In 2009, the Steelers drafted a defensive end in the first round of the draft for the first time since taking Huey Richardson with the No. 15 overall pick in 1991. Ziggy Hood wasn’t the colossal bust that Richardson was, but he never earned a second contract with the Steelers. Two years after selecting Hood, the Steelers doubled down and selected another defensive end in the first round.

That time, they got it right. Cam Heyward was taken with the No. 31 overall choice and has developed into one of the top defenders in the NFL. The Steelers have made their defensive line a priority in recent years and found Heyward’s bookend in 2014 when they invested their second-round pick in Stephon Tuitt, who started 14 games last season in his first as a full-time starter.

When the Steelers broke from tradition to use high draft choices on the defensive line, they also knew they had to break from tradition and employ them in a different way. For years, defensive ends in the Steelers defense took on double teams and allowed the linebackers to flow from sideline to sideline to make plays. But it didn’t make much sense to let players with the talent that Heyward and Tuitt possess get lost in the trenches.

First-year defensive coordinator Keith Butler kept the 3-4 defensive scheme former coordinator Dick LeBeau had used for years but tweaked it, giving more freedom to two players who could wreak havoc on the interior of the line when for years the Steelers had lived and died with their outside pass rush.

Advertise with us

If 2015 was a one-year experiment to see how the defense would play with the changes, coach Mike Tomlin should emphatically endorse a second season of the same from Butler and his thoroughbreds up front.

Heyward recorded seven sacks and became the first Steelers defensive end to lead the team in that category since Aaron Smith in 2004. Right behind him, despite missing two games with a knee injury, was Tuitt, who finished with 6.5. Heyward added 21 quarterback hurries and Tuitt had 16.

But the Heyward-Tuitt duo did much more than pressure quarterbacks. They also helped the defense return to form when it came to stopping the run.

The Steelers returned to a top-five rush defense for the first time since the 2012 season. They allowed 3.4 yards per carry, a full yard fewer than 2014, and held opponents to just six rushing touchdowns. Only the New York Jets gave up fewer (four).

Heyward and Tuitt did their part to improve the run defense, but a healthy Steve McLendon in the middle helped as well. McLendon, the starting nose tackle for the past three seasons, signed with the New York Jets in free agency last month.

Advertise with us

The Steelers did not match the $12 million contract the Jets offered because he only played 34 percent of the snaps last season as they continued a trend of playing more subpackage defense than base defense.

The goal for the Steelers is to find a defensive lineman in the draft who can play nose tackle and then bump out to play in a rotation with Heyward and Tuitt at end in the nickel and dime defenses. Baylor defensive tackle Andrew Billings, who is projected as a first-round pick, fits the bill and could follow in the footsteps of players such as former New England defensive tackle Vince Wilfork, who in his prime dominated the middle for the Patriots but was versatile enough to play in obvious passing situations, too.

If the Steelers don’t take Billings, this is a deep draft for defensive tackles, and they could get a quality interior player in the second or third round. And if that does not happen, the Steelers could always turn to 2014 sixth-round pick Daniel McCullers, who played sparingly in his first two seasons.

McCullers has flashed potential in his limited playing time, but hasn’t been consistent enough to play a large role in the defense. That was also true for reserve defensive ends Cam Thomas and rookie L.T. Walton. All three reserves played fewer than 200 snaps last season.

When Tomlin was asked after the season about employing a rotation next season to give Heyward and Tuitt a break, his answer didn’t shine a positive light on the reserves.

Advertise with us

“If guys prove that they are capable, I have no problem playing a lot of people,” Tomlin said. “But I’m not going to play people that aren’t.”

Thomas’ contract expired and he’s unlikely to return. The Steelers signed free agent Ricardo Mathews this past week to add depth behind Heyward and Tuitt. He’ll compete with Walton and Cashaud Lyons, who spent most of last season on the practice squad, for playing time among the reserves.

Because quality depth is an issue, the Steelers are likely to draft another end next month to bolster the position.

How they were built: Defensive line

Cam Heyward

Advertise with us

Position: defensive end

Year acquired: 2011 draft, first round

School: Ohio State

Signed through: 2020

Stephon Tuitt

Advertise with us

Position: defensive end

Year acquired: 2014 draft, second round

School: Notre Dame

Signed through: 2017

L.T. Walton

Advertise with us

Position: defensive end

Year acquired: 2015 draft, sixth round

School: Central Michigan

Signed through: 2018

Daniel McCullers

Advertise with us

Position: nose tackle

Year acquired: 2014 draft, sixth round

School: Tennessee

Signed through: 2017

Ricardo Mathews

Advertise with us

Year acquired: 2016, free agent

School: Cincinnati

Signed through: 2016

Cam Thomas

Position: defensive end/nose tackle

Advertise with us

Year acquired: 2014, free agent

School: North Carolina

Signed through: UFA

Top five defensive line prospects as rated by nfldraftscout.com

1. Sheldon Rankins, Louisville Sr.

Advertise with us

2. A’Shawn Robinson, Alabama Jr.

3. Jarran Reed, Alabama Sr.

4. Andrew Billings, Baylor Jr.

5. Robert Nkemdiche, Mississippi Jr.

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.