Poll Question: What will the Steelers' record be at the end of the season? Answer #1: 8-8 (Votes: 17.5%) Answer #2: 7-9 (12.5%) Answer #3: 6-10, 5-11 or 4-12 (55%) Answer #4: 3-13 (0%)Answer #5: 9-7 (5%) Answer #6: 10-6 or better (10%)

Rick: Ray, I do not think it is a matter of if Haley will be fired but when. Does he finish the season?

Ray Fittipaldo: If things do not change between now and the end of the season with the offense I agree some changes will be made on the coaching staff. There could be sweeping changes if things completely fall apart. The offense has talent at QB, RB and WR. They have invested lots of $ and high draft choices in offensive linemen. The offense played well toward the end of last year and it was expected to carry the load this season until the defense could come around. That has not happened. If it does not happen soon I think you will see a change, but I'm not someone who advocates change in the middle of a season unless there are major issues between the coach and the players. After the season is when I would expect a change, once again if things do not improve greatly.

BadNewsBearer: In any given game I think it is fair to blame or commend the performance of individual players. However these ongoing problems with redzone performance seem to indicate that the people who hire and develop talent, GM and coaching staff, aren't doing their job very well. Am I wrong?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: It's on everyone: the players for not executing, the coaches for not having the players prepared to execute the game plan or not putting together a good game plan and the GM and scouts for not procuring the talent necessary to compete. I don't know how to divvy up the blame, but when things go awry the way they have gone awry the past three seasons I think it's fair to spread the blame around. I will also remind you that things are cyclical in the NFL. The Steelers had a long run of success from 2004-11. They're going through a down period now, which is normal. I think what stings for ownership is the fact that they are wasting some prime years for Ben Roethlisberger. They have not committed to a total rebuild because they feel like they have a franchise QB and can continue to compete for the playoffs. But they just can't seem to put it together on offense these past three years. As I stated earlier, the cupboard is not bare on offense. Bell, Brown and Roethlisberger form a solid core. They should be much better than what they have shown in the early going this season.

Guest: Not a Haley fan but if you don't have a offensive line you are limited in what you can run. Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: The offensive line was not the problem yesterday in Cleveland. They averaged 4.3 yards per carry. They ran the ball well. For the most part, they protected Roethlisberger well. I think the issues run much deeper than the performance of the offensive line. There seems to be a disconnect between Roethlisberger and his receivers not named Antonio Brown for one thing. Can we at least start there?

Guest: Are you aware of Mike Munchak having experience calling plays?

Ray Fittipaldo: I was discussing that this morning with my colleagues at the PG. I do not believe he does have play-calling experience, but I am not 100 percent sure. I believe he was strictly an offensive line coach before becoming a head coach without directly calling plays. And by the way, I do not believe Randy Fichtner, James Saxon or Richard Mann do either.

Advertise with us

steelmann58: Ray players or coaching or excution the issue

Ray Fittipaldo: As I stated earlier, it's a combination of all three. I refuse to absolve Roethlisberger of blame. He has not played well in recent weeks. He has continually missed open receivers. However, I am not placing all of the blame on him, either. I am starting to wonder if there are any NFL-caliber receivers on the roster other than Antonio Brown. That might be a bit harsh. How does any NFL starting-caliber receivers sound?

Guest: Hi Ray, after yesterday´s poor performance, do you still think we can compete for a playoff spot? It seems that even an 8-8 record is a dream!

Ray Fittipaldo: I said 9-7 before the season, but I don't think that is possible now. I'm starting to wonder if this is a 6-10 team or worse. The only reason I hesitate is many other teams on the schedule are mediocre or bad, too. The Steelers still get to play the Jets, Saints and Falcons. None of them are any good, either.

Guest: I think Tomlin is a decent coach but we're seeing the results of some really bad drafts, especially on the defensive side of the ball. They have had nothing between Timmons and Heyward but drafted punters and QBs in the 4th round and now Dri Archer. It's going to take lots of time to rebuild from those non-performing drafts. As such, do you think that the steelers will do more in FA since they havent been building through the draft?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: They can't because they are up against the cap as it is. They spend to the cap every year. That's one area where there is no hope. There is no magic bullet through free agency because they don't have the money to spend. Complicating matters is the fact that they just spent money on a long-term deal on Cortez Allen, who doesn't look like he's getting much better. They have to hope some of these guys they drafted and are counting on take a step forward and perform better. If they don't, it's going to be a really long playoff drought, i.e. one longer than three years.

