The AFC North is the only division in the NFL that has four teams with winning records. A half game is all that separates the first-place Cleveland Browns (6-3) and last-place Steelers and Ravens, who own 6-4 records.

It is the first time since 1935 that every team in a division is at least two games over .500 at any point in the season, according to ESPN. Since the NFL went to eight four-team divisions in 2002, no division has produced four teams with winning records.

With a 23-14-1 record through 10 weeks, it owns the best record in the NFL and has been hailed as the best division in the league. But what exactly does being in the best division in the NFL mean come playoff time?

In the 12 years since the NFL went to the new division setup, a team from the best division that year won the Super Bowl four times. The term “best division” can be subjective, so the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette used the overall record of teams from the divisions as the standard.

Advertise with us

The Super Bowl winner came from the best division for the first three years of the new divisional setup — from 2002-04 — but it did not happen again until last season. Tampa Bay, New England (twice) and Seattle are the teams that won after coming out of the best division.

The NFC West last season featured three teams with at least 10 victories and had a 42-22 record, tied for the best record for a division since 2002. Only the St. Louis Rams (7-9) did not have a winning record.

“When you play against playoff-caliber teams it definitely helps you,” veteran Steelers safety Will Allen said. “The Browns are vying for the playoffs just like we are. Baltimore has been in the playoffs every year except for last year. Being in a tougher division brings better competition and it brings a greater preparation for what’s to come.”

But playing in a tough division guarantees nothing.

In 2007, the AFC South also produced a 42-22 record. The Colts (13-3), Jaguars (11-5) and Titans (10-6) all made the playoffs, but none even made it to the conference title game. The Giants ended up winning the Super Bowl out of the NFC East, which was 40-24. In almost any other year, that would have been the best division in the NFL.

Advertise with us

In 2008, the NFC South was 40-24. The Carolina Panthers (12-4) and Atlanta Falcons (11-5) qualified for the playoffs, but each lost their first games. The representative in the Super Bowl that season was 9-7 Arizona. The Cardinals came out of the NFC West, which was 22-42, the worst record for any division since the new setup in 2002.

The Steelers beat the Cardinals in Super Bowl XLIII after coming out of the AFC North, which was 31-33. However, one can argue the AFC North had the two best teams in the NFL that season, or at the very least in the AFC. The Ravens were a No. 6 seed and upset No. 3 seed Miami and No. 1 seed Tennessee to get to the AFC championship against the Steelers.

It begs the question: does the best division have to have four strong teams or simply two that are among the very best?

“I’ve always viewed our division as a tough one no matter what the records have said,” said veteran tight end Heath Miller, who has played in three Super Bowls with the Steelers. “Whoever comes out of our division is prepared to make a run through the playoffs because we’ve played in weather; we’ve played against good defenses. Generally, we’ve played good defense and have had to run the football. Those are all characteristics of playoff teams. No matter what, this year or any other year, the team that comes out of this division is prepared for playoff football.”

Recent history suggests Miller is right. Since 2002, the AFC North has represented the AFC in the Super Bowl four times, tied with the AFC East, which also has four Super Bowl appearances in that time — all by New England. The Colts played in two from the AFC South and the Raiders and Broncos of the AFC West each played in one.

Advertise with us

“I played against the Falcons with [Michael] Vick, against Drew Brees when New Orleans went to the Super [Bowl], some good Carolina teams,” said Allen, who played for the Buccaneers from 204-09 before signing with the Steelers. “The AFC North is just different. It’s always been different. It’s highly competitive. It’s going to be a battle. I really didn’t understand it until I started playing in it.”

The NFL has an unbalanced schedule and an argument can be made records are skewed as a result. For instance, the AFC North this season has the good fortune of playing the NFC South, which is the only division in the league without a team with a winning record. They are a combined 1-7-1 against the AFC North, with the lone victory coming by Tampa Bay against the Steelers. The AFC North also plays every team from the AFC South, which only has one winning team entering the weekend.

The NFC West is 22-14 this season and challenging the AFC North for the best division record. It, by contrast, plays the AFC West, which sports three teams with winning records, and the NFC East, which has two teams with winning records.

Short of a Super Bowl pitting teams from each division, there won’t be an answer this season, but the AFC North does hold an edge in head-to-head matchups in the Super Bowl versus the NFC West. In the past nine years, the AFC North is 3-0 against the NFC West. The Steelers beat the Seahawks and Cardinals and the Ravens beat the 49ers.

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.