(First in a series of stories this winter and spring that will examine the Steelers position by position heading into the 2016 season)
Mike Munchak said he had never been associated with a team that lost its center and left tackle in the same season. Not in his 12 seasons as a player or 21 seasons as a coach in the NFL.
“Those are usually your two best guys,” Munchak said. “It’s hard.”
Playing without two-time All-Pro center Maurkice Pouncey all season and left tackle Kelvin Beachum for the final 12 weeks was a difficult dilemma for the Steelers, but their three remaining starters and two unsung reserves made it look easier than it was.
Other teams would fall apart without their starting center and left tackle, but the Steelers won 11 games and came oh-so-close to playing in the AFC championship with a career backup starting 16 games and a first-year player protecting Ben Roethlisberger’s blind side.
And the line didn’t just survive, it thrived. Even with Cody Wallace at center and Alejandro Villanueva at left tackle, the offensive line was ranked among the top 10 in the league by analysts who grade line play.
Read More
The Steelers were ranked as the eighth-best offensive line by Football Outsiders and Pro Football Focus. If you don’t buy what their analysts are selling, consider the Steelers did very well in the traditional statistics used to judge offensive line play, as well.
The Steelers averaged 4.4 yards per carry, tied for eighth best in the league. They allowed 33 sacks (tied for 11th fewest in the league), and they only allowed their quarterback to be hit 60 times (second fewest in the league).
There was a narrative going around after the season ended. Boiled down, it went something like this: Franchise quarterback Ben Roethlisberger sustained knee, foot, head and shoulder injuries, which forced him to miss four games and parts of five others. Therefore, the offensive line didn’t protect him well enough.
The Steelers were far from perfect in their protection, but that narrative is false based on how other teams, most with healthier lines, protected their quarterbacks.
By contrast, the Cleveland Browns allowed 53 sacks and a league-high 123 quarterback hits. The Colts, who almost ran out of quarterbacks by the end of the season, allowed 118 hits on their quarterbacks, twice as many as Roethlisberger, Landry Jones and Mike Vick endured.
Or how about the job the Steelers did against the Broncos in two games against the Super Bowl champions: While the Patriots and Panthers allowed four and seven sacks in the AFC championship and Super Bowl, the Steelers allowed only three in each of their two games. Super Bowl MVP Von Miller, who terrorized the Patriots and Panthers, did not record a sack against the Steelers. Demarcus Ware only had one in two games.
It makes one wonder where the offensive line would have been ranked had their best players stayed healthy.
We might never know because Beachum and left guard Ramon Foster are unrestricted free agents and left side of the offensive line could have a whole new look in 2016.
The Steelers have large sums of money tied up in Pouncey ($44 million through 2019) and right tackle Marcus Gilbert ($30 million through 2019). And they are expected to devote more of their resources to sign right guard David DeCastro, who earned All-Pro honors for the first time last season, as he enters the final season of his rookie contract.
The Steelers could try to re-sign Foster, but he is 30 and could get more money than the Steelers are willing to pay on the open market.
Beachum’s free agency is a bit more complicated. He is coming off a major knee injury sustained in the middle of October. Beachum should recover in time to be ready for the season opener, but it’s unknown if another team would be willing to give a big free-agent contract to a player coming off a major injury.
If a team does make a big offer, it’s unlikely the Steelers would try to match it. The Steelers and Beachum could not come to terms on a long-term contract last summer.
If Beachum does not return, the Steelers would likely go into training camp with Villanueva as the starting left tackle. He started the final 12 games of the season, including two in the playoffs. The Steelers were 7-5 in those games.
Villanueva had no NFL experience entering the season. He was on the Steelers practice squad in 2014 and might not have made the 53-man roster if Mike Adams had not injured his back last summer.
Villanueva is far from a finished product. He had issues in pass protection, allowing seven sacks and his share of hurries, but there might be enough potential for the Steelers to believe he could line up as a starter over the course of a 16-game season.
If the Steelers had to replace Foster with a player on the roster, they would have to go with someone with much less experience. Chris Hubbard was the top reserve at guard and tackle last season, but he has never started an NFL game in his two seasons on the team. Rookie B.J. Finney is another candidate, but he has never dressed for an NFL game, having spent his first season on the practice squad.
Drafting a guard or signing one in free agency is a possibility, though not a high priority with the Steelers having bigger needs at cornerback, safety, defensive line and tight end.
That might mean more shuffling of the deck for Munchak, but after what he experienced in 2015, the potential changes in 2016 don’t seem as daunting.
How they were built: Starting offensive line
Marcus Gilbert
Position: Right tackle
Year acquired: 2011 draft, second round
School: Florida
Signed through: 2019
David DeCastro
Position: Right guard
Year acquired: 2012 draft, first round
School: Stanford
Signed through: 2016
Maurkice Pouncey
Position: Center
Year acquired: 2010 draft, first round
School: Florida
Signed through: 2019
Ramon Foster
Position: Left guard
Year acquired: 2009, undrafted free agent
School: Tennessee
Signed through: UFA
Kelvin Beachum
Position: Left tackle
Year acquired: 2012 draft, seventh round
School: SMU
Signed through: UFA
Reserves
Cody Wallace
Position: Center/guard
Year acquired: 2013 free agent
School: Texas A&M
Signed through: 2016
Chris Hubbard
Position: Guard/tackle
Year acquired: 2014, undrafted free agent
School: UAB
Signed through: 2016
Alejandro Villanueva
Position: Tackle
Year acquired: 2014, free agent
School: Army
Signed through: 2016
Byron Stingily
Position: Tackle
Year acquired: 2015, free agent
School: Louisville
Signed through: UFA
Doug Legursky
Position: Center/guard
Year acquired: 2008, undrafted free agent*
School: Marshall
Signed through: UFA
*reacquired in 2015 as a free agent
Draft prospects (as rated by nfldraftscout.com)
Top five centers
1. Ryan Kelly, Alabama Sr.
2. Nick Martin, Notre Dame Sr.
3. Jack Allen, Michigan State Sr.
4. Max Tuerk, Southern California Sr.
5. Evan Boehm, Missouri Sr.
Top five guards
1. Cody Whitehair, Kansas State Sr.
2. Vadal Alexander, LSU Sr.
3. Landon Turner, North Carolina Sr.
4. Josh Garnett, Stanford Sr.
5. Christian Westerman, Arizona State Sr.
Top five tackles
1. Laremy Tunsil, Mississippi Jr.
2. Ronnie Stanley, Notre Dame Jr.
3. Taylor Decker, Ohio State Sr.
4. Jack Conklin, Michigan State Jr.
5. Shon Coleman, Auburn Jr.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.