Dude_From_Cali: Aging stars, overpaying average talent to big contracts. Injuries... and "other unnamed" reasons are the root cause of Steelers demise. Thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: You just about covered it although I would stop short of blaming injuries. Every NFL team must overcome injuries. Look at the Browns yesterday. Don't make excuses for the Steelers in that realm.

Bill: Besides Timmons, is there ANY starter on defense that is playing "above the line"?

Ray Fittipaldo: No, not really. Heyward steps up and makes a play every now and then, but he's not a Pro Bowler. There are no Pro Bowl-caliber players on this defense. That's a big part of the problem.

Advertise with us

Steve: The conversation based on articles is more centered the lack of talent on the team. But with the inconsistent play , 1 game on 1 off (very off), is it more of a intensity, focus, hunger issue? How can a team that has gone 8-8 the past two seasons not be hungry enough to focus for more than a week?

Ray Fittipaldo: The talent is a big problem on defense. It's not such a big issue on offense when you have Ben, Bell, Brown and some very good offensive linemen. Many teams in the NFL compete for the playoffs by being very good on one side of the ball. The Patriots have done that for the past five or six years. The Steelers probably had to outscore teams to make the playoffs this season, but it's not looking like the offense is going to be able to do anything close to that.

steelmann58: ray will the finally give Bryant a hat if not fr anything else but use in the red zone

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't see how it can hurt to be honest with you. I can think of several players who can be deactivated on game days, starting with Darrius Heyward-Bey.

Jim: It is sad to see LeBeau's defense in such a sorry state. I live in Jacksonville and after the game the playes made comments how predictable the Steeler D was. Is it arrogance on Lebeau's part to think he can do what he used to do when he had more talent?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know if I would call it arrogance, but he is very much a believer in his system. There are so many things that go into this: talent, the complicated nature of the defense, his unwillingness to play younger players, etc. But really what it boils down to is the defense has lost its way when it comes to stooping the run and preventing big plays. It's the basic tenet of his defense, and they've failed miserably in those two things for the past 22 games or so, maybe even longer.

Guest: Try this again. True or false, in the past, Troy would gamble a lot and be out of position and it would not result in a big play frequently because the pass rush was good and Ryan Clark would often know what Troy was doing and cover for him. What we are seeing now, is the result of troy gambling without either of those to cover for him?

Ray Fittipaldo: I honestly do not know the answer to your question. I cannot get inside Troy's head and I don't pretend to understand the intricate and detailed nature of their defense, especially when it comes to Troy's freelancing. However, I will say he's not the player he was four years ago. In a nutshell, he's at the end of his career and he's not making the plays he used to make. That's the bottom line.

steelmann58: Ray how hat is both OC and Dc seats at this point.

Ray Fittipaldo: Temperature rising on both.

Advertise with us

Go FRUSTRATEDS!: Is it time to recognize they we DON'T HAVE to a franchise QB.

Ray Fittipaldo: Ben is not playing well now, but I think there are 22 or so other teams that would love to have him. I still think he's a top 10 QB in the big picture. He's not playing like it now, but it could be much worse. How would you like to be a fan of the Houston Texans and have this bearded Fitzgerald as your stating QB or Tampa bay and Mike Glennon or any number of other journeymen out there?

Guest: Is trying to establish the run with a porous defense a pointless strategy when you're down by 14 points?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think you want to get away from the running game in a 14-3 game. Look at what Cleveland did in the opener. They stuck with the run and they came back. The issue is the red zone offense. It stinks and no one seems to have any answers.

young: Hey Ray! i always like your chat session. Its funny to me how fans here feel like the sky is falling when we lose? do you agree that sometimes players need to be held accountable as much as fan want to hold coaches or coordinators your thoughts please

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Absolutely, players should be held accountable. I mentioned how Ben has not played well most of this season. I mentioned the other receiver beside Brown not stepping up and making plays. It's on them to execute and they haven't done a good enough job of that through six games.

Daniel: I know there's plenty of blame to go around all over the team, but where do you think the biggest fault is? Haley? The talent on D? Tomlin? LeBeau? I'm just without a clue of where to look for things to get fixed.

Ray Fittipaldo: I think people would feel a lot better if it was only one thing. There are several issues that are holding back this team from becoming a contender.

steelmann58: Ray have we seen enough of the Archer experiment to know this was a bad pick @3,and how many mor games is Cam Thomas going to get a hat on Sundays.

