Poll question: Assuming the Broncos, Patriots, Colts and Bengals win their divisions, which two AFC teams will earn wild-card berths?
Chargers and Chiefs ( 9% )
Chargers and Ravens ( 36% )
Ravens and Chiefs ( 0% )
Ravens and Dolphins ( 0% )
Dolphins and Chiefs ( 0% )
Steelers and Dolphins ( 55% )
Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my weekly Steelers chat. Please post your questions and we'll get started soon.
Comment From Carlo
Can you explain the injury settlement situation for me? For example, Shaq Richardson. Can they bring him back this offseason if he is still not signed?
Ray Fittipaldo: I suppose they could, but if they wanted to keep him they would have just kept him on the practice squad/injured reserve. They released him so that tells me they don't want to work with him in the future either.
Comment From Ghostbuster
Can't get off to a fast start with Ben throwing high in first Qtr. Technique? Adrenalin? Nerves? Coaching?
Ray Fittipaldo: Coaching has very little to do with Ben Roethlisberger having an off game when it comes to his throws. It's on him. I'm not absolving anyone of blame, Mike Tomlin included, but for those people who wish to point out his record against sub .500 teams ought to take a look at how the QB played in those games. This team is built to win through its offense and the QB as much as anyone deserves the blame for the losses to the Jets, Bucs and Saints. And please point out how the defense allowed the late score versus the Bucs. The offense left too many points on the field earlier in that game, including Ben missing big plays down the field to Antonio Brown.
Comment From Guest
Been saying this for a while, this team doesn't have the talent to compete for a SB. Trade BR for a couple of 1st rd picks, suck for a season then fire Tomlin and Colbert.
Ray Fittipaldo: This organization does not share your philosophy.
Comment From Lloyd
Was Ike just out of shape from returning from injury or has his coverage skills deteriorated?
Ray Fittipaldo: There are those who will point out that his coverage skills deteriorated last season when he was rated as the worst CB in the league.
Comment From Guest
Why can't we get a defense that does not take 3 years to learn? It might allow this team to turn things around a little faster with the lesser talent we now have.
Ray Fittipaldo: Because that's how the defense operates. It is complicated. I've written stories on the problem. And to be honest with you, no one in the organization seems very concerned about the young guys sitting and learning.
Comment From Southern Steel
Greetings Ray. 20 seconds left in first half, two time outs. Instead of picking up 5-10 yards to make Suisham's attempt a bit easier, two straight end zone shots. Manning and Brayd would work the middle of the field with short passes and use the timeouts. Would you say that clock mismanagement is a frequent theme for Ben and Coach Tomlin?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's not even clock management. That is simply making the correct play and the Steelers failed by going for the big play. Maybe Ben was seeing the defense was not going to be able to hold up, and he thought they needed a TD to end the half. Whatever the case, the coaches need to tell him to get in better position for a FG there.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think the Ravens overall, but they're so bad in the secondary. That's why they're losing. I can see the Ravens finishing 10-6 and second behind Cincinnati. I can also see them losing 63-35 in a wild card game against the Colts.
Comment From Jonah
Who is the best 7-5 team in the Division right now?
Ray Fittipaldo: Question for previous answer
Comment From Guest
If the steelers finished 8-8, will there be any coaching and Mgmt changes? If so, what changes?
Ray Fittipaldo: I could see how the organization would want to make some changes if that happens. That would mean a 1-3 finish when things were set up for a division title if they won them all. I'm not going to guess what those changes might be, but I don't think Mike Tomlin is in jeopardy.
Comment From Scott in Dallas
Is BR really worth $20-25 million per year? I don't think this team can proceed with that kind of commitment and rebuild the Defense. I know the Franchise QB arguement...
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe Ben should take a look around him and do what Brady did and give a hometown discount so he would have more opportunities to win Super Bowls. And judging from his performance this season I would say no to your question. If a QB is going to command $25 million in yearly salary he had better be Brady, Rodgers or Manning-like, and Roethlisberger has not played consistently enough for me warrant that kind of dough.
