Ed Bouchette: Good afternoon, let's begin

Dude_From_Cali: Ed: Will Cortez Allen be on roster next year with $5.7M salary and $4 dead cap issues pending?

Ed Bouchette: I would be surprised if they would commit that kind of money to a guy who cannot start. It's one thing to sign someone to a big contract but when he fails to produce, you do not want to throw good money after bad. They did it this year, giving him his $3 million roster bonus in March but they really didn't have anyone at the position and figured they'd give him one more year. They won't give him 2, in my opinion.

Dude_From_Cali: Will Mike Adams on roster next year? Passed up lots of big names to pick Adams...

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: First off, will he be healthy enough next year? I'm told his back still isn't good. I would guess not at this point.

Will from Freehold NJ: Good Afternoon Ed, What’s the ideal record to secure a Wild Card berth? 10-6?

Ed Bouchette: I would think 10-6 should do it, but there are no guarantees someone can get hot yet.

Ed Bouchette: I don't think a whiff, but he has not been as dominant as you want from a first-round draft pick in his third season.

BD in Baltimore: Is Alejandro Villanueva improving enough for the Steelers to let Beachum to test free agency or were they going to let it get that far anyway?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: It looked as though they were going to let Beachum test free agency anyway. His knee injury will be a hard sell to others on the open market

Prince: Why didn't Ben just start the game? Seems like another contradiction from Coach Tomlin.

Ed Bouchette: Because it was a better story the way it unfolded.

Taz: Stepping on Landry's foot Gilbert's first mistake all year?

Ed Bouchette: I'm not sure it was his mistake, since he does not have eyes in the back of his head.

Advertise with us

Will from Freehold NJ: Everyone in “Steeler Nation” (including me) wanted Dri Archer gone and I believe a lot of us were happy with the Jacoby Jones signing. To say that Jones has been a disappointment is an understatement. Is it a lack of chemistry or did is he just not good enough anymore?

Ed Bouchette: Let's give the guy more than 2 games. They gave Archer 1 1/2 seasons and he did nothing.

Jud: Now that we're over half way through the season, what's your biggest surprise vs. biggest disappointment?

Ed Bouchette: Biggest surprise is that they are 6-4 with Ben missing four full games and 5 starts and Le'Veon Bell missing 2 full games and Maurkice Pouncey missing the season and Kelvin Beachum most of the season.

Disappointment? It would have to be the early kicking woes of the Steelers that cost them a game or two, even a chance to upset NE in the opener and definitely a loss to Baltimore.

Advertise with us

Little City: Is Jarvis Jones as bad on tape as he looks live at the game? Is this poor coaching or poor drafting?

Ed Bouchette: You assume I look at tape. You assume too much.

Jud: Who do you see as our biggest threat in the remaining schedule?

Ed Bouchette: Cleveland, Jan. 3.

Don't laugh.

Advertise with us

OK, you can laugh.

at Cincinnati, and at Baltimore and at Seattle.

Guest: Now that Pouncey is eligible to come off of 8-week IR, don't they have to activate him or put him on season-ending IR?

Ed Bouchette: No, he can stay on short-term IR as long as it takes. I don't think you will see him again. It's Mike Adams, on PUP, they must make a decision about this week and really there is no decision because he won't play this year.

Troy: Ed, in your years covering the Steelers has there ever been a year with more injuries. Such as going threw 4 QB's and kickers.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Yes, they've gone through 4 QBs recently. Not that many kickers though.

Ed Bouchette: The four QBs came in 2010 -- Roethlisberger, Batch, Dixon, Leftwich

Tship: Ed, Do you think they are pleased with Dupree's development to this point?

Ed Bouchette: Rookie OLBs used to get 1 or 2 years to learn before being thrown into the fray. So, yes, I would think they are pleased so far.

John B.: do you think the ref errors over the past few years has anything to do with just us having more of a view of whats going on or is it that theres so many rules they're just hoping for the best? or is this problem bigger?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Better views, but also I think replay has made some officials hesitant. Bad calls, though, have always been part of sports and the old NFL refs made some doozies too. Also, they had fewer rules to worry about decades ago.

Taz: Not that many kickers? I count 4 - Shuisham, Hartley, Scobee, and now Boswell.

Ed Bouchette: Hello? He asked me if I'd ever seen them go through 4 kickers BEFORE this year. I said no.

