Kimo von Oelhoffen heard the noise, heard the awful sound professional athletes dread to hear even in an opponent. And it made him sick, almost despondent.
In the seconds after he got tangled with guard Eric Steinbach and accidentally crashed low into the left knee of Bengals quarterback Carson Palmer, tearing his anterior cruciate and medial collateral ligaments and patellar tendon, von Oelhoffen reached out his right hand to Palmer, as if to comfort the fallen enemy.
Behind him, Bengals wide receiver Chris Henry was running behind cornerback Deshea Townsend, catching the pass Palmer heaved down the right sideline, on just the second play of the 2005 AFC wild-card playoff game, for a 66-yard gain. But von Oelhoffen could only turn his attention to Palmer, who was writhing on the ground in pain, and became visibly distraught.
“It affected me big time,” von Oelhoffen said. “The kid was good, the kid earned the spot. He should’ve been able to play.”
Palmer led the NFL in touchdowns (32) and completion percentage (67.8) and was second in passer rating (101.1) in 2005, leading the Bengals to their first division title in 15 years, thanks in large part to a 38-31 victory over the Steelers five weeks earlier in Heinz Field. And, just like that, he was done.
Several of the Cincinnati players accosted von Oelhoffen and angrily encircled him, even though he had spent six years as a member of the Bengals and was friends with many of them.
Read More
“Guys were infuriated,” Bengals right tackle Willie Anderson said at the time. “But I know him. He’s not a dirty player. His momentum just kept him going into Carson. It wasn’t a dirty play.”
Nonetheless, von Oelhoffen, then 34 and the starter at right defensive end, was bothered by what happened. And his teammates saw what it did to him on the sidelines.
“I remember talking to Kimo like, man, you don’t have to apologize any more. You shouldn’t be upset at something you didn’t do on purpose,” said linebacker Joey Porter, now an assistant coach with the Steelers. “He was making me mad because he was taking it too far. I was like, hey man, we’re trying to win the damn game. That was not on purpose. You know you didn’t do it on purpose. Snap out of it and let’s go.
“And he did.”
Like von Oelhoffen, the Steelers snapped out of their doldrums, too. After veteran Jon Kitna replaced Palmer and helped the Bengals to leads of 10-0 and 17-7, the Steelers stormed back in the second half to win the AFC wild-card playoff game, 31-17, at Paul Brown Stadium. Not only was it the first road playoff victory under Bill Cowher, who had been 0-3, it began the team’s historic run as the first No. 6 seed to go on the road and win the Super Bowl.
A decade later, the injury to Palmer still haunts von Oelhoffen, who is now a defensive line coach at Western Oregon University.
“That always bothered me,” von Oelhoffen was saying the other day over the phone. “I would say it was one of the most emotional times in my career. I was in my 14th year and when you play that long, you develop respect for everybody. We’re a fraternity, we’re all working, we’re all trying to get ahead, we’re all trying to help people. You don’t realize that when you’re young. After years of being in the league, you understand we’re all in this together.”
Feels like the first time
Ten years later, the symmetry is eerily familiar.
The Bengals are champions of the AFC North, the Steelers are the No. 6 seed as a wild-card team, and they’re meeting again tonight at Paul Brown Stadium, just one day removed from the 10-year anniversary of that game — their only other postseason encounter. And, in case you missed it, the Bengals will again be without their star quarterback, who just happened to get injured — irony of ironies — against the Steelers.
This time, though, the injury was self-inflicted.
Andy Dalton, who leads the NFL in passer rating (106.3) and yards per attempt (8.42), still hasn’t returned from the broken thumb he sustained when he tried to tackle defensive end Stephon Tuitt after an interception on the Bengals’ first possession of their Dec. 12 game at Paul Brown Stadium. His replacement, AJ McCarron, will be making just his fourth start, trying to become the first quarterback since Gifford Nielsen of the Houston Oilers in 1979 to win a playoff game with just three or fewer starts under his belt.