Comment From Ghostbuster
Retirement decision on the Diesel imminent?
Ray Fittipaldo: Every player in that locker room intimated he was done for the season. He's 36 so I think the logical train of thought is he's likely done for his career. Of course, Stephon Tuitt might not be ready to play next season either, so...
Comment From Scott in Dallas
Time to "unleash hell"?
Ray Fittipaldo: It is Dec. 1.
Comment From ChiTownNate
Hi Ray! Quick comment, I was disappointed with the lack of urgency late in the 3rd quarter when the Steelers were down by three scores. They were running the play clock all the way down when they had at best only 5 possessions left in the game. No hurry up or nothing, they still had a chance in that game. My question, how do you like there playoff chances? I actually still think their chances are good. This lose was to an NFC opponent. Thank you
Ray Fittipaldo: I totally agree with you on the lack of urgency in the third quarter. I thought they shold have gone to the hurry up earlier. As far as the playoffs go, I have seen nothing that suggests to me this team is capable of winning four in a row to close out the season, and I think that's what it will take to get in. I don't even think this team can go 3-1 to get to 10-6 and 10-6 would likely be a situation where they'd have to get in via a tiebreaker.
Comment From Dude_From_Cali
what are the odds when both CB's & both SAFETIES are lame ducks in the same team same year roster. Time to clean house, cater BBQ ribs for retirement parties.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Ike is done after this year. Troy could be. William Gay had a bad day yesterday, but he's been pretty good all year. And Mike Mitchell hasn't been very good, but what's your plan B? Robert Golden? If he was any good they never would have signed Mitchell in the first place.
Comment From mdgirl
I'm tired of holding my tongue about this for so long. It is an incredible liability to have a kicker on a PROFESSIONAL football team whose range is 49 yards. I don't care how accurate he is inside 49. To not have a chance of hitting a field goal outside the 33 (except for 1 fluke) is a complete handicap no other team has to contend with. I know that's not why we lost yesterday, but I can think of at least 4 games we lost over the last 2 season because of this. Other teams have him pegged too
Ray Fittipaldo: Suisham missed that FG because of a bad snap and bad hold. He is capable of hitting from beyond 50. Maybe not as consistently as others but he has that capability.
Comment From Steve
Bottom line seems to be that the Steelers just aren't that good. Who should (or may) take responsibility for the lack of talent & scheme that we've seen over the past three years?
Ray Fittipaldo: There is plenty of blame to go around. Everyone knows about the 2008 and 2009 drafts. That's killing this team right now. They are trying to overcome that.
Comment From Guest
We all know the talent on defense is not there, is this more a defensive philosophy that needs to be changed or are we stuck with the 3-4 pressure from the LB's philosophy? Thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: They have drafted with scheme in mind in recent years and it's not easy to change schemes when you do that. Look at what Tennessee is doing this year going from a 4-3 to a 3-4 and the struggles the Titans have had. I just think it's a lack of talent at the positions that have to be strong in that defense -- OLB and NG.
Comment From JPRNY
Can Thomas was consistently push back at the point of attack or ran out of the play. As a nose tackle he can't anchor. At what point do the Steelers let McCullers play 20-25 snaps and see how he holds up. Certainly can't be any worse than yesterday.
Ray Fittipaldo: No arguments here. But I am guessing McCullers has not showed the type of consistency they would like at that position. But I'm like you. I just don;t see how things can get much worse.
Comment From Guest
Ray, why are they choosing to not use Dri Archer at all?
Ray Fittipaldo: Did you see him carry on that second-and-1 near midfield yesterday? He got picked up and thrown back 5 yards like he was a rag doll. Perhaps, it's just that he's not any good.
Comment From Guest
Darius H-B has had more chances than Limas Sweed at this point. Any reason why they keep giving him a helmet and keep letting bad things happen by forcing him the ball?