Ray Fittipaldo: The Archer pick is looking like a bad pick now, especially since Tomlin and Colbert sat at the podium on draft day and admitted they took him at least in part because of his special teams abilities. He's been terrible on kickoff returns, when the ball is not booted out of the end zone, and he hasn't been able to supplant Brown as the punt returner. Making matters worse, he's doing a fine impersonation of Chris Rainey in the offense. Other than that, it's looking like a fine pick.

Advertise with us

Gus: Ray you seem to be the only media member who clearly sees this team is bereft of talent, how is this Tomlin or LeBeaus fault when Kevin Colbert clearly has blown multiple drafts now? Will colbert ever be accountable?

Ray Fittipaldo: Some of the picks from certain drafts have not worked out. There have been some bad picks, some mediocre picks and not enough quality picks. Having said that, it's hard to find people out there in the NFL who believe Colbert is the main problem. In fact, I talked with a former NFL personnel director today who told me this year's draft is really good. He said Shazier will be a great player and Tuitt will be very good. You just won't see the fruits of that draft this year.

Steve: Whath impact do you believe Joey Porter has had on the linebacking crew? It seems the Steelers have lost the toughness, physicality they always had, even in down years.

Ray Fittipaldo: They don't have the talent at OLB. It's not an issue with coaching. Jason Worilds has under-performed in a contract year. They signed James Harrison out of retirement and Arthur Moats appears to be just a guy.

Doug: I think the organization's belief in "throwaway receivers" is coming back to bite them. I understand letting Mike Wallace leave, but wouldn't Sanders Incontri look pretty good in Steelers uniforms these days? There seems to be a bit of unfounded arrogance in who they let go and who they keep

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I would argue they should have kept Keenan Lewis over Ike Taylor than Sanders over Wheaton, although Wheaton sure is having a tough time lately. There is absolutely no rapport there with Ben. It's hard to watch.

Tbomb75205: Any bright spots from any of the new players, whether rookies of FA? Even if they are small, just looking for something to be pleased about...

Ray Fittipaldo: No bright spots from the Cleveland game. Shazier might practice more and could play vs. Houston though.

steelmann58: Ray does Haley ever like to use Play action or Deep crossers at all. sometimes his playcalling is mind boggling.

Ray Fittipaldo: Good point on the play-action. It's been missing from his offense. Other teams do it so well. It's been interesting to talk with the Steelers and their opponents in recent weeks. I've heard it from both sides. Defenses are playing coverage against Ben, dropping seven guys and not allowing the big play. This says one thing to me: those team's don't think this offense has the ability to drive the field for TDs on a consistent basis. Based on their red-zone performance that's a good strategy. It seems like the offense either shoots itself in the foot with penalties, bad play-calling, missed assignments or some other bad play. If you are those defensive coordinators why do anything else?

Advertise with us

Big City: I have seen the argument presented that the Steelers had to sign Cortez because they had nobody else at the position. But that doesn't make sense; wouldn't it be better to start from scratch than to burn cap space on a guy who isn't good enough?

Ray Fittipaldo: Obviously, they thought he was good enough. His play so far has to worry them. It's looking like it could be a big mistake.

Paul: What is the biggest weakness in the defense? I say it is the safeties. Troy's guessing resulted in 2 TDs yesterday when the game was still close. Mitchell has been a big disappointment.

Ray Fittipaldo: I can name more reasons. The defensive line isn't very good, the outside linebackers can't pass rush and the corners aren't very good either.

Doug: I think there are two very different things in play here. The defense just does not have the talent or has too many older players in addition to That lack of talent. Losing Shazier and Jones for weeks certainly will hinder their development.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, but Shazier will be back soon. Jones is on long-term IR so he won't be eligible to return to the active roster for a while.

Touchdown Joey: Brad Wing had a pretty unimpressive showing in the pre-season, but they never bothered to bring in any competition. Is it too much to say he's been a disaster thus far?

Ray Fittipaldo: Wing has had the misfortune of screwing up at the wrong time. His poor punt vs. Tampa Bay played a big part in that loss. His bobbled snap yesterday gave momentum to the Browns although it's not lose to the top of the list for the reasons they lost yesterday. I mean, if he gets that snap down they lost 31-13 instead of 31-10.