Unlike 2005, it is the Bengals who could be seeking payback for what happened in the final regular-season meeting between the teams — a convincing 33-20 victory by the Steelers that ran their record in Paul Brown Stadium to 14-3.
That was the Bengals’ opportunity to finish off the Steelers, in effect, put an end to their playoff possibilities. And, in retrospect, they would have done just that had they beaten their division rival.
Of course, they thought the same thing 10 years ago when they beat the Steelers, 38-31, at Heinz Field on Dec. 4, dropping the Steelers to 7-5.
“We thought we finished them off,” former Bengals defensive tackle John Thornton was recalling the other day. “It was a big moment for us. We were ready for the game. I know, from a defensive standpoint, they weren’t that diverse on offense. We knew their formations. They just had big, physical people and, if you knew what was coming, you could stop them. We knew we could cover their receivers over the top and we felt we had receivers they couldn’t cover.”
That game at Heinz Field not only was the last time the Steelers would lose — they won eight consecutive games en route to their fifth Super Bowl title and first under Cowher — it served to incite and motivate the Steelers because of the post-game antics of Bengals receivers T.J. Houshmandzadeh and Chad Johnson.
As he ran off the field and headed to the locker room, Houshmandzadeh grabbed a Terrible Towel and began shining his shoes with it. In the locker room, Johnson crowed that it was time for a change in the division, like going “from black and white TV to color TV.” That angered several of the Steelers, and they didn’t forget.
“I know T.J. personally and he caught me off guard that he was feeling that good to do that and think they weren’t going to see us again,” Porter said. “They were going pretty good. All that was fine, but using the Terrible Towel to clean your shoes? They don’t understand how sacred that Terrible Towel is to us. So they struck a nerve, and we knew the only way we could play them again is we have to win out.”
And the Steelers did, sending them to the rematch with the Bengals.
Gadget alert fails
The first thing anyone remembers about what happened Jan. 8, 2006 is the injury to Palmer, which occurred on the first postseason pass play for the Bengals in 15 years, second-and-nine from their own 12.
But, there were several other moments in the second half that were just as significant.
First, the Bengals botched a field goal attempt because of a high snap. Then, Kitna knocked the ball out of his own hand while scrambling, scuttling a drive. Finally, a shanked 30-yard punt by Kyle Larson put the Steelers in position to take control.
Three plays later, they did, fooling the Bengals with a gadget play they knew might be coming.
Offensive coordinator Ken Whisenhunt called “Direct 38 Truck Throwback” on third-and-3 from the Bengals 43, a play in which wide receiver Antwaan Randle El lined in the Wildcat formation in the backfield, with Ben Roethlisberger just slightly to his left. Randle El took a direct snap from center, ran to the right, stopped and threw back left to Roethlisberger.
Wide receiver Cedric Wilson, who had a 54-yard catch to set up a late first-half touchdown pass to Hines Ward, was running wide open behind cornerback Ifeanyi Ohalete and easily caught a 43-yard touchdown that gave the Steelers a 28-17 lead and effectively ended the Bengals season.
The play was particularly deflating for the Bengals because their defenders said they had been on alert for a trick play. And it still happened.
“Every time they crossed the 50, that’s all we would say — trick-play alert,” said Thornton, who played at West Virginia and is now director of Octagon Football, a sports representation firm. “They would always do something when they would cross the 50. Marvin had alerted us to that and, when it happened, you almost got upset. That’s the sad part — you know what’s coming and they get it.”
“For us to know their tendencies and allow that play to happen, that, to me, is the only play I honestly remember,” said former Bengals linebacker Brian Simmons, now a scout for the Jacksonville Jaguars.
It was the third touchdown pass for Roethlisberger, who did not throw an interception. That performance set the stage for what he would do in a divisional playoff victory in Indianapolis and the AFC Championship game in Denver when he completed 66 percent of his passes (35 of 53) and combined to throw four touchdowns with one interception.
Ten years later, the Steelers are hoping for a repeat.
“We like the situation we’re in,” Porter said. “They’re the [AFC] North champs, we’re the sixth seed. We’re in the same situation. It’s similar to ’05. Just different years, different players.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.