Ray Fittipaldo: I can't come up with one
Comment From Guest
What did the Steelers brass see in Cam Thomas? He is terrible and was demoted last year in San Diego. Why would they think he would perform any better in Pittsburgh?
Ray Fittipaldo: He was a cheap, stop-gap measure. The Steelers needed Stephon Tuitt to come on and be good as a rookie. That did not happen.
Comment From Guest
Did Pittsburgh waste a 3rd round draft pick on Archer? Seems a waste with him not getting any snaps.
Ray Fittipaldo: Don't forget they admitted they drafted him with special teams in mind. Then we find out in training camp he is not capable of returning punts. And we find out a few games into the season he is not capable of returning kickoffs. Maybe they should try him at gunner.
Ray Fittipaldo: Or personal protector.
Comment From steelmann58
Ray this team needs a playmaker OLB and CB or S come draft time?
Ray Fittipaldo: They don't draft CBs high unless they believe he is a perfect fit for their scheme. And they haven't done that since 1997 so don;t hold your breath on that one. I agree with you on OLBs. It's unfortunate that Jarvis Jones was injured this year. I'm not convinced he was going to be the next James Harrison, but at least they would have a better idea about him.
Comment From Eddie Haddad
Mike Tomlin made his bones as a D-backs coach. The Steelers DBs stink. Their evaluation of D-Back talent stinks. His fault? There is zero development of defensive talent back there
Ray Fittipaldo: What do you expect when the players who are playing are free agents no one else wanted? We can go down the roster. Brice McCain was cut by the Texans after last season. Antwon Blake was cut by the Jaguars last season before the Steelers picked him up. William Gay was cut by the Cardinals. It's not like they're investing high draft picks in the secondary. I'm not absolving Mike Tomlin or Carnell Lake of blame. I'm just stating the facts.
Comment From steelmann58
Ray if this team fails to win another game will it cost Tomlin
Ray Fittipaldo: That would mean five consecutive losses and a 7-9 record. That's an interesting question, but I don't think it will happen because the Steelers will do what they always do -- rise up and beat the Bengals this week and then fall flat on their faces in Atlanta.
Comment From Derek
Your prediction on our record the remaining games and do we get in the playoffs?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'll say 2-2 to finish 9-7. No playoffs.
Comment From Chaz
How big a disaster has the Mike Mitchell signing been? Also, I know they guaranteed him 5 million on a 5 year/25 million contract. Since that's five million per year average, can they cut him without much of a cap hit?
Ray Fittipaldo: They can cut him after the season without it being a terrible cap hit. I don't think they'll do it, but they do have that option.
Comment From Fr. Joseph Hadgkiss
Raymond, the play of Cameron Thomas makes me want to vomit. Are the Steelers telling their fans that Josh Mauro and Nick Williams sucked MORE than him?
Ray Fittipaldo: Josh Mauro started his second consecutive game for the first-place Arizona Cardinals yesterday.
Comment From Kirby
Looks like sweeping the Bengals is a must now. Will the front office ever truly fix this defense?
Ray Fittipaldo: They've been trying. They used their first two picks on a linebacker and a defensive lineman who haven't contributed very much. Ryan Shazier has been injured and Stephon Tuitt cannot get on the field.
Comment From Scott in Dallas
Does BR seem like he is a team first guy that would "settle" for less? Early in his career I would have said NO. He keeps saying it is about the SB's but he also has hinted at how he is underpaid as well.
Ray Fittipaldo: It depends if he truly wants to compete for Super Bowls over the final years he has left. Look at the problems the Ravens are having after they paid Flacco. Like Roethlisberger, the talent around him is lacking. I'm not saying he has to play for $15 million a year. Just take less to give the team a chance to win.
Comment From Guest
What's the likely strategy for moving on without Kiesel? Hemer from the PS, someone from outside the organization, or hope Thomas, Tuitt, etc. can hold down the fort?
Ray Fittipaldo: I am guessing Hemer gets the call up to the active roster and that Tuitt gets more snaps.
