Entering today’s games, the Steelers are one of five teams in the AFC with a 6-5 record jostling for playoff position. Two others are one game behind and in contention for wild-card berths with five weeks remaining in the regular season.

The competitive balance former NFL commissioner Pete Rozelle sought so many years ago is alive and well, and it can create some head-spinning scenarios for fans when it comes to figuring out which teams will compete for the Super Bowl.

’Tis the season for NFL tiebreakers when fans’ hangovers come not from too much eggnog, but when they try to figure out what their favorite team must do to qualify for the playoffs. It’s the only time of the year they scurry to computers to find out what strength of victory means. Or better yet, contemplate the scenario in which their favorite team can make the playoffs based on a coin toss.

Yes, a flip of a coin can still send a team to the playoffs, and one of the men responsible for coming up with the original tiebreaker steps still keeps an office at the UPMC Rooney Sports Complex. In fact, the building is named after him.

Advertise with us

Steelers chairman Dan Rooney and former Dallas Cowboys president and general manager Tex Schramm were asked by Rozelle to come up with a tiebreaking process in 1967, the first season the NFL went from two divisions to four with the addition of the expansion New Orleans Saints.

“We had a lot of ideas,” Rooney, 83, was saying after a Steelers practice last month. “What we never wanted was for it to come down to a coin flip. That was always going to be the last resort, but it has to be in there.”

The coin flip remains part of the NFL’s tiebreaking procedures 48 years after they were first devised, but it has never decided anything. Plenty of other obscure tiebreakers have, from which teams get into the playoffs, how the teams are seeded in the playoffs and how the draft order is finalized.

Tough-luck tiebreakers

It didn’t take long for a franchise to feel slighted by the new rules determining the playoffs. The 1967 season provided one of the most hard-luck playoff misses in NFL history.

Advertise with us

Today, head-to-head competition is the first tiebreaker in any scenario. When Rooney and Schramm devised the original tiebreakers, the first way to break a tie was point differential in head-to-head games.

This set the stage for an odd NFL playoff footnote. It’s the story of how the Baltimore Colts entered the final week of the season without a loss and missed the playoffs.

After Los Angeles beat Baltimore in the regular-season finale, both teams finished with 11-1-2 records in the Western Conference’s Coastal Division. Los Angeles won the division title and Baltimore was left out based on better point differential in head to head games.

For all intents and purposes, the Rams and Colts staged a play-in game, because they had tied in their previous meeting earlier in the year. Roman Gabriel outdueled Johnny Unitas in a 34-10 Rams win in Los Angeles.

So the Colts watched the playoffs from home as the Green Bay Packers, whom they beat, 13-10, in November that season, won their second consecutive Super Bowl.

Advertise with us

Before 1967, if teams were tied at the end of a season, the NFL staged a “playoff game” to decide which team advanced to the NFL championship. This happened eight times from 1933-66, including in 1947 when the Steelers and Eagles were tied with 8-4 records atop the NFL’s Eastern Division. The Eagles won the playoff game, 21-0, at Forbes Field.

In 1975, tiebreakers helped shape NFL history in a different way. Modern-day NFL fans have tiebreakers such as strength of victory and strength of schedule to decipher. Forty years ago, something called the point rating system was used to determine playoff seeding.

Minnesota earned the top NFC playoff seed based on the point rating system, a formula that took into account points scored and points allowed. The Vikings got the top seed because they were first in the NFC in points scored and second in points allowed for a combined rating of 3, while Rams were fifth in the NFC in points scored and first in points allowed for a rating of 6.

As a result, Dallas, the NFC’s wild-card entrant, had to travel to Minnesota for a divisional-round playoff game. The game’s winning touchdown is one of the most famous plays in NFL playoff history and it produced a description that has become a part of football’s vernacular.

On second-and-10 from the 50-yard line with 32 seconds left, Cowboys quarterback Roger Staubach heaved a desperation pass to Drew Pearson, who reeled in the touchdown for a 17-14 victory. When asked after the game about the play, Staubach said: “I closed my eyes and said a.‘Hail Mary.’ ”

Advertise with us

Staubach’s luck ran out three weeks later in Miami when the Steelers beat the Cowboys, 21-17, in Super Bowl X.

Tiebreakers have been tweaked only a few times over the years, usually when the league has realigned its divisions and conferences. Over time, point differential and points scored have been de-emphasized by the NFL competition committee because coaches find it distasteful to run up the score.

