it’s hard to play quarterback when the people watching your games aren’t even sure you should be the guy,” Redskins coach Jay Gruden said.

Tonight, Cousins will start just his 27th game in the NFL against the only team that wined and dined him 4½ years ago, beginning the season still wanting and needing to prove himself to the Redskins — and maybe some other team in the NFL.

Cousins turned down a multiyear contract from the Redskins that, according to reports, was worth $16 million per year with $24 million in guarantees. By comparison, the Philadelphia Eagles, who finished second to the Redskins in the division, gave quarterback Sam Bradford a two-year, $36 million deal in the offseason (then traded him to the Minnesota Vikings). If Cousins accepted the offer, he would have ranked 21st in average annual salary among quarterbacks in the league, tied with Cincinnati’s Andy Dalton.

Instead, he is playing this season under the franchise tag, meaning he will earn $19.9 million — the average of the top five paid quarterbacks in the league — $4 million more than the Redskins’ multiyear offer. Now he has an opportunity to match or exceed what he did last season and earn an even greater yearly average in 2017 as an unrestricted free agent, whether from the Redskins or another NFL team.

Conversely, the Redskins have another year to see if Cousins is really their quarterback of the future or a one-hit wonder who flourished merely because he had the best set of receivers in the NFC East?

Advertise with us

That is not always the norm in the NFL.

Money always doesn’t add up

Usually teams aren’t so judicious when it comes to finding and paying a quarterback to play the most valued position in the NFL, especially when one has success. But paying those ridiculous sums not only fails to guarantee future success, it often cripples the team’s salary-cap structure and puts them in an untenable financial position that makes it difficult for them to sign some of their other core players.

The Steelers, of course, are fortunate with Roethlisberger, whom they signed before the 2015 season to a five-year, $99 million contract extension that guaranteed him $35 million in salary and bonuses last season and another $18 million this season. He has won two Super Bowl titles for them, has a career record of 113-56 as a starter in the regular season (18-9 since 2014) and appears to keep getting better with age.

But other teams have not seen success match the dollar amount handed to their quarterbacks.

Advertise with us

For example, when the New Orleans Saints signed Drew Brees to a six-year, $60 million contract from the San Diego Chargers in 2006, the decision proved to be a wise one. Brees led the Saints to four winning seasons, posting a 62-34 record with four playoff appearances and a Super Bowl. Conversely, since signing his whopping $100 million contract in 2012, the Saints are 32-32, have had three losing seasons and won just one playoff game.

Brees was scheduled to count $30 million against the cap this season until the Saints restructured his contract last week, giving him a one-year contract extension worth $24.25 million, all of which is guaranteed.

But there are worse cases.

The Chicago Bears are 11-21 since they signed Jay Cutler to a seven-year, $126.7 million deal. The Atlanta Falcons signed Matt Ryan to a five-year, $103.75 million deal in 2013 and have gone 18-30 since without a playoff appearance. After Roethlisberger, Ryan will count more against the salary cap in 2016 ($23.7 million) than any other quarterback. Even the Ravens, who gave Joe Flacco a six-year, $120.6 million contract after he helped them win the Super Bowl, are just 23-25 since then.

That’s probably another reason the Eagles traded Bradford to the Vikings. Even though they drafted quarterback Carson Wentz with the No. 2 overall pick in the draft, Bradford was going to count $23.5 million against their cap in 2017, making up more than 14 percent of the projected $165.5 million cap, according to Overthecap.com.

Advertise with us

Then there is Tom Brady, who has won four Super Bowls for the New England Patriots. Despite his success as the best quarterback of his generation, he has never counted more than $15 million against the salary cap because the Patriots keep re-signing him to new deals, according to the website. It is a tricky game NFL teams have to play because they all feel they need a quarterback to win games.

Which brings us back to Cousins and the Redskins.

Accuracy counts

Accuracy in quarterbacks is something that is always desired, especially with the advent of the quick passing game the Redskins like to employ with receivers Pierre Garcon, DeSean Jackson and Jamison Crowder and tight end Jordan Reed. And you don’t have to be a No. 1 pick to do so. Two of the most accurate passers in recent history — Ken Anderson and Joe Montana — were third-round choices.

Cousins led the NFL in 2015 by completing nearly 70 percent of his passes and he was a fourth-round pick. The team that took him to dinner drafted nose tackle Alameda Ta’amu seven spots after the Redskins beat them to Cousins.

Advertise with us

Despite leading the Redskins to a division title for only the second time in 16 years, Cousins has to prove himself in 2016 to see if he is worth some of the monstrous money that is tossed around to other quarterbacks. Never mind he helped the Redskins win six of their final eight games by throwing 19 touchdowns and only two interceptions in that stretch.

“We just kind of got an identity as an offense as to what we were going to do well and hang our hat on,” Cousins said. “That helped. Just continuing to stack up that experience made a big difference.”

Now he has to do it again.

Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac.