From 1966-83, the Dallas Cowboys made the playoffs in 17 of 18 seasons. They won two Super Bowls and played in 10 NFC championships. It was one of the most impressive runs of success for a professional franchise in American sports history.

But nothing lasts forever. Near the end of the run, from 1980-82, the Cowboys lost three consecutive NFC championship games.

"When you do that, you continue to think you can keep doing it," said Gil Brandt, vice president of player personnel for the Cowboys from 1960-89. "I don't think we ever said, 'start over.'?"

And then, without notice, lean years followed. After losing to Washington in the 1982 NFC championship, the Cowboys did not win another playoff game under Hall of Fame coach Tom Landry. When Jerry Jones purchased the Cowboys after the 1988 season, he told Brandt and Landry it was over when he fired them.

Advertise with us

The Cowboys famously bottomed out in 1989 with a 1-15 record, but from that low point came high draft choices, which laid the foundation for what would become a mini-dynasty in the 1990s when the Cowboys won three Super Bowls in a four-year span.

Knowing when to start over is a dilemma for NFL owners. Steelers chairman Dan Rooney and team president Art Rooney II must determine if the Steelers are at the end of an era or merely in a mini-downturn similar to the one the team faced with Bill Cowher from 1998-2000 when it went three consecutive seasons without a playoff appearance.

Since the Steelers' most recent appearance in the playoffs after the 2011 season, they are 19-19. They muddled through 8-8 seasons in 2012 and 2013 and are 3-3 heading into Monday night's prime-time game against Houston.

Reload or rebuild?

The Steelers, like the Cowboys of a generation ago, never want to start over. They were slow to move on from older players when their 1970s dynasty came to an end. That, along with some poor drafts, led to a down cycle for the franchise that produced just four appearances and two playoff victories in the 1980s.

Advertise with us

After Hall of Fame coach Chuck Noll retired following the 1991 season, the Steelers regained their perch near the top of the league. Over a span of 22 seasons under Cowher and Mike Tomlin, the Steelers have made the playoffs 14 times. They have added two more Super Bowl victories and just four years ago played for a chance to win their seventh Lombardi Trophy.

But now they are in no man's land - not good enough to compete for a championship, but not bad enough to select high in the draft.

"We always say we don't rebuild; we reload," said veteran cornerback Ike Taylor, who has been with the team since 2003. "Quietly, we've been rebuilding."

Taylor, 34, is one of six veterans from the 2005 and 2008 teams that won the Super Bowl. Ben Roethlisberger, 32, and Heath Miller, who turns 32 this week, remain as starters on offense. Troy Polamalu, 33, is the only defensive starter left with Taylor injured, but Brett Keisel and James Harrison, both 36, were brought back out of retirement to play in reserve roles this season.

The Steelers view leadership through veteran players as vital toward their efforts of remaining competitive, but younger players must eventually taste success firsthand to get the full effect.

Advertise with us

"We've got a few guys who won championships and they know what it takes," Taylor said. "The past two years we're 8-8. That's not a good feeling. A lot of the young guys, they don't know what it takes. They don't know what it's like to have that confetti come down on you. They don't know what it's like when you have home-field advantage at Heinz Field and the ground is shaking. They don't know what it's like when you pull up at night for a playoff game and you just get chills walking into the locker room because of the atmosphere. We can talk about it until we're blue in the face, but until they get feeling, they won't ever know."

Louis Riddick, a former NFL player and front-office executive with the Redskins and Eagles, also believes there is value in keeping veterans around to lead young players.

"I don't think you can ever totally reset," said Riddick, who was director of pro personnel for the Redskins from 2005-07 and held the same position for the Eagles from 2010-13. "Yes, it's a young man's game, but there are definitely roles for veteran players that are beneficial. I'd prefer for them to be at the signal-caller positions - quarterback, center, inside linebacker and safety - because it's vital to have great leadership at those positions. That's why I can see them keeping Troy around for so long and Ryan [Clark] before him. For any team, great team-building takes place with a mix of younger and older players."

For the Steelers, some of the young players recently drafted have assumed important roles. Others have been slow to develop and others are no longer with the team. The Steelers no longer have any players from the 2008 and 2009 draft classes.

"In drafting, it's not just hitting on players, it's where you're getting them and developing them within the context of your program and how you're utilizing them on game days," said Riddick, who played at Pitt and now works as analyst for ESPN. "The Steelers aren't getting the return on their investments they want.

Advertise with us

"I understand what they are doing. You can see the transformation taking place, on defense in particular. They drafted Ryan Shazier and Stephon Tuitt. They are two building blocks for the future on the first and second level. They added Mike Mitchell to get more speed on the third level. They are following a blueprint, but they're not seeing the results yet. You're not seeing it yet from Tuitt. Shazier has been hurt. Mitchell doesn't look comfortable yet. It's just not coming together yet. It's very frustrating for them. The great teams always find a way to stay competitive and make adjustments along the way."

Brandt, who works as an analyst for NFL.com, said he believes the Steelers made the correct choice to prolong rebuilding because they have a franchise quarterback in Roethlisberger, but he has noticed a downturn in performance from some of the older players.

"It's a cyclical thing," Brandt said. "Guys have gotten older. Polamalu isn't making the plays he used to make. Competitive balance is such that other teams have guys who are playing at 100 percent capacity. If you have guys who are playing at 90 percent capacity, all of a sudden you go from a playoff team to a team that's 8-8."

Different blueprints

It's hard to argue with the formula the Steelers have used over the years. They are the model franchise of the Super Bowl era with more championships than any other team. But as they struggle to regain their footing, they are being bypassed by franchises that have rebuilt in different ways.

Advertise with us

The defending Super Bowl champion Seattle Seahawks got bad before they got good again. They played the Steelers in Super Bowl XL after the 2005 season, but they had four consecutive losing seasons before they became a threat again. They were 4-12, 5-11, 7-9 and 7-9 from 2008-11.

The Seahawks finally made it back to the playoffs in 2012. Last season, everything came together: a 13-3 record and home-field advantage throughout the playoffs, which they rode to their first NFL title.

San Francisco, which has competed in three consecutive NFC championship games, had eight consecutive non-winning seasons before getting back to a championship contender. The 49ers were 46-82 from 2003-10. Since then, they are 40-13, with those three conference title game appearances, and they remain a contender this season.

After Seattle's losing seasons, general manager John Schneider selected five players who have earned Pro Bowl status, including quarterback Russell Wilson, cornerback Richard Sherman, safeties Kam Chancellor and Earl Thomas and offensive lineman Russell Okung. Another Pro Bowl lineman, Max Unger, came in 2009, the year before Schneider took over.

The most interesting aspect of Seattle's rebuild is that only Okung and Thomas were first-round picks. Unger was a second-round pick. Schneider drafted well in the middle and later rounds to form the foundation for his Super Bowl-winning team. Wilson came in the third round and Chancellor and Sherman came in the fifth round. Linebacker Malcolm Smith, the Super Bowl MVP, was taken in the seventh round in 2011.

Advertise with us

"Everyone is doing a much better job in the draft," Brandt said. "It really is unbelievable from top to bottom how close everyone is now. That really does make it harder to win on a consistent basis."

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.