Guest: I was surprised to see Chickillo play so many snaps on defense? Are they that high on him, or is that a slam on Jones?

Ed Bouchette: Joey Porter wants to give his guys a breather, which is a reason they rotate. More passes in the game these days means more pass rushes which means more stress on what Mike Tomlin might call the "windage.''

Advertise with us

Dude_From_Cali: Ed: what happened to your legendary Tasmanian chatting speed of 1 question answered per 7 seconds?? It's 4 times slower by my count.

Ed Bouchette: The more we go on, the tougher it is to find a legitimate question to answer. I still can outdraw y'all.

Dude_From_Cali: Cortez's injury on IR is marginal / fanthom or real?

Ed Bouchette: It's real marginal maybe?

Guest: The Bengals are now 8-1 and go to Arizona this week. If they're 8-2 after that, is it so crazy to think the Steelers have a shot at the division?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Steelers need to pay attention to their own stuff. The rest will take care of itself.

Ed Bouchette: However, yeah, it could happen.

West Coast: Ben has had some unbelievable games in his career, but that was something different Sunday. Yeah, it was the Browns, but given all the variables (i.e., injuries to himself, team, no prep, etc.), how would you rate that game among his greatest?

Ed Bouchette: I can't rank it, but as I wrote, it goes down in Ben Roethlisberger lore.

Dude_From_Cali: This SHORTENED kick off is boring to watch. I don't buy the excuse of player safety reason.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Well, why do you think they shortened it then? No, it is all about injury. However, maybe after seeing all of this they'd be better off just flipping the coin and giving the winner the chance to take the ball at the 20 or defend. No kickoffs.

Thad: Hi Ed, great chat as always - can you elaborate on Troy's resentment towards the organization? Is it directed at the team or an individual (Colbert)?

Ed Bouchette: I have not talked to Troy, have not seen Troy. He, of course, did not attend the SB XL reunion over the weekend. From reports and people I've talked to who know Troy, he was not happy with being pushed into "retirement.''

Dude_From_Cali: Why don't guys wear steel plated shoes when 300 lb men are attacking, stomping all game long? Too much logic to work?

Ed Bouchette: You ever try to run in a steel-plated shoe?

Advertise with us

Will from Freehold NJ: Do you think the Steelers should start the backup QB, I think he wears #7, moving forward?

Ed Bouchette: Steelers are 4-0 when they play two QBs this season.

Big City: Was Landry depressed about missing the bulk of the game?

Ed Bouchette: Did not seem to be that at all. he's not that kind of person. He seems always to be upbeat

dave: Why are they letting Jones return punts instead of AB? Are they suddenly concerned about getting him injured?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: It's not like AB has broken any good returns this year.

Dude_From_Cali: It was stupid for NFL to pit Steelers at Pats opening game as banner bait. Steelers are notorious slow starters and the game's tepid, final score proved so. Boring game, IMO.

Ed Bouchette: It was 28-21. Hardly tepid. Hardly boring.

Guest: If that was a playoff game, do you think Ben would have started?

Ed Bouchette: If it were Cincinnati, I think he would have started

Advertise with us

Guest: What did Jacoby Jones show this year that he was better than Dri Archer? Should we bring back DRI!!!?

Ed Bouchette: Give it up. Dri Archer was a wasted draft pick and as I wrote today, the rest of the NFL agrees since no one has signed him.

Troy: How long will Landry Jones be out 3-4 weeks a safe bet?

Ed Bouchette: No, I think he will be the no. 2 QB in Seattle for their next game

Leo: Do you think Hines Ward gets over looked as a Steeler great?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: By whom?

Paul: Do you think Boswell has a chance to keep job next year?

Ed Bouchette: Yes

Guest: If the Steelers fans expect all 1st rounders to be great...How good would the Browns be in even a few of their 1st round picks were great?

Ed Bouchette: If they could have even one of the three QBs they drafted in the first round since the Steelers drafted Ben, they'd be better off.

Panko: Do you think Cowher will ever return to coaching? I feel like that question used to come up all the time and now it's accepted that he's just an analyst.

Ed Bouchette: No, I think Bill has found a gig he really likes and will stick with it and not return to coaching

Spirit Sniper: How bad is Harrison's knee?

Ed Bouchette: I don't think it's bad

Ed Bouchette: Thank you for another great chat. See you next Tuesday.

Follow @EdBouchette on Twitter.