Jim: It seems to me that Pittsburgh started the game yesterday with a ball control game play leaving little time for Cleveland to strike. However, when Pittsburgh got behind, the game plan did not seem to change. Is this team capable of making half time changes based on what doe/doe not work in the first half?

Ray Fittipaldo: If they were going to get back into that game yesterday the offense had to score on its first possession. It did not and the Browns assumed control again after the defense forced a punt on the first series after halftime. I agree with you the reason they lost yesterday was Ben and the WRs could not get on the same page. That, along with the defense giving up an inordinate number of big plays.

Advertise with us

Cold Play: Miller and Ben appear to have lost a ton of mobility. Any chance the find options to offset that. Martavius is another Finesse player, right?

Ray Fittipaldo: You are correct about Ben and Heath. They cannot move the way they once did. They are in their 30s after all. The Steelers could use one of those pass-catching tight ends that everyone else seems to have now. Maybe that's a target for the 2015 draft. Heath has been a consummate pro and helped this team win two Super Bowls. And it's not like he's out there embarrassing himself now. It's just that, like Troy and Ike, he's lost a step and close to the end of his career.

young: Lack of a pass rush have doomed this team do see major shakeups happening to help that?

Ray Fittipaldo: Like what? Signing Howard Jones from the practice squad? They don't have many options.

steelmann58: Ray if the issue is not having enough good players who to blame Colbert or Tomlin?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: They are both to blame. However, I will mention once again that the NFL is cyclical. The Steelers have drafted in the lower or middle part of the first round for years now and other franchises are not screwing up the draft the way they used to. That makes it hard to sustain success.

flump33: After so many years of good records and low draft spots, are the steelers draft pick a result more the result of lower positioning / less talented players available than poor draft choices?

Ray Fittipaldo: It's both. They have been selecting lower int he draft for years, which makes it hard to sustain, but there have been some bad draft picks they would like to have back. Maybe more than anyone could have anticipated. But that's the way it goes sometimes. You don't hit on every single pick you make.

Doug: Let's try this again: I think the Steelers have two different sets of problems. One, The defense does not have enough talent and too many aging stars who are shadows of their former selves. The offense has decent talent , but can't seem to get out of each other's way. The defense is related to drafting, and the offense is related to coaching. Thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think that's a fair assessment, but I would hesitate to say it's all on the offensive coaches. There is disconnect there for some reason. The players deserve some blame, too, but we all know you can't fire all the players, so unless the offense starts to play better Haley should not feel comfortable with his job security

Advertise with us

KMac: Seemed like Wheaton showed a lot of promise early, but has slipped a bit lately. Growing painrs or is he just not that good?

Ray Fittipaldo: That's a good question. He's a third-round pick so you would hope he picks it up. If not, that's another middle-round pick that doesn't look so good.

Guest: Do you think the Steelers will still sign Ben to a big $$ contract extension if they finish 6-10 or worse?

Ray Fittipaldo: Interesting question. I would suspect lots would be discussed if his play does not pick up. That's why the Rooneys pay Colbert and Tomlin a lot of money. They have to figure out if Ben is the problem or if the problem likes within the offensive schemes and play-calling.

Bill: Seems like one of the problems on defense is that it is so complicated that it supposedly takes 3 years to learn - thus thus they don't figure out if they have a bust until much later and then they insist on playing them anyway instead of getting free agents.

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, this is a problem that I have written about extensively. They did draft Shazier and played him right away. I think they know they have to adjust there a little, but it's hard because the defense has been so good to them over the years. That's another decision for Tomlin: have opposing offensive coaches finally figured out LeBeau? Or is it strictly a personnel problem? I suspect it's a combination of both.

Brian H: Why is Cam Thomas still on the team? He's killing his own teammates. Why not give McCullers a shot?

Ray Fittipaldo: Depending on the severity of McLendon's shoulder injury you might see McCullers dress this week.

Cold Play: Cowher and Hines say we have a Finesse offense. Is that a Knock on the coach or the players? What must change?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think it's a shot at everyone -- front office, staff and players.

Touchdown Joey: Ben may still be a top ten quarterback whom 22 teams would love to have, but it's painfully obvious that he's begun a decline, especially for a guy who relied so much on his mobility. Can they really give him another $100M this offseason??

Ray Fittipaldo: That question will loom as long as he continues to play under the line. It's a good question and I don't have the answer now. It will be up to Colbert, Tomlin and the Rooneys to figure it out.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for all your questions this week. We'll do it again next week.