The previous time the league tweaked tiebreakers was 2002, which led to one of the most interesting factoids involving tough-luck tiebreakers.

Did you know the only reason the New England Patriots are not going for their 15th consecutive AFC East championship this year are NFL tiebreakers?

In 2002, the Patriots, Jets and Dolphins tied for first place in the AFC East. The Jets won the division based on the fourth tiebreaker (best record in common games), and the Patriots lost out on the wild card to Cleveland based on conference record. In 2008, the Patriots and Dolphins were tied atop the AFC East. The Dolphins won the division title based on better conference record, and Baltimore beat out the Patriots for the wild card based on better conference record.

Advertise with us

Steelers ties

The Steelers have missed the playoffs twice because of tiebreakers, most recently in 2009. The Steelers, Ravens, Jets and Texans all finished with 9-7 records that season. The Jets and Ravens made the playoffs. The Ravens finished ahead of the Steelers and knocked them out based on the better division record (3-3 over 2-4).

Twenty-five years ago, the Steelers also missed the playoffs on a tiebreaker. In 1990, they had a chance to win the division outright on the final weekend of the regular season, but lost at Houston, 34-14. That created a three-way tie atop the AFC Central. The Steelers, Oilers and Bengals all owned 9-7 records.

The Bengals won the division based on best head-to-head record (3-1 to the Oliers’ 2-2 and Steelers’ 1-3). The Oilers earned the wild card over the Steelers and Seahawks based on better conference record.

The Steelers have benefited from tiebreakers, too, most notably in 1997, when they won the AFC Central over Jacksonville based on the fifth tiebreaker. Tied in head-to-head competition, division record, conference record and record in common games, the Steelers finally won out based on better net-division points (78 to Jaguars’ 23).

Advertise with us

The Jaguars had to go on the road to play in the wild-card round at Denver and lost, 42-17. The Steelers got the No. 2 seed, a bye to the divisional round of the playoffs and beat New England at home to advance to the AFC championship for the third time in four years.

“I don’t remember losing the tiebreaker that way, but it is interesting looking back on it,” said Mark Brunell, the quarterback for Jacksonville in 1997 and now an analyst for ESPN. “The difference between going on the road and being at home for a playoff game is huge. It’s a game-changer.”

Denver then had to come to Pittsburgh and beat the Steelers, 24-21, to advance to Super Bowl XXXII. They defeated the Green Bay Packers for their first Super Bowl victory two weeks later.

Two years ago, the Steelers needed an eight-game parlay over the final two weeks of the regular season to get into the playoffs.

The stars aligned for the first seven, including a Steelers victory against Cleveland in the regular-season finale at Heinz Field. The Steelers were set to get into the playoffs with an 8-8 record because they won all tiebreakers against other 8-8 teams. The final domino that had to fall was Kansas City winning in San Diego.

Advertise with us

The odds were stacked against the Steelers. The Chiefs had clinched a playoff berth a week earlier and rested their starters. But Steelers players still rushed out of the locker room to their televisions at home “hoping for a miracle” as guard Ramon Foster recalled last week.

Chiefs kicker Ryan Succop was set to deliver that miracle when he lined up for a 41-yard field goal with seconds remaining in regulation.

Succop missed. The Chargers won in overtime. The Steelers were out.

“Heartbreak,” Foster said.

“Letting your season go through your hands because of the stuff you did, that’s what I was thinking. That’s what we did then, and we cannot drop the ball this time. We can’t depend on other teams to get us in. A lot of teams don’t like us. To this day, I think the guy from Kansas City did that on purpose.”

Advertise with us

The Steelers could be in for another nail-biting scenario this season. The tiebreakers for the wild cards don’t favor them. They are currently eighth in the conference, and only the top six teams qualify for the postseason.

The Steelers currently lose tiebreakers to the Chiefs, Texans and Jets because of their 3-4 conference record. Winning the five remaining games would almost certainly get the Steelers in the playoffs. Winning four of five might do the trick, but it’s not guaranteed. Teams with 10-6 records have missed the playoffs the past three years.

That’s why the game against the Colts tonight is being viewed as a must-win by Steelers players.

“You don’t want someone else holding your destiny in your hands,” right tackle Marcus Gilbert said.

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.