Generally when you are fretting the outcome of a December football game between two 6-5 teams, it’s because you harbor some minor pathology, such as an interest in the Famous Idaho Potato Bowl.

Yeah, that’s a real thing.

So thank God for the NFL, where 6-5 not only gets you enduring relevance, but just about guarantees a full month of desperation football, commencing as it does this very night around 8:30 p.m. at Heinz Field.

The Steelers and Colts, both 6-5, both laboring through seasons in which their franchise quarterbacks have started barely half the games, are both acutely aware that the home team has allowed a near-comic 10 touchdown passes in the past three games.

Advertise with us

“It’s just a lack of detail, certain plays we’re not detailed enough — not cognizant and aware of the situation,” said Steelers safety Will Allen, who may or may not start again in Keith Butler’s secondary, along with one of two other secondary suspects who might find themselves spectating when Indianapolis’ offense first appears. “That causes a lack of execution.

“This is a league, man. If you’re not on your screws, it’s gonna get exploited.”

When these defenders were last seen in public, Seattle’s Russell Wilson and co-horts were exploiting the snot out of them with five touchdowns, four on the Seahawks’ final five possessions on their way to 39 points.

“We can’t be giving up 39 points,” said Butler, the first-year defensive coordinator who refuses to finger the secondary specifically for this flash flood of scoring passes. “It’s always a combination, a combination of rush and coverage. It’s rarely one or the other. We have to do a better job of covering, we have to tackle and be where we are supposed to be when we have to be there. We have to coach better and those combinations of things surely end up giving up as many as 39 points.”

You can hope that 39, the worst day for a Steelers defense in more than two years, will be the worst day for this defense for a very long time, but you can’t deny that Butler’s first edition isn’t simply an example of a typical up-and-down season.

Advertise with us

This defense isn’t up-and-down; it’s great-and-awful. It muzzles Arizona and Cincinnati (allowing one touchdown pass to each) and it plays dead for Oakland (four touchdown passes) and Seattle (five).

It’s a good thing it’s not just the secondary.

Or is that a bad thing?

“We all have to play better,” said Butler. “We have to get to the quarterback a little bit better. If you look at that last touchdown pass they had, we were a split-second from getting there on the blitz we ran. We kind of ran the blitz wrong from a couple of guys, and if we ran the blitz right, we would’ve gotten there on that, it wouldn’t have been an issue.”

A big part of the issue isn’t so much what but when. Seven times last Sunday, the Steelers allowed third-down conversions, three of them on third-and-10, two more on third-and-16, and two of those passes went for touchdowns including the play to which Butler referred, a short Wilson throw on a harmless crossing route that Doug Baldwin toted 80 yards for the clinching score.

Advertise with us

It’s in performances like this that the Steelers defense is poisoning the high-production offense that churns reliably on days Ben Roethlisberger is available to run it.

Ben has thrown for 300 or more yards on five occasions this year. His defensive teammates have allowed six, including two by since-benched commodities Johnny Manziel and Colin Kaepernick.

“It takes a split-second, one second of lack of detail, and teams will exploit you,” said Allen, who authored the little detail of looking back at Wilson as Baldwin bolted away from him on the first of his three touchdowns last week. “Every play that you saw in the Seattle game, every play that we’ve been beat, it’s because of lack of detail and concentration. There’s nothing crazy that any team has done to us; it’s all what we’ve done to ourselves.”

You might take some comfort then in that this team shouldn’t have any difficulty focusing on Colts wideout T.Y. Hilton, who last year on this same field averaged better than 25 yards on six catches that would have crushed Mike Tomlin’s team had not Roethlisberger picked that day to throw for 522 yards and six touchdowns.

Ya know, a turnover wouldn’t hurt now and again.

Advertise with us

There were no takeaways last week, and five times in this season’s first 11 games, the Steelers got one turnover or none.

Talk about details.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.