Comment From Donald
If you were Steelers GM this offseason, what position would you select in the first round and who would you select?
Ray Fittipaldo: Too early to say who, but it's obvious this team needs some play makers on defense. You're pretty much set on offense. It's up to the QB to play consistently. The only position on offense that I would address in the first two rounds are a pass-catching tight end and maybe a left guard or left tackle. And I'm not even sure I would pull the trigger on those positions in the first round.
Comment From JamesinNYC
Chargers and the Steelers? Chargers look pretty darn good, maybe a home field advantage behind Denver. What is the prognosis with Shazier?
Ray Fittipaldo: Shazier practiced last week, but he spent more time on the scout team than with the 1s. I think they'll try to get him more involved this week. I'm not convinced they think they're better with him in there though.
Comment From Guest
Do you agree the Steelers need 2 players who can pass rush and should consider free agency or should they wait 2-3 years to develop someone? Is this the priority need on defense?
Ray Fittipaldo: They won't have the salary cap space to sign a big-time pass rusher unless a bunch of guys retire or are released. Plus, that's not their M.O. They drafted Jones and they'll try to develop him.
Comment From Franco
Do you think there's even an inkling in the Rooney's mind about changing front office and Coach or is that a moot point?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think they have that inclination this year.
Comment From Zack
Would you sign a FA vet like Carriker to play DE or bring up Joe Kruger or whomever from the PS?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they'll go the practice squad route. If they go outside and get a free agent for four games it will speak poorly of Tuitt.
Comment From steelmann58
Ray it seems like if Ben does not have a good game the steelers can't win
Ray Fittipaldo: I would say that's an accurate statement. That's the way this team is built. You have the QB, the top-flight WR, the top flight RB, an O-line with high draft picks all over the place. They should be able to outscore teams and win. They haven't done that consistently enough and the blame goes on the QB first and foremost in many of those losses.
Comment From steelmann58
Ray did Brett sign a 2 year deal or is this injury his final straw for the veteran.
Ray Fittipaldo: He signed a two-year deal but the salary cap hit would be minimal if they wanted to move on. I think it's something like $250,000 in dead money if they release him.
Comment From Brub
Is Mike Tomlin a 4-3 Tampa 2 guy at heart that is forced into running the 3-4? I know the D has been very good in his tenure, but when LeBeau hangs it up, do you think a 4-3 is in order?
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin has been on record saying he likes the flexibility of the 3-4 when it comes to defending many of the multi-threat QBs that populate the league.
Comment From Rag Doll
Tomlin said he didn't know how Ben's wrist injury affected his throwing. Is he more than a spectator on the sideline"
Ray Fittipaldo: Ben was high on his throws before he hit his hand. He was asked after the game if it was the reason for his play. He said no. I believe him.
Comment From Scott in Dallas
Aside from the 12 TD's in 2 games our offensive output has been pretty blah from a scoring perspective. What is to blame for the poor performance in TD efficiency? Play Calling? Execution?
Ray Fittipaldo: Both. The execution has not been consistent from anyone in that offense, all 11 guys. And you can cherry pick certain play calls all the time. I'm sure it's a little of both.
Comment From cain
Ray how come no one blames the GM?
Ray Fittipaldo: Kevin Colbert has been called out for some of his recent drafts. He also has the equity in place having built a team that went to three Super Bowls in a six-year span and won two of them.
Comment From Jeffrey
Do you believe the weak pass rush is over exposing the weak secondary? And has anyone else noticed other team bully the Steelers and they take it. Joey Porter would have never allowed some of the things that are going on now.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, the pass rush is letting down the secondary. We can point out all we want how the coverage skills of Taylor and others leave a lot to be desired, but this defense does not work without a pair of pass rushers on the outside who apply pressure to QBs. The Steelers don't have that.
Comment From steelmann58
Ray do we sweep Cinny and part two will the network flex to a later 4pm start on dec 28
Ray Fittipaldo: No and maybe if the game has playoff implications.
Comment From Ralph Berlin
Big coaching changes for the Steelers in the off-season? I think Tomlin is safe...Thinking changes in OC DC and Special teams are needed.
Ray Fittipaldo: Depends how the team finishes of course. They've tried different offensive coordinators and special teams coaches under Tomlin. The talent is in place on offense in my opinion. They just have to have to figure out a way to get the QB to play consistently.
Comment From cain
Ray honest question can we win out?
Ray Fittipaldo: They haven't won four in a row all year so I'm saying no.
Comment From Hank
Straight up trade: Ben Roethlisberger for Tyrann Matheiu, a No. 1 and and No. 2 in 2015, as well as a 2016 No. 2 pick
Ray Fittipaldo: I'll pass this along to Colbert.
Comment From DA Rag Doll
Do we have a legitimate # Receiver? Sander was great again.
Ray Fittipaldo: I assume you meant No. 2 WR and the answer is no. Lance Moore played 49 snaps yesterday because I'm assuming the coaches did not like Martavis Bryant dropping another TD pass. Lance Moore playing 49 snaps wreaks of desperation when he averaged 17 snaps a game all season.
Comment From Jimmyo
Big Ben gets a lot of credit for winning 2 superbowls but the first one he was terrible. I believe he had the lowest QB rating of any QB.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, but they got to that Super Bowl because of him.
Comment From Sparks
A lot of needs on this team: defensive line depth, outside LBs, a desperate need for CBs, safeties, a TE to eventually release Heath, and a RB to spell Bell. As inadequate as this team looks now, the near-term future doesn't look any better. Agree?
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you. It's going to be even tougher next season when the Steelers have to play the AFC West and the NFC West. If there was a season to make the playoffs it was this one because of the easy schedule. But they did not take advantage.
Comment From DA Rag Doll
Would you be surprised to see Heath gone next year?
Ray Fittipaldo: Heath still catches the balls that are thrown to him. He's not going to rack up a lot of YAC, but he does enough for this offense. I do think it would be nice to get his future replacement on the roster, preferably someone who can run and force teams to account for a TE.
Comment From NJ Stiller Fan
Ray, would you say the biggest cause of our inconsistency on offense is the lack of a reliable #2 WR? Makes me realize how valuable Sanders/Cotchery were for us last year.
Ray Fittipaldo: It's part of the reason. The O-line has been leaky at times. The QB's play has been inconsistent. It's not just the lack of a bona fide No. 2.
Comment From Jason Olson
The Steelers clock management has been horrible all year. Yesterday trailing 7-6 they could have run the ball down the Saints throat and kicked a field goal to be up 9-7 at the half. Instead they go for it all with about 4 minutes left and end up with an INT and then the Saints go right down to score and make it 14-6. They get the ball back and do not use the time wisely and end up missing a long FG due to a bad snap and hold when they could have used their timeouts and moved the ball a lot closer. Is this Ben or Haley?
Ray Fittipaldo: As I said before, that's not clock management. That was just a bad play by the QB.
Comment From Bruno
AJ Green and Julio Jones against these DB's? Oy and Double Oy.
Comment From Ken
Ben is having a so-so year and defense is toothless. Bottom line. Average team
Comment From GSK
You seem to have given up on Archer after very little chance to prove himself? Why so down on a rookie who hasn't been used properly yet?
Ray Fittipaldo: They've tried him at three different positions -- put returner, kick returner and by force-feeding him snaps at RB. He has had plenty of opportunity to show what he can do. He hasn't done anything.
Comment From GSK
I wouldn't place too much emphasis in what division is going to be good or bad next year. Look at the NFC South this year...no one would have predicted that.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah but I have a hard time seeing how all of those teams could get bad over one offseason. The AFC West has three teams that are 7-5 or better. The same with the NFC West. One or two of them might fall off a tad but not all of them.
Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for all the questions this week. We'll do it again next week after the Bengals game.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.